Subliminal Spam Using an Animated GIF 216
JohnGrahamCumming writes "Everyone's noticed the recent flood of image spam (including the SpamAssassin developers who are working on an OCR-extension to beat it), but take a look at this spam containing a subliminal message flashed every 17 seconds to try to entice you to buy the stock being pumped. Does this work? Warning: link shows the actual spam; don't blame me if you lose money on this stock!"
That's ridiculous. (Score:5, Funny)
A little history is in order here. (Score:5, Interesting)
BillyDoc
Re: (Score:2)
Thank goodness I set camino to only play anim gifs once. It stops on the 'buy' part of the image. The real suckers would be anyone who paid to build/send such a message. Somewhere there's a photoshop jockey laughing all the way to the bank.
Subliminal messages (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
There is a lot of subliminal messages in advertising, especially on TV. Given our consumerist culture, i'd say it's working fairly well.
Oblig. Simpsons Quote (Score:5, Funny)
Smash: It's a three-pronged attack. Subliminal, liminal, and superliminal.
Lisa: Superliminal?
Smash: I'll show you. [opens the window, and shouts at Lenny and Carl, who are standing on the corner] Hey, you! Join the Navy! Carl: Uh, yeah, all right.
Lenny: I'm in.
Must... buy.... (Score:4, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Also Doesn't Work (Wikipedia) (Score:3, Informative)
If subliminal messages had any significant effect we would know about it. They've been trying for years.
There have been interesting claims at subliminal messages in popular music. KAKE-TV in Wichita, Kansas, used a subliminal message to attempt catch the BTK killer, but it had no perceptible effect.
I'd
Re:Also Doesn't Work (Wikipedia) (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Gee, I always thought that if they were working properly we wouldn't know it...
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
I don't buy the study, though. The geographical split is likely very significant here. There's good evidence that people decide these things based on what they feel at the time, and there's also good evidence showing that people's self-statements of happiness are influenced by where they live. Without a control group, the results are pretty mea
Re: (Score:2)
Somebody call Edison Carter.
And get that little twerp Bryce in here. I want a word with him.
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
Nope. (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Nope. (Score:4, Insightful)
It worked though - even though the original article is slashdotted all of the images have been reproduced here. The spammers must be laughing all the way to the bank...
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Except.... (Score:5, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I occasionally design animated gif web banners and I've emailed them to clients for approval from Outlook to Outlook, and they've shown up (animated) just fine. Last time was all of a couple of months ago.
That's Outlook 2000 (I think). I know 2003 removed automatic display of images, perhaps that's what you're thinking of, but at any rate that's all images, animated or otherwise.
Well... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
The key is, they don't pay for those resources. They use some sort of a "bot-net" to send the mail - "zombie" computers, often on residential broadband connections which have been contaminated with some virus (or something virus-like, trojan, backdoor, et cetera - the spec
Bah (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Bah (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
stuff aNd nOnsense (Score:2)
For the impatient (Score:3, Informative)
Main image [moofit.com]
Subliminal image 1 [moofit.com]
Subliminal image 2 [moofit.com]
Subliminal image 3 [moofit.com]
The subliminal images are shown for a fraction of a second every few seconds.
Re: (Score:2)
Well, whoever really spends time to read that godaweful "text" picture deserves to be "brain manipulated"
Cool, the ideal plan for getting rich! (Score:2)
2. (was ???) post it on slashdot so everyone read it
3. Profit!
This spammers are getting smarter and smarter, how can a spam image get to the homepage of such a news site like slashdot?
Re: (Score:2)
Re:I'll respond, (Score:2)
Block all Images (Score:3, Insightful)
My solution:
For email addresses that are on spam databases, I block all emails that contain images at the MTA level.
Anyone who has good reason to be sending me images will know my non spam-infested address.
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
I have seen something similar in some emails that, after you send an email they return a mail saying that you need to re-send the email to verify that you are a human. However, I thought that It would be excellent to send this mail with a CAPTCHA and tell the recipent just to hit REPLY and write in the subject of the message the text in the image.
I would use
He's blind, you insensitive clod (Score:2)
And get the business that you represent sued for discriminazism against blind people.
Face to nose: "Goodbye!" (Score:2)
Only pedophiles get animated gifs in their e-mail anyways...
Not subliminal! (Score:5, Insightful)
Therefore, it's not subliminal, since the flashed frame is supposed to be imperceptible to the conscious mind.
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
I think in this case, probably yes, but I was waiting for it like you probably were. I think someone actually reading the message (that's to say, the type stupid enough to take stock advice in spam seriously) might just think it was a light flickering.
Re: (Score:2)
Noticed that the text you are reading dissappears for a very long moment?
Yes of course. When you have to stop reading because the text disappears, I would say it is very noticable.
Sad Situation (Score:2, Insightful)
Really, the best thing I ever did in my email client was to turn off image loading.
--
Arizona Web Design [initusdesign.com]
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Not quite subliminal (Score:4, Informative)
Did the blogger even READ the wikipedia article linked to? It says "These messages are indiscernible to the conscious mind". I can almost count the number of BUYs in the image.
