Microsoft Sets Value Of Pirated Windows: $1 581
nick_davison writes "The BBC is reporting that Microsoft has reached a deal with the Indonesian government on pirated software - which is believed to affect around 50,000 government PCs. Under the deal, Indonesia will pay $1 per copy and agree to buy legally in the future. Indonesia's information minister, Sofyan Djalil, said, "Microsoft is being realistic. They can't force developing countries like us to solely use legal software since we can't afford it. They want us to gradually reduce our use of it." Somehow it seems unlikely the same rules will be applied to developing companies and poorer individuals in the United States."
They want the money (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:They want the money (Score:5, Insightful)
A very true observation. But it's not so much about money itself anymore as it is power and control. They want the guarantee of a steady flow of money more than the money itself, and the only solution that can put that guarantee in place is the lock-in of a single vendor solution. They're willing to all but give Windows away to establish that lock-in, and that's what this agreement is designed to do.
Re:They want the money (Score:3, Funny)
Re:They want the money (Score:4, Funny)
How about (Score:5, Funny)
Re:How about (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:How about (Score:4, Insightful)
Innocent or not, she wasn't even given the chance to defend herself. It seems obvious to me that the judges in this case had decided guilt from the beginning, and were expecting her defense to be a plea for leniency. This is not justice. This is the opposite of justice, and its an outrage. However, the fact that no western nation is actually DOING anything about this is indicidive of world politics today. Indonesia is important economically. Thats all that matters. Let Miss Corby rot in prison the rest of her life, as long as Indonesia's markets remain open.
Such little, unimportant things like Human Rights are never going to get the attention they deserve from the west, not as long as our politicians, and the people they represent, refuse to grow some balls and make some (economic) sacrifices for what should rightly be percieved as the greater good.
Re:How about (Score:4, Insightful)
This is only *one* way of running a trial. Some countries practice guilty until proven innocent, including as it happens, Indonesia.
In the "western" system of proving guilt over a presumption of innocence we have the possibility of releasing (perhaps dangerously) guilty people because we couldn't adequately prove thier guilt, but it's very hard for innocent people to get locked up.
However in countries where we must prove innocence over a presumption of guilt we have the possibility of locking up innocent people because they couldn't adequately prove thier innocence, but it is very hard for guilty people to be erroneously released, without bribery of course.
Six of one, half dozen of the other really, both systems have advantages, both have problems. You have to decide for yourself if you would rather have some guilty people get away with it, or some innocent people serve time erroneously.
Re:How about (Score:4, Informative)
http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/content/2005/s13
ELEANOR HALL: Is it the case that the Indonesian legal system is based on the presumption of guilt?
TIM LINDSAY: No, that is completely false. As a matter of fact it is completely the opposite. The system in Indonesia is the same as the system in Australia, and our Commonwealth system. Article 66 of the Criminal Procedure Code specifically states that the burden of proof to prove guilt in a criminal case lies with the prosecution.
In other words, that unless the prosecution can prove guilt, the person is innocent. So the common furphy that is being circulated in Australia in the media at the moment that people in the Indonesian system are presumed guilty until proven innocent is totally false.
...
Someone send a memo to the RIAA... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Someone send a memo to the RIAA... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Someone send a memo to the RIAA... (Score:5, Insightful)
* Some corporations are corrupt
* Some governments are corrupt
* Individuals are often powerless when the two get together
* Resistance is futile
* You will be assimilated
Hope that helps.
Small corrections (Score:5, Insightful)
* All governments are corrupt
* Individuals are powerless when the two get together, unless they get together, too
* Resistance is not futile, but is bloody
* You will be assimilated quicker if you buy Nikes, eat at McD's, use MS products
A copy of windows is not worth a $1 (Score:3, Insightful)
This makes the punitive side of the damages pretty low, but the scale of this settlement means very little for casual pirates.
Re:Someone send a memo to the RIAA... (Score:2)
Re:Someone send a memo to the RIAA... (Score:2, Informative)
Going forward, MS will charge the proper licensi
Re:Someone send a memo to the RIAA... (Score:4, Interesting)
If they couldn't afford it now, how will they affor it in the future?
And, what's to say, I can't afford Windows, so, can I pay $1? They got to, why can't I?
Mod down, not insightful (Score:2)
1) Fines paid to RIAA members were by people distributing music illegally, whereas the Indonesian govt. was just using illegal software.
2) A dollar goes a lot farther in Indonesia, so $1 for them means a lot more than it does for a US citizen.
3) MS sees the Indonesian govt. as someone they can work with, so they're compromising, whereas RIAA
$1... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:$1... (Score:2)
You mean "my 2 cents"?
