Slashdot Log In
Illumninatus! Author Needs Our Help
Posted by
kdawson
on Wed Oct 04, 2006 06:50 AM
from the magnum-opiate dept.
from the magnum-opiate dept.
Criceratops writes, "Almost every fringe-geek worth their salt has read 'The Illuminatus! Trilogy,' or at least the 'Principia Discordia,' and much of the enlightenment therein came from Robert Anton Wilson. On the eve of 'Xena' being officially named Eris, Douglas Rushkoff's blog reveals that the extremely ill Mr. Wilson can't make his rent. Another testimony to how our society refuses to reward those who enrich it... but not if we can help it!"
This discussion has been archived.
No new comments can be posted.
Illumninatus! Author Needs Our Help
|
Log In/Create an Account
| Top
| 553 comments
| Search Discussion
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
If you send him $5, the fnords won't get you. (Score:5, Insightful)
(http://www.zog.net/ | Last Journal: Friday December 12 2003, @07:21AM)
I don't care what he spends his money on, or why he's in trouble, but this is just one of those little bits of culture, like Snow Crash, Neuromancer, Iain Banks' Culture series and any number of other miscellaneous books that contribute to letting me look at life in a more fun way.
I agree with the guy who said "if a bum asks for money, buy him a sandwich". Where this differs is that here's someone who's actually done something cool and worthwhile and inherently nifty.
Re:If you send him $5, the fnords won't get you. (Score:4, Informative)
(http://www.davidgerard.co.uk/)
Re:If you send him $5, the fnords won't get you. (Score:5, Funny)
(http://www.stileproject.com/ | Last Journal: Friday June 22, @03:09PM)
Re:If you send him $5, the fnords won't get you. (Score:4, Insightful)
(http://bondage.com/)
No, it's just sad that you can't let go of $20 without demanding DNA tests and genealogy charts. For me, the website is plausible enough, and the address and everything makes sense, so I'll take the minor chance that my contribution is going to a scammer, or that it's going to the right guy and that he's choosing to use it for something other than rent. Whatever. If either of those turn out to be the case, I will be neither bitter nor angry; it's $20, FFS.
There's no rational reason why it should be so, but karma definitely exists. Just remember this post when the time comes that you genuinely need some minor assistance and people demand urine samples and documentation from lawyers and truestees. "Wow," you will think. "I was a snotty little kid back then." And you will be right.
-b
Payment for his copyrighted work? (Score:5, Insightful)
(http://www.threesquirrels.com/)
You posted that on Slashdot, where every third post is a complaint about the tyranny of copyright and payment for the use of intellectual property?
How naive.
Re:Payment for his copyrighted work? (Score:5, Insightful)
Personally, if I could Paypal bands/artists/creators directly for their works I enjoy, I would. Heck, I'd probably pay again for the same work down the road in the right setting. In the end, the amount they get from me would be substantially higher than what their distributors pay. But that's just me. Your mileage may vary.
Re:Payment for his copyrighted work? (Score:4, Insightful)
Of course it's not "slashdot" that "hates IP," it's a very noisy, seldom-challenged group of loons that post comments along those lines. The "you shouldn't get to make money later, off of work you did yesterday" crowd is shrill, carping, ridiculous... but also rarely called on what's wrong with their take on things because they also tend to give comfort to people who are too cheap to pay for their entertainment in general.
Personally, if I could Paypal bands/artists/creators directly for their works I enjoy, I would.
And, as is so often pointed out here, you can. Unless the artist has chosen to do business a different way. Most successful/promising ones would rather concentrate on their art, and hire someone to do all of the paperwork, the promotion, the publishing, the legal crap, and so on. Those publishers are sometimes members of a trade association or two, and those trade associations are the pet demons, around here. But people here keep forgetting that many an artists chooses to personally form a studio or a record label so that they can, themselves, help cultivate and promote new talent, and they quickly realize there's a lot to be said for letting a single entity help with their industry representation and other not-about-the-art-itself activities.
So, if you don't like the business decisions that an artist has made (including the media and related DRM-ish stuff that comes with those deals), don't do business with that artist. Couldn't be simpler!
Re:Payment for his copyrighted work? (Score:4, Insightful)
How naive.
You mean the very same slashdot where non-traditional methods of compensating creators are constantly under evalluation and up for debate? Where people recognize that it takes not only time and effort to create something new, but that nothing is ever completely new and that we all stand on the shoulders of the giants who have come before us?
Yes, how naive indeed.
