The Future of Linux on Laptops 375
katie_york writes "CoolTechZone discusses the future of Linux on laptops after HP and Ubuntu's recent announcement. 'What would be even more exciting for Linux is if other OEMs, similar to HP, took the same approach by partnering with selected distributions of consumer friendly Linux and started offering an alternative not only in third world regions, but also in the United States. In addition to that, support for Linux on the desktop side of things would be just as welcomed.'"
Priceless... (Score:5, Interesting)
From TFA:
Wow...sounds like Gundeep Hora wrote this article with Slashdot specifically in mind...
^_^
Re:Priceless... (Score:5, Insightful)
I'm surprised this doesn't draw more attention. I mean it wasn't that long ago that one vendor had MS threaten to withdraw their windows reseller's licence just for offering a machine with no pre-installed OS. I mean we're not even talking about support here - they went ballistic just because someone offered the consumerbase choice.
In fairness, I should say that MS have no objection to vendors offering linux systems. Just so long as they're about three times the price of the wndows equivalent, run on crappt hardware, or are otherwise deeply unappealing. It seems to help the vendor hides the machine away or refuses to admit it exists as well.
Re:Priceless... (Score:3, Insightful)
HP and no one else should fear Microsoft when it comes to offering choice to their consumers. That they cannot extend this offer to the US, assuming it has to do with MS, is above all in my humble opinion, an acknowledgment of the sad state of American justice and politics and its relationship with corporations.
Just the perception of a third world geek :)
Re:Priceless... (Score:5, Interesting)
So if you want a Linux Laptop, in the US right now, you've got wal-mart, and some small computer shops that probably have the license cost for windows included in your purchase price.
correction Re:Priceless... (Score:2)
I guess too many geeks spurned The evil empire of wal-mart, and they too decided it's not worth the effort of trying to explain to customers why the computer 'didn't come with windows'
*= they're looking like they're all legacy type systems that most slashdotters already have more than enough systems at that speed level though...
Re:correction Re:Priceless... (Score:2)
http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?produc
Re:Priceless... (Score:3, Interesting)
You've got that the wrong way around (Score:2)
Re:Priceless... (Score:3, Informative)
Linux has become all but invisible at Walmart.com.
There are limited prospects for after-market sales in Linux and maintaing a separate Linux inventory doesn't make sense for a mass-market retailer.
Re:Priceless... (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Priceless... (Score:4, Funny)
Europe the new third world (Score:4, Insightful)
I was unaware i lived in a developing nation , such as um the whole of Europe
Comment removed (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Europe the new third world (Score:2)
Re:Europe the new third world (Score:2)
You'll be calling us terrorists next.
Re:Europe the new third world (Score:3, Insightful)
For some contries the cost of windows 100+ USD is a lot of money ontop of the $600 for the laptop already. Linux in the poorer areas can make the difference for a small company in these areas to keep someone empoyeed for an other week (or more in some other areas).
Re:Europe the new third world (Score:2)
Re:Europe the new third world (Score:2)
I would consider 100+ ontop of a purchase a hell of alot and i live in germany(not that i use windows anyway so its really truely ott).
I was more meaning the EU nations though
The world (Score:5)
So I guess that leaves Europe, Canada, Australia, and many others out uh?
I know, I know, it's a US centric site (per your FAQ), but we still feel it you know?
Re:The world (Score:3, Insightful)
Reminds of a story about Americans on a guided tour in Sydney one day.
One of the tourists asked a question about Australia and ended their question with ...compared to other places in the third world?
I suppose Americans, like Australians, are bombarded with news features either about their own country or the "third world" and they can be forgiven for thinking that the third world is everywhere else.
Re:The world (Score:2)
Re:The world (Score:2, Funny)
Re:The world (Score:3, Interesting)
Everyone is is trapped by their world viewpoint and the media. Most people from the EU seem to think that people in the US are as dumb as our sitcoms. Of course the UK if full of quirky peo
thought I saw a lindows laptop before at fry's (Score:2, Insightful)
Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2, Interesting)
But once Linux is installed, the difficult part is to *use* it. Installing new software and making it work properly is not trivial. Even with GUIs like Synaptic, using any Linux distribution requires Unix knowledge. You can't use (upgrade/customize/etc) a Linux workstation without using a terminal for instance.