I bet this is more of an attempt to get around OCR spam detectors that don't support animated gifs.
Interesting (Score:4, Informative)
I seriously doubt the capbilities of a GIF to recreate a true subliminal advertisement. It's a bit dependent on the screen position, machine load, audience's focus, etc. With a movie or a a captured TV audience, it's a bit stronger. Also, this isn't a metaphorical allure, but simply a crude flashing.
For some things subliminal messages can work. [sleeplearning.com] For others, it is well-known to be completely ineffective. [about.com]
I doubt this is going to be much of a difference in SPAM, and is rather a sales differentiation point for a mass marketeer. Somebody is paying extra for this, for sure.
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, it's a pity that Vicary actually falsified the results [snopes.com] of his now-infamous theatre experiment. Futhermore, I challenge you to provide any real evidence of a controlled, repeated study in which subliminal advertising was actually proven to work. My guess, you can't.
Re: (Score:2)
Are you kidding? I, for one, am extremely glad that his original conclusions are wrong, that the human mind cannot be manipulated as easily as this quack posited. If Vicary's fudged results had been correct, and considering the capability of corporations and governments to misuse and abuse the resources at their disposal, we'd probably be living in a much more draconian world than we already are!
On a sideno
Re: (Score:2)
Apparently I needed sarcasm tags...
Cause for concern? (Score:2)
Re:Cause for concern? (Score:5, Informative)
I did a Ph.D. on the use of preattentive perception (read "subliminal") on just-in-time memory support. This was the "Memory Glasses" project that got a bunch of media attention a few years ago -- you may have even seen me pitching it to Alan Alada on PBS's Scientific American Frontiers "you can make it on your own" [pbs.org] episode.
The long and short of it is that, yes -- properly encoded, "subliminal messages" can jog your memory, but no, they don't otherwise work as sug,gestions or influence your behavior. If you're curious, you can actually read my dissertation on the Memory Glasses [devaul.net] and find out more.
There was a lot of hype in the 70's and 80's about the evils of subliminal marketing, but it was all based on junk science with forged data.
Slashdot a better spam blocker (Score:4, Funny)
New slashdot business model (Score:4, Informative)
(2) Post on slashdot telling people about the spam
(3) Get enormous viewership
(4) Profit!
Just wait for the new Viagra technologies slashdot articles.
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
1. Most
2. Most
Using a very special algorerythem (patent pending, tm, etc.) I have determined that:
A. There are 12 married
B. Four married posters under 40
B. Two guys that are dating (not each other)
C. Two girls who reads Slashdot.
Of course, some AC posts might be from people who really do have accounts, so these numbers may be inflated.
Re:New slashdot business model (Score:5, Funny)
Given the responses to any post I ever make, I think your estimate is over by one.
~Rebecca
Re:New slashdot business model (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:New slashdot business model (Score:5, Funny)
A. There are 12 married
B. Four married posters under 40
B. Two guys that are dating (not each other)
C. Two girls who reads Slashdot.
E. An undetermined but very small number of folks who can keep the first FOUR letters of the alphabet straight...
Re: (Score:2)
subliminal advertising doesn't work (Score:2)
so sayeth Cecil
You would have to be ... (Score:2)
They might want to work on... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I would hope that you wouldn't buy anything that was advertised via spam, regardless of the apparent quality of presentation. However, consider this: a lot of the spam I see is nearly unintelligible, because the intelligible spam already got blocked by my spam filtering.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
If I were to receive the same e-mail that you're receiving even though I didn't sign up for it, because Nintendo scraped my e-mail address off a web page or used a Windows virus to extract it from someone's address book or bought a CD containing 500 million e-mail addresses for $50
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
If message includes "!!!" in subject, move to trash. (If you have friends using !!!, tell them to see a doctor about mania treatment)
Works like wonder on my Yahoo mailbox since filters introduced, it still busts some undetected spam by Yahoo.
For Korean spam, use "3/4" symbol for detecting. Unless you aren't working at Wall Street of course.
BTW those things were added by me before Spam detection etc. was
Doesn't seem to phase dspam (Score:2)
17 Seconds?!? (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
No, it doesn't. (Score:5, Informative)
Rarely and barely. Under very controlled conditions, with very careful measurement, a very slight effect which lasts a very short time can sometimes be found. However, most of the conditions under which people attempt to use it are so uncontrolled (ie. the entirety of whatever environment you're in is affecting you) that there'd be no way to detect the usually tiny effect. If anyone claims it has effect in such a situation, they have no clue how it works, and are probably trying to sell advertising to someone who is so desparate that they have even less of a clue.
The reality of the matter doesn't keep it from happening. Greed drives people to try things that would make even a habitual lottery ticket buyer snicker. For many years (and still, as far as I know) advertisers of tobacco and alcohol would have grotesque death images airbrushed into their magazine and billboard ads. This was based on the dual assumption that subliminals work, and Freud's theory that there was a ubiquitous "death wish", and it was stronger and more prone to manipulation in people who used these substances.