Update to this story - Money raised (Score:5, Informative)
Quoting the man (Score:4, Interesting)
(http://www.caperet.com/ | Last Journal: Friday August 05 2005, @07:18AM)
In other news ... (Score:2, Insightful)
(http://kombat.org/)
If you're looking for sob stories about nice people falling on hard times, there are for more worthy cases than Robert Anton. Why don't you stop by the local Veterans hospital, or contact the Children's Wish Foundation, if you really have money you feel should be used to help others.
Yes, but (Score:5, Insightful)
(http://benambra.org/)
If you're looking to do the most good for the most people per dollar, money invested in, say, vaccine distribution or malaria prevention is always going to outweigh helping anybody living in the West. And that includes US Army veterans and sick kiddies (in fact, the treatment of Western children with life-threatening illnesses is arguably the single most overfunded branch of the medical profession). But it's only human to want to help out those who we feel a connection with in some way. And Mr. Wilson's work has made a connection with many Slashdotters. I'm not among them, I haven't read it. But if, for example, Linus Torvalds or Joss Wheedon turned up destitute on my doorstep, I'd help them out (even though in both cases them ending up destitute would indicate some very poor life decisions), to thank them for what they've given me.
Re:In other news ... (Score:5, Informative)
$23, darling, $23.
Save 2 dollars, and please him even more by showing that you remembered the number.
Ancient Greeks need cash too! (Score:2, Insightful)
(http://www.halley.cc/ed/)
I've heard that the ancient greek civilization has come on hard times too. Since they were the ones who actually created the Eris / Discordia mythology, shouldn't they get a spare dime too? I mean, it's nice to rework some old public domain ideas into a story and copyright it (see Disney), and it's nice to be generous to your fellow man, etc., but I don't get this call to action slashdot article stuff.
I wish it were easier... (Score:2)
Sometimes, it's fairly easy - I prefer to buy CDs at concerts, where a band I already know I like (hey, I did pay for a ticket after all) and possibly some new opening band(s) gets a substantially larger cut of the profit from the sale. Some music and books are also available at the creator's website, particularly if the group or author has a "vanity" label/publisher, and the price is usually comparable to the big-volume retailers.
I don't claim to be a total altruist in the matter, as I do and always will love truly great used book stores (John King's Books in Detroit, anyone?), but in the situation where the price is going to be fairly close (and it often is) from the cheapest method to the one which funnels the most money into the creator's pocket, I'll pay slightly more for the product.
The margin of return to the creator, though, is fairly difficult to pin down in most cases, and where the musicians/authors/etc. know, I appreciate it when they provide that information on their websites.
HUH, Whatever happened (Score:1, Interesting)
So... why can't I just pay some more taxes... (Score:3, Insightful)
(http://www.heresy.com/)
Also, we do value authors - that's why copyrights run out after 25^^50^^75 years so that creators^^^^^large businesses can make money inperpetuity.
Enlightenment Window Manager? (Score:2)
Wrong enlightenment (Score:2)
What is he doing (Score:1)
e17 (Score:1)
about an enlightenment wm release? heck they even used the icon of e1[67]
i'm all for... (Score:1)
(http://www.drunkensailor.org/)
so, i say give your money to him, but do it for the right reasons. if you wouldn't have given it to anyone, than you're a hypocritical a$$hole
Who's fault is it? (Score:2)
(http://www.malti.org/)
No comment.
RAW changed my life. (Score:5, Insightful)
My first exposure to RAW was through the Principia Discordia and the Illuminatus! trilogy, but it was his other books that changed the way I think about a lot of things, Cosmic Trigger and Prometheus Rising especially. Quite honestly, I consider him a great influence, and I suspect there are a lot of others like me. That is why this call for help is meaningful here and elsewhere, and why I'm sending a donation.
Those of you who haven't read any of his work and also feel some sort of strange self-righteous lack of human kindness to the point of telling a terminally ill man to "get a job at Wal-Mart" might do well to never grow old, sick, or widowed.
Good Heart, So What. (Score:1)
testimony blah blah (Score:2)
"Another testimony to how our society refuses to reward those who enrich it."
Society votes with it's wallets, and deems itself insufficiently enriched.
Damn... (Score:3, Insightful)
Discordianism (Score:1)
After having read these post and the article... (Score:5, Insightful)
Some of the post here state that, there are people who are worse off and less well known and perhaps such support would be better directed toward them.
Other post questioned why he was receiving private care when he could go to a state hospital.
These are valid points, no argument from me...largely because I don't know much more about him other than he needs help.