So for a newbie or for my parents,
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:3, Insightful)
The problem with linux on laptops is that it is very difficult to find the right drivers for every peice of hardware like the graphic card, the sound card, etc. If HP designs a laptop from the ground up with linux in mind, they can make sure that the parts they choose come with good drivers, or at least f
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
While installing these drivers isn't anything more time-consuming than running a shell script, it has to be done for both SMP and the ordinary version of the kernel, requiring in each case
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:4, Interesting)
Umm... you think so? Linux on the desktop is easy. Laptops can be challenging. Unless of course you mean just getting the binaries onto the disk. Even then its not always straightforward. I 'll always remember the fun I had once getting anaconda to work with some crappy SiS onbard graphics chip
Lapops use more custom components and working drivers are harder to come by. I'm writing this on a Tosh Satellite M30 which works perfectly - but then I did some careful reading ahead of my purchase. Even then, getting the wifi up and running was an adventure.
On the other hand, if it comes pre-installed, we should expect a decent default configuration. If not, it seems reasonable to complain to the manufacturer.
That said, I can see where you're coming from. Hey, I don't even duspute your conclusion.
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
It doesn't have to be some cheap part either; my laptop with a GeForce2go chip wasn't able to install a decent xwindows setup without a tremendous fight. And that was AFTER the epic battle getting the base OS to boot from CD and install properly.
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
I have an HP laptio (Pavilioin ZV5000) and I have tried several Linux distros, Mandr[ake/iva] (really easy to install) did not detected my external hard drive (it is a case to connect an internal HD to USB). Then I looked for help and everyone told me to try another disto.
I tried Ubuntu, and the sound did not worked, I entered the Ubuntu IRC channel and they told me that the ATI chipset was not jet supported.
Then I tried
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:3, Informative)
That is where you are completely wrong, as this is the only difficult part.
But once Linux is installed, the difficult part is to *use* it
Explain please !
IMHO it is a LOT easier to use Linux than Windows. One single example : configure the antivirus. Most users do not even understand the concept of an antivirus. At least in Linux you do not need one.
Installing new software and making it work properly is not trivial
E
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
Is it trivial on Windows? Seriously? IMO, software-installation on Linux is a whole new paradigm when compared to Windows. On Windows, you hunt down the installer on the net, execute it, follow instuctions and install the software. On Linux, you do not need to spend time looking for that installer, since it's already provided by your distributors. Click few icons/type few commands, and the software is installed.
Why is Windows-way easie
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=34155 [ubuntuforums.org]
It's a great feeling when the clouds suddenly part and someone sees the light! ;) And I agree that the Windows-Way is only intuitive because it is what we are used to it - a completely new user, faced with the task o
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
But once Linux is installed, the difficult part is to *use* it. Installing new software and making it work properly is not trivial.
I'd have to disagree a bit. While you're right, in that it IS easy to install most distros now, I think the biggest problem is always getting ALL your hardware to work properly.
If your lappy comes with the OS pre
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
The last several laptops I've delt with:
Gateway Solo 2500*: Required an hour's worth of googling to find out what sound driver would work with the neomagic audio chipset. (And one site was of the opinion that it couldn't work with OSS drivers). I finally found the full solution on a heavily-typoed post to usenet. Just to add to the
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
The part about this that always burns me is that the same people who whine so much about the impossibility of Linux hardware support don't hesitate to open regedit.
Re:Linux, installation and ease of use (Score:2)
You get a driver install. It's either an RPM (double click on in your distro), or a
It installs, then automatically pops up your webbrowser, asking you to A) Download the windows driver for your network card, and then B) Select the directory for the Windows XP driver for your network card.
Pure gui. Very easy.
Not that ndiswrapper is much harder,
Actually... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Actually... (Score:2)
Upgrades? (Score:4, Interesting)
I agree that this is the way to do it (making sure all the hardware works with Linux), however what happens when somone wants to do an upgrade down the road? Chances are they are going to have to choose from a very small list (by comparison to a Windows machine) of upgrades that now work with their version of Linux.
Now some of you may not think this is a bad thing, but I can see where it could be heading... Want that new upgrade? Send your machine back to HP and for $400 you can have this $100 piece of hardware because you have no choices and we can charge you whatver we want! Profit margins here we come...
Re:Upgrades? (Score:5, Insightful)
Chances are they are going to have to choose from a very small list (by comparison to a Windows machine) of upgrades that now work with their version of Linux.