Re:$1... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:$1... (Score:3, Insightful)
Windows is popular because Apple blew it, and Linux was just recent and not very user friendly at the time. I am a Linux fan, but whether or not
officially okay but practically piracy? (Score:3, Insightful)
So if we pirate enough MSFT software here... (Score:3, Insightful)
Not worth it - that's still more than twice what Debian charges.
Re:So if we pirate enough MSFT software here... (Score:2)
If I give Debian a dollar, will all my games start working again?
Re:So if we pirate enough MSFT software here... (Score:2)
But even for that $0.5, you get 14 CDs packed with software. With Windows, you get just a bare-bones OS with a media player, a web browser and a mail client.
Re:So if we pirate enough MSFT software here... (Score:2)
And most slashdotters *still* think more stuff than you should get.
Re:So if we pirate enough MSFT software here... (Score:2)
You mean virus-client, right?
Does that... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Does that... (Score:4, Funny)
They got ripped off (Score:5, Funny)
Re:They got ripped off (Score:2)
Re:They got ripped off (Score:2)
They ripped off their neighbors. (Score:2, Troll)
Free software has these advanta
So (Score:3, Funny)
God Almight American Buck... (Score:2, Informative)
Re:God Almight American Buck... (Score:3, Insightful)
Yeah, my biases affect my ability to estimate value, too.
Re:God Almight American Buck... (Score:2)
For those of you who don't realize that this is a joke (*cough* mods *cough*), a US penny once had ten bits (before the 1960s, I think). So if you see the expression... "a two-bit whore"... it meant a whore who cost two bits of a penny. It doesn't mean virtual bits.
Re:God Almight American Buck... (Score:2, Informative)
Value is only what someone is willing to pay. (Score:5, Insightful)
You scream Linux, OpenOffice and not bluff you'll get big discounts. MS is rich because people simply pay up. Start being an *informed* consumer, markets work better that way.
Re:Value is only what someone is willing to pay. (Score:2)
And yet the market booms when consumers don't have a clue what's going on (witness the dotcom bubble).
TCO (Score:5, Funny)
well alright then (Score:4, Funny)
Re:well alright then (Score:2)
Should have held out for more! (Score:5, Insightful)
Why is Indonesia submitting like this? (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Why is Indonesia submitting like this? (Score:2)
Microsoft...now cheaper than a BK Whopper (Score:3, Insightful)
Seriously, though -- why do people still pirate MS products when you can have the free (better?) alternative operating system, office suite, e-mail client, yadda yadda?
Is this a statement of "joe sixpack" and his relative ignorance of the alternatives or is this more a shot at OSS -- "we'd rather break laws than use your free (no-good) stuff?" The former seems to be a quest for a Linux marketing department. The latter is one for the usability experts to hammer out with the open source coders.
Either way, there's some truth to be revealed in the answer to why people still pirate Microsoft products.
Re:Microsoft...now cheaper than a BK Whopper (Score:2)
of course, microso
No games. (Score:2)
It's games. Why does my mom not want me to get her a mac? Her favorite games will become a PITA to run.
Re:Microsoft...now cheaper than a BK Whopper (Score:2)
This is more of a statement of MS's prevalence than the relative merits of OSS alternatives. People would switch if interoperability weren't such a (purposely obfuscated) bitch.
Now cheaper than gado gado from the local warung (Score:5, Interesting)
I've been to Indonesia briefly. If I remember correctly, one dollar translates to about 10,000 Rupies, which will buy you a pretty good meal just about anywhere, or an unreliable CD containing mp3s of every Bob Marley song ever recorded, or 10 packs of ramen (ramen costs the same everywhere in the world), or about 5 or 10 angkot rides, or more biskuat than you can eat in one sitting. I stayed a few days in a hotel in Batu Karas for about about $4-$5 a night for a room shared with a couple friends. You can buy antibiotics for about a dollar or so I believe.
I didn't see many computers there, so I don't know if Linux is very well established, but no one cares about piracy over there. The percieved cost of windows is about the same as the percieved cost of Linux: whatever it costs to get a burned copy from a street vendor. "Joe sixpack" is unlikely to own a computer (though TVs are very common), but if he does, he'll probably use whatever everyone else is using, which is probably Windows.
Windows amnesty day? (Score:4, Insightful)
Can this set any precident for the "value" of MSFT software in general? If someone is caught with pirated software, could this overturn the (potential) $150,000 copyright violation because of this precident?
I assume MSFT knows what it's doing (what with their fleet of lawyers).
Their information minister is clueless (Score:5, Insightful)
It's not like they're being forced to pay outrageous prices for their sole source of food or something. They have a choice of software, and they choose an expensive, proprietary, non-free one. The shiny, fancy one. Guess what? It costs money.
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:5, Informative)
Not by a corporation.
Realistically now (Score:2)
Well I could take the part of the last free man and say, you can't be forced to do anything, but you can be punished if you don't do what the man says. But let's just say, in this case, what Indonesian judge and jury do you think would allow Microsoft to win a judgement?