However, I'm having difficulty seeing how it follows that it is "morally wrong" or "hypocritical" to provide assistance to someone when:
1) You know they need the help
2) They have, in some way, help you or otherwise enriched your life in the past
3) Maybe you just simply admire them.
If you are moved to help this guy, do so and don't let anyone here call you a "hypocrite". If you're really curious, perhaps use this to learn more about his particular afflicition. Who knows? Someday there may be a fund in his name for this very purpose.
Lance Armstrong's got the "Livestrong" foundation...I wonder what his would be called?
Is there anyone here who hated the book? (Score:4, Interesting)
(Last Journal: Friday August 24, @08:52PM)
RAW's Life After Death (Score:2)
What the subtitle refers to is the false stories that he was found dead in his home on February 22, 1994 that propagated on the internet and the insights he had from watching the situation unfold [rawilson.com].
I really hope that again the current story is also unfounded. But I am afraid its not, so I will be sending a check.
For all those 'the hippy should gedda job' folks, they might be interested to know that RAW was a (little l) libertarian before it was cool. It fact he was probably one of the seed crystals that fostered the 'coolness' on the internet back in the day.
Also: Former "Playboy Advisor" (Score:2)
(http://www.5sigma.com/joseph)
Schrodinger's Cat and The Trick Top Hat were two of the funnest/funniest books I read in my late teens. The Illuminatus Trilogy didn't do much for me, but I do make jokes about the Dog Star from time to time.
Now, I'm going to go Burger.
The story icon threw me (Score:1)
(http://www.cognitive-dissonance.org/)
I feel I've been wronged in some fashion I can't properly explain.
The Justified Ancients of Mu Mu (Score:2)
(http://ettlz.blogspot.com/ | Last Journal: Sunday February 12 2006, @06:53PM)
Humanity (Score:1)
$23.00 Donated (Score:1)
Despite the fact that I've never met the man, and probably never will, Bob has been a great friend to me. I've received enjoyment from his books, I've taken comfort from his ideas and I've spent many hours pondering his philosophy. Now my friend is in need, so I sent him some cash. Perhaps it wasn't much, but it is an amount I know I can afford and since I'm not the only one who counts him as a friend, it'll be multiplied many times over.
Could my donation have done more good if given to a charity? Perhaps so. But I've made donations to Greenpeace, Amnesty International, The St. Vincent DePaul Society, Second Harvest Food bank and others in the past, and I'll continue making such donations.
Ultimately, though, even if I had made no other charitable donations in my life, I'd probably still have donated to help Bob, just because I value what the man has given me and the world. It's worth it to brown bag it for a few days to be able to help Bob out in this small way. If anyone doesn't like that, tough. They have no say in how I dispense my charitable contributions. I wouldn't try to persuade them to donate to Bob against their wishes, so why should they try to persuade anyone not to donate? That so many have tried to do so strikes me as small minded and mean spirited on their part.
I started reading the Illuminatus! Trilogy a... (Score:1, Flamebait)
(Last Journal: Monday January 06 2003, @10:36PM)
Besides being bad literature it does a terrible job of building up a believable conspiracy theory. This book may have helped create the conspiracy theory genre, but later authors have done so much better with the idea. Even Dan Brown's writing looks good by comparison.
Never read his books, so... (Score:1)
(http://nymphs.org/)
less platitudes, more action (Score:1)
He's a Discordian right? (Score:1)
(http://mrmuskrat.perlmonk.org/)
Choices in life, errr blogs (Score:1)
(http://www.myspace.com/avezes)
I have not read his books, but I kow a lot of people who have. many of them are
There is no reason to get offended by something you CHOSE to read. There is no reason to announce that we dont know this guy (though I am currently basically doign that hehe).
It is a good service to let the people who would want to know that this man needs help. Those of us who have not been influenced by him can A) wonder why so many were and go read his books and maybe join their ranks, B)move on to other more flamable threads like HP eavesdropping, or C) sit here and bitch about something that really has absolutely no effect on us at all.
I think I will mix a little of A and B together myself.
Come on, people! (Score:4, Insightful)
(http://127.0.0.1/)
Email to the Universe? (Score:2)
Illuminati? (Score:2)
(http://crumplertech.net/ | Last Journal: Thursday February 22 2007, @03:50PM)
Look what happened to Nikola Tesla (Score:1)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikola_Tesla [wikipedia.org]
Perhaps the 'nothing to see here' error... (Score:2)
(http://www.rangat.org/rthille | Last Journal: Thursday November 23 2006, @12:20AM)
Sad News (Score:2, Interesting)
(http://kruhft.info/ | Last Journal: Wednesday October 03, @08:12PM)
We live in this time of great wealth for some, but in turn, the creators and artists of our world live in squalor; we appreciate and love the work they create, but refuse to give payment, even when it is asked for in great need for help. I know there comments posted here are from the type of people that generally help those in need; I hope that an 'angel' that has been influenced by RAWs work in the past sees this story, investigates, and can give real help to a man that has touches so many lives and minds. I hope to be one someday, it is just too soon for me to be that way, but I plan on it.
