LEGO Mindstorms Will Survive 266
thufir writes "LEGO has released a press release, where they dismiss the rumour that MINDSTORMS is being taken out of production. For some reason the changes in product policy lead to the misunderstanding that they would totally drop the product. 'Hearsay has it that a product range like LEGO MINDSTORMS is no longer in focus. This is not true. On the contrary, MINDSTORMS, CLIKITS and BIONICLE are all good examples of products the company wants to stake on.'" See our previous stories, Lego to Stop Producing Mindstorms and Lego Goes Back to the Basics.
News for nerds, indeed (Score:5, Funny)
Re:News for nerds, indeed (Score:4, Insightful)
You should do what makes you happy anyway!!
Re:News for nerds, indeed (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:News for nerds, indeed (Score:5, Insightful)
A few LEGO projects may indicate a whimsical, curious personality. Too many LEGO may indicate to the women that they will always be second-place to plastic blocks, or other toys. I think most women look for some balance, and extremes in any direction -- too many star wars figures, too many lego, too much money obviously invested in the home theatre -- runs the risk of driving them away.
Or it could be his bathroom isn't clean enough. That's always a deal-breaker with the ladies.
Forgive me for responding to a troll.. (Score:2)
Humans are social creatures. A large portion of that social behaviour revolves around sex. Survival of life demands it: if you don't reproduce, then when you die, something that DID will take your place.
As such, we're programmed to be happy when surrounded by friends and to be happier when we have a mate... forgetting for a moment that we also seem to be programmed to want a new mate about every 1.5-3 years and manage (mostly) to ignore that in favour of monogamy.
So, those people who totally ignore find
Sex and Birth Control (How far OT are we?) (Score:3, Informative)
Nature didn't anticipate birth control or uncontrolled overpopulation, thus our reproductive drives cause us to desire sex, not children... though some people do seem to get the itch for children. It's that excess meat between our ears causing all these problems.
Nature prefers 'population control' using disease, starvation, and predation to 'birth control'. I prefer it the other way around.
Oh, and grow a pair and don't post as an AC!
Re:News for nerds, indeed (Score:4, Funny)
Mumbles a lot and has a fixation with his Swingline stapler.
Re:News for nerds, indeed (Score:2)
Good thing your Ma and Pa didn't share your view point.
Bring back the old sets (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Bring back the old sets (Score:5, Informative)
Look for it here [brickshelf.com].
(Just try not to /. them too much)
Re:Bring back the old sets (Score:2)
I clicked on one of the early 60's boxes and was instantly transported 7,000 miles away and across time back to my old bedroom.
What a trip. Thanks so much for that link, and of course the people who built the site.
The cover designs are totally brilliant.
Re:Bring back the old sets (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Bring back the old sets (Score:2)
I also thought the Black Knight's castle was so badass looking but then it just disappeared off of the shelf
Whew! (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Whew! (Score:3, Funny)
Bob.
Re:Whew! (Score:5, Insightful)
1. Hint that they are killing Mindstorm
2. Tons of people talk about how great Mindstorm is
3. Public gets informed about their great product.
4. Squash the rumors and say "We will continue to sell the Mindstorm products that you love"
5. You know the rest...
Nice working of the system to get some free, targetted advertising. Bravo!
AC
Re:Whew! (Score:2)
Not without precedent. Worked with Heinz Salad Cream in the UK a couple of years ago. Although it's hard to build a robot out of a condiment.
Re:Whew! (Score:2, Funny)
(yes, I'm an American)
Re:Whew! (Score:3, Insightful)
They never said that... (Score:2)
That aside, people don't listen to the slashdot community in its natural technological capacity, why the hell would they listen to some crazed middle-aged guy talk about toys?
Re:Whew! (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Whew! (Score:2)
Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:5, Informative)
Java [sourceforge.net]
Python [demon.co.uk]
Good times!
Perl (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:5, Funny)
Real programmers will use Visual Basic [southwest.com.au]!
Ouch! Ouch! Stop hitting me!
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:3, Interesting)
For example, the average Logo program assumes that the turtle has enough capability to turn 90 degrees then drive forward 15 units. That, in actual robotic terms, is quite a feat. You have to implement a well-clocked motion base with many sensors and motors before that would really happen. And then you're stuck with that specific motion-base on which you could try other robotics methods.
In contra
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:2)
(As long as we're speculating, it should be possible to put a stripped-down Smalltalk kernel on the RCX.)
The teachers at my son's school are looking at it as a way to teach programming. At the same time, they have the students using Moose Crossing [gatech.edu] a kid-friendly MUD/MOO environment.
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:2)
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:2)
Real Mindstorms programmers use either Not Quite C (NQC) [baumfamily.org] or lejOS [sourceforge.net] and Java.
Re:Various languages for Mindstorm programming (Score:2)
Nah, just spreading the joy.
> Love that empty sourceforge site of yours!
Hm. The download area for the mindstorms project is here [rubyforge.org]... I guess I'm not sure what you're referring to...
Re:Dave Baum's NQCC? (Score:2)
Good news! (Score:4, Funny)
And yes, they're for my nephews and nieces!
at last something smart (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:at last something smart (Score:2)
Re:at last something smart (Score:2)
Good... (Score:5, Interesting)
Hmm....any other projects that work with Mindstorm that I should be aware of?
