Submission + - Man jailed 30 days after Flock used to tie him to shooting he didn't commit (substack.com)
An anonymous reader writes: Atlanta Police Department investigators utilized Flock Safety automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras to track vehicles in the vicinity at the exact time of the shooting. The system flagged an Infiniti SUV driven by Ladavious McNair. However, McNair is an Army veteran who was a doctoral student at Clark Atlanta University at the time; his car was only in the area because he was driving to campus. At the exact time of the shooting, he was actively sitting in class—a fact later corroborated by his professor and classmates.
On October 30, 2024, the victim came forward to defense counsel stating they were not confident that the student was the gunman. Recognizing the error and the total lack of credible evidence, Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis signed a motion to drop the charges. On November 1, 2024, McNair was released, and a judge dismissed the criminal case with prejudice, ensuring the charges could never be refiled.
McNair's defense attorney, Marsha Mignott, initiated a warrant application hearing in Fulton County court accusing Detective Mustapha of perjury and false swearing. The defense presented evidence showing the detective knowingly disregarded the solid school alibi and actively falsified the arrest affidavit to tie McNair to the scene.
Driven in part by the fallout from McNair’s case, the Atlanta Police Department conducted an expansive audit of over 115,000 Flock camera searches in 2026. The audit flagged 79 searches for formal review, prompting the City of Atlanta to draft new, stricter citywide operational standards governing automated license plate readers and public safety surveillance.
McNair's case has become a focal point in a broader national debate on systemic automated surveillance. A U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee hearing examined Flock Safety’s nationwide network over concerns regarding data-sharing loopholes, lack of federal oversight, and the rising trend of false arrests.
On October 30, 2024, the victim came forward to defense counsel stating they were not confident that the student was the gunman. Recognizing the error and the total lack of credible evidence, Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis signed a motion to drop the charges. On November 1, 2024, McNair was released, and a judge dismissed the criminal case with prejudice, ensuring the charges could never be refiled.
McNair's defense attorney, Marsha Mignott, initiated a warrant application hearing in Fulton County court accusing Detective Mustapha of perjury and false swearing. The defense presented evidence showing the detective knowingly disregarded the solid school alibi and actively falsified the arrest affidavit to tie McNair to the scene.
Driven in part by the fallout from McNair’s case, the Atlanta Police Department conducted an expansive audit of over 115,000 Flock camera searches in 2026. The audit flagged 79 searches for formal review, prompting the City of Atlanta to draft new, stricter citywide operational standards governing automated license plate readers and public safety surveillance.
McNair's case has become a focal point in a broader national debate on systemic automated surveillance. A U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee hearing examined Flock Safety’s nationwide network over concerns regarding data-sharing loopholes, lack of federal oversight, and the rising trend of false arrests.