For fuck's sake, why don't you actually try a Linux installation sometime, instead of perpetuating this ridiculous bullshit story of Linux's hardware support "problems." Send it back to HP? Are you on drugs?
Linux has excellent hardware support. There is one major wireless chipset that does not have native support, and thus requires you to use the windows driver through ndiswrapper. There are some winmodems that don't work, or are hard to make work. And there are a few printers yet out there that don't behave.
Now, to put that in perspective, lots of printers won't work with Windows XP. And lots of wireless cards won't work in Windows 9x. Various legacy stuff doesn't work on newer versions, and the number of times you'll need a third-party driver is vastly higher in my experience on Windows than Linux. I've got 3 usb->serial dongles; in XP, they each need a different driver, none of which came with the OS....if you want to use them with XP, you'd better have the CD that they came with. Each one is automatically recognized and assigned a device file when plugged into any modern Linux box. Same story with my Sprint PCS phone's data connection; Linux just recognizes it as an ACM device, and you can use the regular dialup setup. To do that in Windows, you have to find a driver, which is very difficult without buying a $40 outlook-sync program.
The truth of the matter is, more hardware will run on modern Linux than any single version of Windows ever produced. Your post was 100% sheer FUD. And if you disagree, and want to come back here and bitch and moan some more, why don't you start with theorizing at least one upgrade you can think of that a normal user would be able to do himself on Windows, but would have to send the box back to HP to accomplish on Linux. I dare you.
Re:Upgrades? (Score:2)
Incidentally, all your points are good, but there are still ease-of-se things. For example, I have a duplex printer - if it's on XP. If it's on a Linux box it's a single-sider simply because the driver doesn't yet support it.
Your comments about the dongles are right on: I have a Belking bluetooth usb which requires complicated installation on any given XP box, works fine until you reboot, then not at all again ever after. I hate XP.
Justin
Upgrades not an issue. (Score:2)
We're talking laptops, remember? You're not going to be throwing in a new NIC or Video card into a laptop. Well... video cards are upgradable, but nobody really sells them so the point is moot. Hard drives would require a reinstall anyway, memory upgrades don't require anything.
So no, upgrades aren't an issue in this case.
Re:Upgrades? (Score:2)
Here you go (Score:3)
You can't beat that!
Re:Here you go (Score:2)
1. It's a desktop.
2. That's only if you pay for dial up modem service at ~$22/month. (Total: ~$330.)
It's not bad at $320 (w/o dialup) though not stunning.
Are we really still having problems? (Score:4, Interesting)
Is Linux still suffering from incompatible hardware in computers these days? I haven't purchased a laptop since 1996 but it ran Linux (I did have to use AcceleratedX because at the time XFree didn't support the video card chipset) just fine.
Are we still having serious problems with people not being able to use their computers 100% with Linux or are they talking about "out-of-the-box" with no configuration necessary?
Re:Are we really still having problems? (Score:3, Informative)
Incompatibility List (Score:2, Informative)
http://www.leenooks.com/ [leenooks.com]
Re:Are we really still having problems? (Score:3, Interesting)
Are we still having serious problems with people not being able to use their computers 100% with Linux or are they talking about "out-of-the-box" with no configuration necessary?
I've had some experience with two different Toshiba laptops (which I think are great) and problems have been:
I've seen enough messages from developers addressing some or all of the issues. The point being they are real problems to varying degrees for some
Re:Are we really still having problems? (Score:2)
Re:Are we really still having problems? (Score:2)
I always end up compiling my own kernel for extra features that I want to use, but I needn't have if I didn't want to.
Oh, yes we are! (Score:3, Interesting)
> He doesn't want to bother with packaging, experimental drivers,
> non-ability to sleep, and other issues that come with Linux (especially
> on laptops). Plus, Macs can run a lot of Officially Supported
> Microsoft software that the industry feels it needs in order to be compatible.
Yup, that just about sums up my experience too. My company really tried
Re:Are we really still having problems? (Score:2)
Choice 1: Choose to run radeon free driver. You will have everything you want working but no 3D acceleration. That makes it a break deal for many uses.
Choice 2: Run ATI's fglrx driver. You have 3D acceleration, yeah!! But don't expect to ACPI suspend and resume
Re:Are we really still having problems? (Score:2)
support them =) http://www.emperorlinux.com [emperorlinux.com]
Whatever (Score:5, Interesting)
This is good news, I guess, and making something work with free drivers on any one distribution makes it work (with some kicking and swearing, anyway) on all Linux. But I'm not throwing a party just yet...