Creators do not deserve untold riches for their works, but they do deserve some treatment so that they can survive into old age comfortably. Artists, by nature, are not the most capable of planners, as intelligent and creative as they are. The need to create often succeeds the desire to plan; some get lucky and live well, others not, as we can see here.
I have never met RAW, and unfortunately, may never get to. But I hope such a brilliant man finds the help that he needs to die in comfort and peace. He deserves that.
fiction, fact or satire? (Score:1, Offtopic)
(http://crashrecovery.org/)
he mixed rare known facts about the Illuminati, with fiction and occasionally added
some jokes. I guess in the heydays of his work he was very popular amongst people
who knew something about this cult.
However things have changed, This Illuminati, Kaballa, Mason stuff has turned out
to be not fiction or satire but the scary truth. Just remember Hugo Chavez's
recent appearance inside the U.N. What happened at the U.N. is of major importance.
Hugo Chavez steals the show at the U.N. quoting from Noam Chomsky latest book
"Hegemony or Survival" [1]. Although wearing a normal suit, he did a almost genuine act
of exorcism from behind the council speakers table:
http://www.niburu.nl/showarticle.php?articleID=143 86 [niburu.nl]
http://www.dailykos.com/comments/2006/9/23/213219/ 005/59#c59 [dailykos.com]
http://www.axisoflogic.com/artman/publish/article_ 23036.shtml [axisoflogic.com]
http://www.counterpunch.org/chavez09202006.html [counterpunch.org]
"The devil is right at home. The devil, the devil himself, is right
in the house.
"And the devil came here yesterday. Yesterday the devil came here.
Right here." [crosses himself] "And it smells of sulfur still today.
Yesterday, ladies and gentlemen, from this rostrum, the president
of the United States, the gentleman to whom I refer as the devil,
came here, talking as if he owned the world. Truly. As the owner of
the world."
The real media file can be found here
"Hugo Chavez, Venezuelan Pres., at U.N. General Assembly"
rtsp://video.c-span.org/project/ter/ter092006_chav ez.rm
Recently Greg Palast did a exclusive interview with Hugo Chavez from
his home in Venezuela
"Hugo Chavez: An Exclusive Interview with Greg Palast"
http://www.gregpalast.com/hugo-chavez-an-exclusive -interview-with-greg-palast [gregpalast.com]
pnm:rm.bbc.net.uk/news/olmedia/1985000/video_19856 70_ven22_palast_vi.rm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/newsnight/ar chive/1985670.stm [bbc.co.uk]
So why is this a important breakthrough? It seems the tide is turning.
If Bushes hegemony was a reality, Hugo Chavez would never been able to
make this speech. Also remember that the President of Iran recently
made his heroic appearance in New York. The crock hunter may have died,
but here's the real hero
http://www.theage.com.au/news/world/iranian-presid ent-steals-the-show-in-new-york/2006/09/22/1158431 902380.html [theage.com.au]
As the plot is folding, the analogy with Tolkiens trilogy, The Lord of
the Rings, is certainly there. "The Evil Eye" on top of the pyramid is
evident. The analogy with the Ring to rule all others Rings may not
seem so straightforward. It seems that this Ring is commonly known as
the holy grail, but the holy grail is a hoax in itself. So what is the
holy grail in fact? Chris Everard from EnigmaTV made a serious attempt
[2] to explain things. He claims that the full knowledge and
understanding of a scripture called The Cabballah is what ordinary man
can give ultimate power with the culmination in power the capability to
kill someone with a
Why do peope continue to think that (Score:2)
(http://slashdot.org/ | Last Journal: Thursday February 21 2002, @04:37PM)
Sheesh.
Now, I hope this man gets they money to live comfortably, and I am always glad to see humans act chartitable, but writing books does not, and should not, garantee income forever.
Yes, I have published stories, poems, and over a million line of code, so I do have an intellectual investment into what I am saying.
Enlightenment? (Score:2)
Spiritual event or window manager? One of them has a familiar symbol [sourceforge.net]...
But, hey, every story needs an icon, right?