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:2)
But you sure as hell can be forced to do things legally.
Seem to have missed the part where it is the information minister aka government official.
If they don't like how MS uses the law against them, they will just change the law.
So yeah, you are right, MS can force them to do things legally, they'll just redefine the law to say what they have been doing is legal.
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:2)
No, they're just forced to pay for the software they use at the job where they get their sole source of food.
You americans are so quick to think every country is like yours, with people affording expensive software. Hellooooo we're talking about DEVELOPING countries here!
They have a choice of software,
They didn't a few years ago.
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:3, Interesting)
Helloooo, then DEVELOP some software! I think the parent of your post is saying that if they can not afford Windows, then use something cheaper or free. Or maybe get rid of computers all together? 50 years ago I think indonesia was trucking along quite well without computers.
In fact, why don't you create the software they need to avoid pa
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:3, Informative)
Probably more Linux software does than Windows software. You're actually bringing up one of Linux's strengths: Availability of translations is substantially higher than on Windows because 3rd parties can write them and submit them to the developer. Compare this to closed software for Windows where Microsoft (or whomever) needs to pay to write the translation -- so for smaller markets they typically don't. This is part of the reason for Linux's s
Re:Their information minister is clueless (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:No, you are clueless (Score:3, Insightful)
Let me guess that you are American? There are actually plenty of retaliation possibilities beyond diplomacy that do not use bombs: import and export quotas, trade tarifs, and so on.
Anyhow, in this case we are not talking primarily about American or Indonesian law but international law, and Indonesia is a signatory [usembassyjakarta.org] of seve
Mod Parent Up (Score:3, Interesting)
If Indonesia decides that copying Windows is legal, then it's legal there.
I know... (Score:2)
So, if you save a ton of money switching from Windows Server 2003 to Dos 5.0. Then Dos 5.0 costs $1000. But if you can't save a dime by switching from Windows 2000 to Windows XP. Then they don't get a dime.
Ahhh... now wouldn't that be nice?
Ted Tschopp
Use free stuff (Score:5, Funny)
GPL - Free as in mine
BSD/X11/MIT - Free as in not closed yet
CDDL - Free as in slave labor
Apache - Free as in complicated
Microsoft - Free as in stolen
Did I miss any?
WTF? (Score:3, Insightful)
By "developing countries" he means 3rd world and poorer than dirt.
According to my tax returns, I'm poorer than dirt. Is MS going to force me into using software I can't afford? Why do THEY get a break when I probably make something comparable to their salary?
Re:WTF? (Score:2)
Not when you compare the cost of living to income ratios. They may pay $20/mo rent where they are, but then they only have to make $150/mo.
Microsoft denies this (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Microsoft denies this (Score:3, Insightful)
Microsoft isn't the only company with lock-in (Score:5, Insightful)
And the best tool of all in the software world to squeeze those-money engorged corporate udders is incompatibility -- file formats, APIs and protocols that only *you* can provide. (And user expertise in your software.)
The smart purchaser stays the hell away from any proprietary file formats, APIs and protocols.
The main reason that the open source world is nice for the corporate world is not the up-front price benefits. It's the fact that open source software inherently has non-proprietary file formats, APIs, and protocols, means that a choice of open source software ensures that you can't be milked (well, *too* much) or else someone else will toddle on in and start providing an alternative.
Consider an example: People using Subversion for their source control aren't going to pay a cent for anything in the future. Even if Subversion cost $5000 a seat, instead of being gratis, it would still mean only a one-time payment. People using ClearCase have many years of rich milk-giving ahead of them.
Microsoft lets people use Windows for minimal cost in areas that it wants to enter because it establishes one of the above pillars of lock-in -- it builds user expertise in their software. Any software with a different interface or behavior immediately represents a barrier to change. That retraining has a cost, that cost can have a dollar value assigned to it, and that dollar value is exactly how much Microsoft can milk you for in the future.
Microsoft's most-used mechanism to help *spread* lock-in is not contracts or dirty legal tactics, but bundling. Get one element of lock-in into play (say, file formats, with Windows binary compatibility), and use it to get Windows deployed, then try to use that to get people to use another element of Windows that can provide its own lock-in benefits. The economic potential, the amount of money that Microsoft can milk users for, increases with every increment of lock-in.
Microsoft didn't give away Internet Explorer for free because they love you and like petting kitties and giving candy to babies. They did it because (a) it builds user expertise in a feature of their software that then is difficult to move away from, increasing lock-in, (b) enough use of Internet Explorer results in network-spanning lock-in as people start dabbling in things like ActiveX, which are a big milk-producing mechanism for Microsoft, and (c) it provides another, significant, platform to use to introduce file format and protocol incompatibility, and thus further milk-producing lock-in. Internet Explorer is an *investment* in producing economic potential, lock-in, which they can cash in for loads of money over time in the future.