We've dispresnsed with the first, given that magazines and billboards are hardly "controlled" environments. Freud dispensed with the second before he died, years before this was ever attempted.
Despite overwhelming odds against it, advertisers still paid to have these images inserted into their ads. I know of one couple who worked at a commercial art house in New York who made $125,000 together in 1978 doing nothing but these. Large corporations will gamble large amounts way out of proportion for any real return just to grab a tenth of a per cent from competitors. John Sculley's biography about his Pepsi days talks about this greed effect (though not subliminals).
The very first "attempt at subliminals" (the "popcorn and Coke" experiment in a movie theater) was a hoax. Like all such material, it is properly filed on snopes.com, along with the rest of the story. http://www.snopes.com/business/hidden/popcorn.asp [snopes.com]
Re: (Score:2)
That isn't to say someone hasn't done it... if you could post a link to some documentation, I will keep an open mind... but I am pretty sure a
Re: (Score:2)
As for whether anyone has done so, examine tobacco and alcohol ads, primarily in men's magazines between 1970 and 1990, after hav
Re: (Score:2)
Except that I worked in an ad agency, and I know people who currently work in ad agencies. I know people who are in the boardroom, and people who
Re: (Score:2)
I would hope they aren't wasting that kind of money today. It's one thing to try it for a while, it's another to keep trying it long after it's proven to be bunk.
Everyone? (Score:2)
I haven't. I can't even remember the last spam message I've seen, period--not even in my throwaway accounts.
Re: (Score:2)
Comcast was my ISP until a little while ago, and it's also my primary mail server. Does anyone know if they've been taking any measures to try and reduce the amount of spam that their customers recieve? Given Comcast's poor ser
Does This Work? (Score:2)
Even if it gets past my spam filters the moment I see rubbish like this it gets deleted. If I want stock picks I employ a professional, not a scum sucking spammer.
Ed Almos
Re: (Score:2)
These stock spams aren't meant to benefit YOU, they're meant to pump and dump worthless stocks so the spammers or their customers can make money fast and get out with the clueless buyers holding worthless overpriced stock.
kill flashing gifs (Score:2)
Typically if the site requires flash I skip it. I find it unbeleiveable that Macromedia didn't put in an option to kill unwanted flash. But I guess this says something about the company. So - one day I'll just neuter flash in this browser when I get pissed off enough to do it.
I had to laugh at poking fun at a real estate agent. He has an awful website. I told him if he wants to sell to me then his website isn't doing its job.
One has to hit them where it counts - right in t
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Does it work? (Score:2)
Honestly, not only is a lot of the spam completely unintelligible, but it just looks so phony its hard not to laugh. Does anybody on /. personally know anybody who's actually purchased something from spam? What about the really bad retarded spam like this?
I know I should never underestimate
mutt email = immunity (Score:2)
I've used outlook, eudora, hotmail, gmail, yahoomail, squirrelmail, webmail, pine, mm
and I still always come back to mutt. I get to control it, archive it, its fast easy, and completely immune to this kids of spamming.
As the SCO stock ppl would say... (Score:2)
Ironically, I read an article about a guy who started shorting all the spam stocks that he got, and made $8000 in 2 weeks worth of trading. Personally I would neither short nor buy any stock I heard about from spam.
Most successful ever (Score:4, Insightful)
What are you talking about? (Score:2)
Nope haven't noticed (Score:2)
pathetic (Score:2)
Have to give it to these guys +1 for creativity -783,114,039,832 for implementation. YOU LOSE!
Graphical SPAM? (Score:2)
-b.
All spam has subliminal messages... (Score:2)
For a good laugh, read their SEC filing (Score:5, Informative)
Fun highlights:
So, after six years, the company has zero revenue and couldn't even get set up as a second-tier reseller of broadband over powerline products. Which is probably why the stock is at $0.38 and headed down.
If you go back to older related SEC filings, you can find the story of the "Hipster portable Internet access device" (didn't happen), and the previous history of Koala International Wireless as a vitamin company under the name "Kettle River Group" (also a flop).
This stock is not "poised for a breakthrough". Except maybe in the down direction.
Re: (Score:2)
Err... Canada's actual name is the Dominion of Canada, not the Province of Canada. Provinces are political divisions within the country.... Just to begin punching holes in it, that is....
Subliminal my ass (Score:2)
And then the image went through 2 insanely obvious flashes. Anyone capable of viewing this image is capable of noticing the "subliminal messaging".
Subliminal messaging pretty much looses it's effect if it's not subliminal.
OMG BUY BUY BUY MY STOCK
(ignore the above line, you didn't see it)
Just a publicity stunt. (Score:2)
it's slashdotted (Score:2, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Are you also reading Slashdot through Lynx? I just ask because it seems like a double standard to say we should restrict one medium to plain text while using rich text for another. And that "Give Pine a try" sure looks like a link to me. Could it be you're using HTML in a response to a Slashdot article?
Personally I appreciate HTML email simply because I can bullet / number items, do indentation and other basic formatting tas