Dear Eldavojohn (Score:2)
(http://www2.bc.edu/~bucklesj)
I wish... (Score:2)
(http://slashdot.org/)
I could have donated this auction to him.
He's probably the reason I had the plate to begin with.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ih=
In defense of urban living (yeah, more OT) (Score:2)
(http://obsidianrook.com/ | Last Journal: Tuesday October 16, @01:48AM)
As an original playtester of Illuminati (Score:1)
(http://www.users.qwest.net/~waffleck-asch/ | Last Journal: Wednesday November 07, @04:46PM)
That way, the embedded RFID chips can be used to complete the grand master plan by the Eco-Terrorists (my idea) to illuminate the Tri-fold Druidic Path and transform our society into a better one in which writers and scientists are treated as gods and business owners and politicians are those we have sentenced for serious crimes against society to serve in such positions with subsistence wages.
Church of the Subgenius (Score:1)
(http://thesoffish.blogspot.com/)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:5, Insightful)
(http://slashdot.org/)
Kind of hard to do that when you're housebound and only have a few months to live, y'know.
And where on earth do you get the assumption that he ever refused to work for money?
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1, Insightful)
(Last Journal: Sunday April 22 2007, @01:32PM)
Why should I? Fair play, if I come across one of the guys books, and it looks like something I want to read, then I'll buy it. But the tone of your statement above makes it sound like we owe the guy a favour, and I don't see why that should be the case.
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Insightful)
(http://www.phpgd.com/)
Did you miss the bit where the article says he's extremely ill? I imagine that a shelf-stacking job isn't a viable option.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:5, Insightful)
(http://xybapodcast.blogspot.com/ | Last Journal: Friday December 08 2006, @10:06AM)
I understand discouraging people from replying to spam or supporting terrorism, but to discourage people from helping another person just seems like time wasted on everyones part.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:5, Insightful)
Summary: "the extremely ill Mr. Wilson can't make his rent"
Article: "whose *infirmity* and depleted finances"
Article: "Bob is a human being in a rather painful fleshsuit"
Article: "I refuse for the history books to say he died alone and destitute"
Wikipedia article (which you say you read) depending on when you read it:
Wikipedia: "This author who has changed the lives of many is dying of post polio syndrome"
Wikipedia: "Robert A. Wilson is currently under hospice care at home with friends and family."
RAW himself did not ask for money. A fan of his, however, did. Your high horse died about 2 posts ago, *get off of it*.
Also, you've never once taken a homeless guy into a restaurant. Liar.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:5, Funny)
(Last Journal: Tuesday November 30 2004, @06:34PM)
You seem supremely qualified to comment, sir. I told Emily Dickinson practically the same thing: "Shut up with that emo shit. It's not paying the bills, and they're looking for a girl to do needlepoint in the village." Sadly, she didn't listen to me, and she died poor, alone, and unappreciated.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:3, Informative)
Perhaps you missed the part where he is 74 years old and extremely ill?
I also would like to know more about the why and how he got into his situation, but your comment really seems to be far over the top. Not everybody who is poor is "refusing to do actual work".
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:2)
(http://simeonband.org/)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Insightful)
That said, authors don't have much of a guild. I'd be surprised if they had a group insurance plan. Bob Wilson was crippled with polio as a child, and though he was able to overcome it for years, he also was subject to recurrence (of muscular weakness, not of polio). If he's now both old and sick, he probably can't walk. I'd be surprised if he was insurable for this problem, as it's
OTOH, a good health plan is contractually obligated to NOT drop you. Such exist. The good ones seem to do reasonably good jobs. (And hospitalization is STILL expensive.)
As for his savings...Bob's books may have sold well for a long period of time, but he was never at the top of the charts. He's never been wealthy, and often lived very near the edge. I'd be surprised if he had any savings. (I'm also fairly certain that the finances would have been managed by his wife, Arlen, who's been dead for years. Also a writer, "relatively successful" [i.e., she's been published in places that paid money, but I don't think enough to live on].)
Writers, painters, musicians...all of these can expect to end life as paupers...if they're lucky. There are exceptions, but that's what they should expect. If Bob was local I'd want to offer him a room and meals. I don't know if I'd be able to, but I'd want to. Unfortunately, he moved away decades ago, and I've lost track of him.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Informative)
(http://miyakohouou.dyndns.org/ | Last Journal: Thursday October 07 2004, @01:15AM)
Basically, medical insurance in theory is supposed to help protect you in the case that you have a bunch of medical bills. In practice what actually happens is that insurance companies either require deductables on the order of thousands of dollars per procedure (where every tiny thing is it's own procedure) or they simply don't cover very much.