Times may be better now... (Score:2)
For example, IBM was, IIRC, shipping Caldera OpenLinux 1.3, a fine distribution, one that was one of the best at the time--until the transition within a few short months from libc5 to libc6, XFree86 3 to XFree86 4, KDE 1 to KDE 2, etc. And suddenly, nearly every piece of new, interesting Linux software was incompatible
Linux is Laptop is Nothing New (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Linux is Laptop is Nothing New (Score:2)
Indeed. IBM's Thinkpad line are typically very Linux-friendly, but there are still problems (the T22's WinModem has no GPL'd drivers so can't be placed in the kernel; suspend/ resume are a little flaky; the X40's built-in card-reader does not work, etc). I'm not sure how much power IBM have now over the future of Thinkpads, but a 100% Linux compatible Thinkpad (with GPL'd drivers from Kernel to acceler
Why laptops? (Score:2, Funny)
You would think that people in the industry would know the difference between a laptop and a notebook.
-Nick
Re:Why laptops? (Score:4, Insightful)
Hewlett Packard Hoary Hedgehog Ubuntu Linux... (Score:2)
Strange Choice (Score:4, Insightful)
You can also get more horsepower for cheaper. I'm sure that are plenty of people that want a Linux laptop, but if I was going to specifically design hardware for linux, I would start with a desktop. I would probably also include the US, but that's another story.
Re:Strange Choice (Score:2)
I will buy (Score:4, Interesting)
I'd be especially interested if it had an AMD processor.
HP had one of the best laptop repair policies I've ever seen. Back when I did HP warranty work, one could send in a (broken for just about any reason) laptop, and pay a flat $400 fee for getting it fixed. While that may sound expensive, it's a heck of a lot cheaper than paying for the parts + labor for an LCD replacement.
Additionally, it seems HP doesn't hide behind the "bad pixels are not a defect" policy. While some manufactures (*Cough* Apple, Dell) require that your LCD has at least 20+ bad pixels before they fix, I've seen HP repair laptops with 5 or less.
Obviously, this is anecdotal, and their policies may have changed.
I would be happy with a OS Free system (Score:4, Insightful)
2. I don't want to be limited to what I can run.. I don't want to be "taxed" for software I will never use.
So in the end I really don't care what OS's you offer.. What I want is the ability to order a laptop void of any OS at all!!!
Re:I would be happy with a OS Free system (Score:2)
I don't want any special "No OS" configurator that limits my choices and charges more for upgrades..
I want to be able to go into your online store and order ANY product you have void of an OS period.
( Of course within reason, Im not asking to be provided a Linksys router with no software installed )
Re:I would be happy with a OS Free system (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:I would be happy with a OS Free system (Score:3, Informative)
http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/compare.
Its done, But they give you such limited choices
Question (Score:3, Interesting)
> if one is at the same time selling m$ stuff.
Why is this not illegal under anti-trust law?
Re:I would be happy with a OS Free system (Score:3, Informative)
Uh-huh [walmart.com]
Sure. [dell.com] (Not technically without an OS, but a floppy in the carton with FreeDOS is about as OS-free as you can get)
Whatever [tigerdirect.com] you say. [tigerdirect.com]
Sleep Mode (Score:3, Insightful)
My IBM laptop, an older model, does not sleep well, the battery may last a little longer, but its not dead like an Apple laptop is. Perfect entering and exiting sleep mode, and Linux will get a toe-hold
Old Computers = Cheap Computers (Score:3)
Oh, the irony! (Score:5, Interesting)
To say that the laptop is not linux friendly is an understatement. There are no drivers for the video card, you can get X.org sort of working with the vesa driver. The touchpad is partially supported, scroll bar doesn't work and you need to resort to tricks to make it work (remove and readd the psmouse module).
I installed the latest Java development kit for Linux AMD 64 on it, followed by Eclipse. Eclipse keeps crashing every few minutes.
Although my intention was to run Ubuntu on this laptop, I find myself booting to Windows XP home all the time just to get some work done.
Re:Oh, the irony! (Score:4, Informative)
There's a known bug [sun.com] in hotspot's amd64 version that makes eclipse crash. Disabling the jit compiler worked for me, although with a performace hit. I've been waiting for Sun to fix it for a while already, it's pretty frustrating (so please vote for the bug).