Quite unlikely (Score:3, Insightful)
end rant
Re:Quite unlikely (Score:5, Informative)
Whatever else Indonesia may be, it is not a small country. Indonesia is the world's largest archipelagic state. ... Area - comparative: slightly less than three times the size of Texas [cia.gov]
Re:Quite unlikely (Score:3, Informative)
Not to mention 250 million people, slightly less than the 300 million or so in the U.S.
Not as big as it seems (Score:3, Informative)
http://www.indexmundi.com/indonesia/gdp.html [indexmundi.com]
And as Bill Gates's personal wealth is esitmated at $46.5 billion
http://www.marxist.com/scienceandtech/bill_gates_c apitalism.htm [marxist.com]
And Ballmer's worth is $12 billion
http://www.guardian.co.uk/microsoft/Story/0,2763,1 046102,00.html [guardian.co.uk]
And Paul Allen is worth $20.5 billion
http://www.guardian.co.uk/microsoft/Story/0,2763,1 046102,00.html [guardian.co.uk]
you have the top three at Micr
Now WHY??? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Now WHY??? (Score:3, Insightful)
so... (Score:3, Insightful)
$1 is for each pirated copy the government declares so far. After that, the government stops pirating, and starts paying money! Thats right - for having an initial amnesty to get the ball rolling, Microsoft gets another lucrative government IT contract.
If... (Score:2, Interesting)
Obligatory Robocop movie quote: (Score:2)
Don't foget! (Score:4, Funny)
WTF? You all missed the biggest question! (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:WTF? You all missed the biggest question! (Score:3, Informative)
Several years ago Microsoft Indonesia sued cmoputer stores who install (pirated) Windows onto newly built systems. They claim damage of several billions rupiah, enough to make any local computer store to go out of business. Last time I was in Jakarta, all those stores sued are still in business. In one news article, the defendant's lawyer asked the judge whether he h
Poor Americans are still left in the cold (Score:2, Insightful)
Now granted, someone that owns a PC generally seems like they'd be someone that can afford an OS. But thats not the case alot of times. I mean you go into any place that sells software, and you STILL see Windows Xp Home at the $80 mark or more. Often or not it's still $100 in most big chain stores like Best Buy.
I know plenty of people who have small, self built PC's they've bui
"They want us to gradually reduce our use of it." (Score:3, Funny)
Article title is completely wrong (Score:2)
On the other hand, we could argue as to what is the value of a legitimate copy.
Being Poor Excuses Being A Crook? (Score:3, Insightful)
Thieves in Indonesia remain theives.
It's ludicrous for an Indonesian government minister to justify theft on the grounds that the government can't afford to buy Windows. How did they pay for the hardware the stuff runs on? Or, did they steal that, too?
Smacks of a con to me.
he seems arrogant (Score:3, Informative)
I Spoke to My Indonesian Girlfriend About This (Score:5, Interesting)
"Damnit this is awful. But it sounds about right. After that damned Suharto ran off with $30 billion dollars, there was no way in hell we could ever afford to pay for anything. But still, better for him to steal it than Microsoft."
3.1459265359 (Score:3, Funny)
Microsoft Sets Value Of Pi
Well I thought it was funny...
Re:3.1459265359 (Score:3, Funny)
Poverty? USA? Please. Bad timing or what? (Score:3, Informative)
Those so poor they can afford a $500 PC
Oh, my heart bleeds.
Do USAians actually understand what poverty means? A huge number (I don't have the figures to hand) earn less than USD10 per month.
In fact, the Make Poverty History have a poster (which unfortunately does not appear to be online) quoting a statistic that a London (UK) parking meter earns more in an hour than something like 75% of the world's population earns in a month.
Please, the http://www.makepovertyhistory.org/ [makepovertyhistory.org] campaign, put this stuff up on the web, not just on dead trees!
We do realise that the G8 summit is upon us, and that huge international protests against international poverty [makepovertyhistory.org] are due to coincide with it? ... Don't we?
Or is this just some sheltered young white well-to-do middle-class ... oh, just remembered where I am.
Go, Dubya!
Goddam It! (Score:4, Insightful)
If you go global, then do it fair.
Re:Hrm.. (Score:2)
Nothing different - this deal was for the government there, only for Windows, and I doubt it covers anything that is 'pirated' after the settlement.
Re:Hrm.. (Score:3, Insightful)
Then we'd all buy our MS products overseas.
Re:Hrm.. (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Hrm.. (Score:3, Interesting)
I've seen other companies do this. Users buy a product over-seas thinking that they are getting a bargain, then they call the company for support and are told to pay or go away. It won't really affect the technies who can support themselves but it makes it difficult for people who will need some help.
Re:Hrm.. (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Hrm.. (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:A dollar? (Score:2)