Furthermore, unless you're extraordinarily healthy, once you get past a certain age it can be very difficult to get health insurance at all, because insurance companies are afraid you might actually use their services.
Finally on that note, even crappy insurance is extremely expensive- and unless you work for a company who helps pay for it, or are rich, you can't afford health care.
Now, for people who don't have health care, there is Medicaid and Medicare. These are basically government insurance. The problem is that over the last several years they have been gutted to the point where they are even more impotent than they used to be.
Whether you have Medicare or Medicaid or some insurance plan, the bills quickly add up and people are usually left in a situation where they can't afford any more medical treatment. From there the options depend basically on what exactly the person is dying of.
If you get shot/stabbed/dismemebered/etc. Then basically you can walk into any hospital in the US and they are required to give you "stabalizing treatment" - which basically amounts to stopping you from bleeding to death before they take your billing information. For people dying of long term terminal diseases (e.g. cancer, organ failure, etc.) then there are free hospitals. The idea is that when you go to one of these hospitals they take as much as they can get from you, and leave it at that. Of course these hospitals also generally have abysmal quality, so nobody who can afford to pay any medical bills goes to them, so they never get new equipment/have the budget to hire good doctors/etc. This makes a viscous sort of cycle. These also tend to be in rather bad areas in the bigger cities- they mainly serve to tread drug overdoses and gunshot wounds. If you live in a small town and need to get to a hosptial like this- too bad.
Your other choice aside from the free hospital is to go to a hospital that is equipped to give you some of the best medical care in the world, but it basically involves liquidating all of your assets and turning them over to the hospital, then getting as much on credit as you can, then when you have no more to give they cut you off of treatment and transfer you to the free hospital. These hospitals generally aren't equipped to keep up the level of treatment you've been getting, so at this point generally they dope you up on pain killers and let you die.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:5, Insightful)
People continually moan about the state of the NHS, but it's safe to say I'd rather become ill here in the UK than over there in the USA.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Insightful)
(http://66.249.93.104/ | Last Journal: Monday November 20 2006, @09:27AM)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:5, Insightful)
1) It is extremely important to distinguish between employer-provided insurance and privately-purchased insurance. The theoretical purpose of medical insurance is not, as you say, to protect you in case of a large number of bills. It is to pool risk and collect enough money from each insured to cover the cost and a bit of rake-off for the insurer. The purpose of medical insurance *companies* is to make as much money as possible. Therein lies the rub.
Employer-provided insurance tends to be pretty good. Most people work for large companies and these companies use their bulk purchasing power to get something very close to this risk-pooling arrangement. People trying to buy insurance on their own, however, are completely at the mercy of insurance companies. They will face possibly ruinous exclusions, especially the nebulous "pre-existing condition", and a great many hurdles. The insurance companies work hard (which is expensive) to find reasons not to pay the claims of these people.
2) The long-term problem is a bit similar. If you work for a long time for a large company, you are generally well covered until Medicare (*not* Medicaid) kicks in. Increased worker mobility (i.e. decreased job security) makes the insurance problem greater.
3) Medicare hasn't been gutted (though there was a debacle recently with the new PHARMA welfare act, err, new drug benefit) because it is for old people and old people vote. Medicaid has always been pretty crappy because it is for poor people.
4) The US already has a decent program in Medicare and a very good program in the Veteran's Administration Hospitals. However, expanding these programs to universal coverage is politically impossible at the moment.
Even the mediocre NHS is far better (even Canada's crappy system is better though France's system may be best of all) from a coverage per dollar standpoint. The administrative costs associated with the US system are extreme and provide no medical benefit to anyone.
I remain convinced that the US will eventually embrace single-payer under a less corrupt Republican administration (a Nixon-to-China moment if you will) when big business republicans realize they cannot afford it any longer and faux libertarian (that's a bit of snark since I don't believe there are any *real*, i.e. uniformly consistent, libertarians) entrepreneur types realize that the dangers of leaving a job and foregoing insurance can make entrepreneurship far too risky. (I'm not entrepreneurially inclined but if I were, I'd worry a lot less about losing my house since I could always go back to the rat race and rent than losing my insurance since I might get cancer while uninsured and simply die).
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Insightful)
Can anyone explain how your country works in this regard?
As difficult as it is for those of us in less barbaric countries to imagine, you are indeed hung out to dry if your health insurance runs out, and it's only good up to a point. Usually the limit is up to a specific dollar value - or covers treating a given illness for a limited time span. The maximum amount a policy covers it varies depending on the premium you are willing to pay / can afford each month.