Re:Oh, the irony! (Score:4, Interesting)
You got it.
Another question - are you comparing with the 64bit version of XP? You're not are you?
Nope, just the crappy 32 bit version of XP home that came preinstalled with the laptop (and that I never intended to use).
Have you tried 32bit Linux on it? I would put money on it working a lot better.
I'm thinking about it and might give it a shot. It will probably help with Eclipse crashing, I somehow doubt the video card and touchpad will work to its full potential.
I mean for God's sake, what advantage are you expecting from 64bit support on a laptop?
Blazing fast compilation times? Who knows, I dropped my old laptop and that was the end of it (I was happily running Ubuntu 32 bit on it) and needed to get a new one, I got a good deal on this one.
Planning on installing more than 4GB of RAM are you?
Maybe someday I will.
Try comparing like for like.
I don't have access to a 64 bit version of windows, don't know how much one would set me back, I hope the fact that I'm using windows now is temporary, while linux distros get better support for the hardware on the laptop.
And seek help for your masochist tendencies.
I'm working on it.
customers (Score:2)
Re:customers (Score:2)
My sister runs Ubuntu at home, and now that she is looking for a laptop I am steering her towards a Mac. She asked me about this MacOS thing which it has: Is that apple's version of Windows? I answered with a qualified yes and made a mental note to explain operating systems to her when the time presents itself
My point is that (a) Microsoft does represe
Corporate announcements (Score:2)
Well, actually, not quite zero, because you can be sure if something's announced, it's because all parties involved are postively sure it will have no significant impact on the future. Makes sense, if you think about it. Knowledge about the future is power -- competitive power and power to create additional profit. That's why Apple
Ironically laptops are putting me off Linux (Score:2)
Now I know this is not an Ubuntu spe
Unfortunately... (Score:2, Insightful)
for the record (Score:2)
In India you can already get an acer model (Score:2)
that ain't bad with a 1 year international traveller warranty
would love to see other models of acer also to have this option
Linux as a Gaming Console (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Linux as a Gaming Console (Score:2)
What about BSD? (Score:2)
Suspend/Hibernate (Score:2, Insightful)
Someone should make a line of computers that... (Score:2)
The laptops would have WiFi chipsets with linux support. And power management functionality that works in linux. And so on.
The desktops would include things like Ethernet cards with linux support. And so on.
Then, have printers, scanners and such that are also supported in linux available as an
Nokia's new tablet runs on Linux (Score:3, Interesting)
Nokia's new 770 Tablet [nokia.com] - Debian Linux, X, Gnome, Opera, 802.11g, Bluetooth 1.2, 800x400 widescreen, handheld form factor - supposed to go on sale for US$ 350 within 4 months. (No phone included.)
Nokia's site for open-source components for the 770: Maemo.org [maemo.org] has Linux sources and application development resources.
Developer's FAQ PDF here [nokia.com]
Why now, and not for SuSE or Mandriva (Score:3, Informative)
HP first started shipping Linux preinstalled on NX5000s with SuSE [macnewsworld.com].
And, Mandriva ships pre-installed HP laptops [mandriva.com] (looks like an NX9030) in Europe
I point out that Mandriva 2005LE does everything (at least on my HP NX7010) this apparently "highly configured system designed especially for HP notebooks" does out-the-box, including:
-LAN (8139too)
-WiFi (ipw2100 in my case)
-Modem
-Sound
-Bluetooth (I use it with a Logitech MX900 and my Nokia 6600)
-Graphics adapter (fglrx or radeon)
-Battery usage meter (ie acpi)
-Suspend to disk
-Hotkey configuration (new in 2005LE, keyboarddrake should choose the right keyboard layout )
I don't have any Firewire devices, and I all the IR devices I have have a faster medium (bluetooth or cable), so I haven't tested them, but the firewire modules get loaded fine.
(On the download edition of Mandriva, you would need to download the firmware for the ipw2100, you would get the radeon driver, and the modem may not work out-the-box
So
Re:Accurate Article (Score:2, Interesting)
It was originally like this:
Old World: Europe
New World: US/Canada
Third World: the rest
The true first world would be Europe.
Of course, the above is not very PC or useful now.
Re:Accurate Article (Score:5, Informative)
Even before they start supporting linux it'd be (Score:2)
Most of the recent inspiron models quite mysteriously seem to behave well with linux, so it shouldn't be much of a problem to offer some customized linux with their notebooks