Where the system falls down is when someone has a serious long term illness, such as Cancer, and the treatment works, you can easily end up running out of insurance cover 2 or 3 years down the road. When that happens, you have to sell all your possessions (house, car, TV) to pay for the drugs (which are really expensive - often hundreds of USD worth a month). When the money ultimately runs out, and you are lying bed ridden, flat broke in low rent accommodation - having been forced to sell all of your valuable possessions just to stay alive - you simply stop getting the medication you've been getting and you are left to succumb to the illness (that is, to die).
If you have a partner, then they are left with nothing when you die - not even the house you used to live in (because you'll have used up all the money from the life insurance pay out that would already have been made when your condition was diagnosed on the medication you needed to keep you alive), making it a double tragedy for them. I don't know how someone is supposed to get their life back together after something like that.
"Emergency rooms" are required to treat all patients brought in (regardless of insurance or ability to pay), so when you are at the final stage of your illness at deaths door (days, or hours before the end) they will give you medication to control the pain, but that's the extent of the free treatment available (and you / your partner will still get a hefty bill for any services rendered, they just can't - by law - refuse to treat you even if they know for sure you can't pay it).
Scary stuff.
Such is the price people seem willing to pay in return for lower taxation and greater spending power at the checkout.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Insightful)
The well off person who has millions in the bank to cover all medical eventalities has likely been fortunate enough to have been born with a skill that has enabled them to obtain that money.
Funny. Statistically speaking, the well off person was born into a family that is well off. The secret to wealth is to be born to rich parents, then, since you have money, the money condensation principal kicks in. You can just loan money to those who were born poorer and collect interest.
I've been in tears since this thread started and the thought that America can stand by at let its citizens die sends shivers down my spine.
While the stated goal of pretty much any government program, or lack thereof, is to make people's lives better, we all enter into that with a lot of preconceptions and principals. Americans are predisposed towards independence and each person taking care of themselves. This is reflected in our lack of socialism and in our stance on drugs and firearms. Much of Europe is more predisposed towards placing responsibility on a central authority as is reflected in their beliefs about those same topics. Neither is optimal for quality of life, but it is pretty obvious that overall, Western Europe is closer to the ideal.
If you want to hear some scary numbers take a look at the number of Americans that are financially ruined by medical expenses. I think the last time I heard it was something like 50% of all personal bankruptcies were due to a medical problem.
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:2)
O, Discordia!
Can I buy his book? (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:4, Informative)
(http://hype.be/)
The general deal is that he's suffering from the more morbid symptoms of post-polio syndrome, can't really walk, has trouble swallowing, and is extremely frail. He has friends serving as fulltime nurses and aids, but doesn't have family capable of providing support. The IRS and medical bills have also worked against his solvency.
Try getting a job with those symptons
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1, Interesting)
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:2, Insightful)
He was paralyzed by polio. Try keeping your job and your insurance when you can't even move. I know we have the medical leave act, but I think "I need medical leave for the rest of my life" doesn't count. Even if he had insurance on his own, they'd have almost certainly raised his premium until he was forced to drop it, and if not, he probably hit that 1-2 million dollar lifetime maximum pretty quick by the time he got to 74. Too bad his family isn't rich, the Republicans would be all over it, as long as they weren't the ones that'd have to pay to keep him alive.
It's interesting though. I got a letter from social security telling me that if I became completely disabled today, I'd receive a whopping $160 a month to live off of. The drugs that keep MS from eating my brain cost roughly $20000 a year, and are fortunately covered by my insurance. It certainly would have been a pleasant surprise to discover that the Republicans were actually serious about this "compassionate conservative" thing, but I think it's pretty clear now that they're just full of bullshit.
"Compassionate Conservativism" (Score:5, Funny)
(Last Journal: Monday November 14 2005, @11:24AM)
After driving a ways, the man asks the CC "So where are we going? Do you know where I can find work?" to which the CC laughs, and says "Oh no heh, I dont have a lawn mower, and the grass is much taller in my yard."
They never understand.
Re:If you're going to donate money... (Score:2, Informative)
According to Bob's own website the account is his personal PayPal account.
KFG
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:2)
(Last Journal: Monday November 14 2005, @11:24AM)
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:2)
(http://www.alexandergieg.org/)
As a result, there would be a lot more houses available, driving their prices even further down. And as a secondary result, the monthly house-renting prices would be a lot lower too. All those people who can't currently afford renting a house would afford them, including the cheap-laborers mentioned above.
And this includes Mr. Wilson.
Re:Scam? (Score:1)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:1)
(http://go.away/)
You don't get invited to too many parties, do you...
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:4, Insightful)
(http://slashdot.org/)
>So, I have a job and insurance, because I don't want to be like this guy.
Trust me, there's no risk you'll ever be like that guy.
Hail Eris!
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:1)
(Last Journal: Wednesday February 25 2004, @11:29AM)
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:2)
(http://www.ihoz.com)
Re:I Don't Know, Man (Score:1)
Instead of sending him money why not buy one of his books. He should get royalities from that right?
P.S. I haven't read any of his books and doubt I will so I can't say if you're missing out on anything or not.
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1)
(http://www.infamous.net/)
Buying books is fine, but by the time he gets the tiny royalty from that he'll be dead. And the tiny royalty from a book purchase doesnt't reflect the value received from reading a mind-altering work like Cosmic Trigger.
So send money now. Buy books later.
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1)
(http://www.infamous.net/)
Plenty of people have bought his books over the years. Wilson is a well-known author and speaker [rawilson.com]:
If you don't know, or don't like, his work, fine. That's your problem. Go read some other story. But his work is well known among theRe:I Don't Know, Man (Score:1)
But instead of sending him money, I'd rather send him a letter advising him on how to live a better life throw a steady income job.
RTFA, Jerk. Maybe you can send him a letter advising him "not to die from Post-Polio Syndrome", or not to waste all of his money on needed medical treatment, or maybe you can tell him how it is his own fault for being silly enough to contract Polio (before there was a vaccination for it) in the first place.
Or maybe you could forget the Neocon ideology that holds that everyone in trouble is there because of their own failings. That's just an excuse NOT to care.
And just maybe you could spend a bit of time helping your fellow man rather than preaching at him.
Re:There used to be this guy (Score:1)
(Last Journal: Friday June 11 2004, @11:15AM)
But that was because he was an idiot. Not because he was unsuccesful.
You do what you want, we'll do what we want (Score:3, Insightful)
(Last Journal: Tuesday August 07, @01:18PM)
Okay, enough sarcasm. Here's the deal. We live in a free country. You are free not to help this man. But we are free to call you an asshole to your face. You can't shut us up. You can feel motivated not to help when someone asks for money, and the rest of us will feel motivated to point at you and say, "Look at the poor crippled human, isn't it pathetic, it lacks empathy and compassion and it lives in a hell of its own making because it can not connect with other human beings on a deep and meaningful level. How sad. Glad I'm not like that."
I met Robert Anton Wilson at a conference I was helping give a presentation for in 2000, called Disinfocon. It was put on by disinfo.com, "The yahoo of the weird and unusual." He is a very nice person, very smart, and his books are not garbage. He gave a presentation on the book "Saharasia," by James DeMeo, a student of Wilhelm Reich, which explains the origins of human violence. Very interesting.
You seem to think that because he is poor now, his books must not of sold well. They were on the NY Times best seller list. They are very popular, and every real geek I've ever met has read them. Even if you have not read his books, if you have read any books in the last thirty years chances are you read someone who was deeply influenced by his writings.
I'm truly sad for you. You are obviously missing something which most of the rest of us find to be one of the most important parts of being human. If sharing compassion and empathy were as easy as sharing money, I would give you some of mine.
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1)
(http://davecheatham.com/)
You don't even know who RAW is, aren't you?
Okay, here goes: RAW writes books that do, indeed, sell. I own four of them. The Illumninatus! trilogy is the second book on the bibliography of the Hacker's Jargon file. His Schrödinger's Cat trilogy has been called the first quantum sci-fi novel.
His books referenced Buckminister Fuller, Timothy Leary, James Joyce, Aleister Crowley, and Alfred Korzybski, either as geiuses or complete lunatics depending on different character's moods. He's one of the most psychologically aware sci-fi writers, often describing people's 'programming' and 'reality tunnels'.
Frankly, if you don't know who RAW is, I have to question what the hell you're doing posting on slashdot.
So, considering he was a successful writer, or at least as successful as they come, and they won't sell you private insurance if you have post-polio, what exactly should he have done to pay his medical bills?
Re:Cue all the anarcho-capitalists.... (Score:1)
(http://davecheatham.com/)
Yeah! Luckily, only well-known writer need help in paying their medical bills. There can't possibly be anyone out there in the same situtation who can't appeal to slashdot because he spent his live paving roads that hundreds of thousands of people use every day.