Joe
It's been slow going, but (Score:3, Interesting)
I need to set up NQC or LegOs for the next phase, and I need a good way to control the camera.
Dang. Not enough hours in the day.
Re:Good... (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Good... (Score:2)
- line following
- soccer game
Both done with Lego Mindstorms:
http://oblom.net/robocup
What about the Mindstorms add-ons? (Score:5, Interesting)
The Lego shop doesn't list any of them other than the base set. People like Amazon list them but can't say when they will have any stock. They do seem to have vanished from the face of the net. I have managed to get a Mars Explorer set half price which suggests it's end of line. The only place I can get anything is BrickLink [bricklink.com] and at a price.
When I saw the original
Re:What about the Mindstorms add-ons? (Score:3, Informative)
Their print catalog is really cool.
Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:3, Interesting)
Not only that, but he builds them, then the 3 year old destroys them, and they have a great time playing together with them. At only $5CDN each, they're great cheap entertainment.
Definitely not for adults, but great for kids to spend an hour with the lego here and there.
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:2)
I've got the original set of six at my office (as well as a whole collection of Simpsons characters, LOTR characters, etc.)
Of course, all they do is look cool as yet another toy collection, I don't use them, sadly.
Now, the classic bricks - I've got a ton at home that my son and I play with.
I'd love Mindstorms, but it's a bit pricey... don't have enough time to play with it to justify it. But maybe when my son i
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:2)
Same could be said about the Star Wars and other tie-ins.
That being said, my grandson loves the Bionicles.
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:2)
True. However, I bought the big-ass TIE interceptor a little while back, and spent a whole afternoon/evening putting it together.
I'm 30 years old, having spent a lot of my childhood (until about 2 years ago) playing with legos. I'd completely forgotten how much fun they were, even with instructions to follow.
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:5, Insightful)
The trick isn't to look at Bionicle as a building kit for vehicles and structures, but to see it as an action figure building kit. This has become especially obvious as the limb pieces have become more and more diverse. Sure, it's slightly limiting, but it's also the single best source for ball-joint parts, which on their own aren't so bad.
Kids buy it because their cool action figures. Everyone else seems to like ripping them apart for the useful pieces, and making some pretty wicked looking skeletons of whatever creature comes to mind.
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:3, Interesting)
Finally, someone gets it. My son has been buying Bionicle since they came out. To be honest, it's only done his education good, especially as he has researched the underlying mythology that goes along with the toys themselves, spurred on by the movie (which, IMO, for a kid's movie was excellent. Made a huge
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:2)
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:2)
I wish I had some pictures taken of what he came up with to
Re:Good thing they keep mindstorms, but ... (Score:3, Informative)
What you want are the Lego Designer and Inventor series sets [lego.com]. They consist chiefly of traditional Lego bricks, include several designs in each set, and, by God, they don't seem to be advertisements for anything! The pieces are versatile, and you should be able to use them to build many models not envisioned by the original builders. The product line leads up very nicely to the Technic sets (which were called "Expert Builder" sets when I was a kid).
If I had more disposable income, I would buy up every
Need cast iron mindstorm kits (Score:5, Funny)
Great product, glad to see it is still going.
Re:Need cast iron mindstorm kits (Score:5, Funny)
So you're saying that you wanted your robot to win the confrontation?
Fish don't eat legos (Score:4, Funny)
There goes my idea (Score:2, Funny)
When did legos begin to diminish creativity? (Score:5, Interesting)
At what point did the introduction of increasingly sophisticated and purpose-built Lego pieces diminish the creative aspects of Lego construction?
1961: First lego wheels
1964: First Lego sets to include specific building instructions
1974: Large-scale "maxi-figs" (solid bodies, poseable arms, heads w/ faces)
1978: Town sets with mini-figures, trees, signage (gas, fire station, etc)
1984: Knights, armor, swords, horses, wagon wheels, banners
1988: Pirates, cannons, tree trunks and leaves, pirate flags, alligators
1995: Aquazone, scuba gear, squids, painted canopies w/ sea-monster faces
2000-present: Bionicles, Star Wars, Spider Man, and Harry Potter sets
Another point in time? Actually, I'm not as interested in the date itself as much as the sequence of brick releases.
Re:When did legos begin to diminish creativity? (Score:2)
I wonder when they stopped using wood for the boxes.
Bob.
Re:When did legos begin to diminish creativity? (Score:3, Insightful)
I'm okay with the mini-figures and town/castle sets -probably 'cause that's what I grew up with. But the aqua-zone sets had overly detailed paintjobs on many of the pieces that diminished the imaginative part and often limited those pieces to under-water adventures.
But then I think about the town and castle paint jobs. They had pieces with Exxon stickers, police station l
Re:When did legos begin to diminish creativity? (Score:2)
The spaceship/moon logo I wasn't too thrilled about. Maybe painting the pieces to make them more representative of functional objects, thi
Re:When did legos begin to diminish creativity? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:When did legos begin to diminish creativity? (Score:4, Insightful)
I don't understand whole 'Bionicles diminish creativity' thing. Have you ever actually watched a kid play with them? Mine do, and the stuff they come up with is pretty wild. They'll look at an instruction book and find something they like, but being too impatient/stubborn to actually follow instructions, they'll figure out how to build it themselves.
The fact is, original Lego is great for building orthagonal structures, but terrible at anything else. Circles, angles, joints, gears, wheels - none of these can be built with 'regular' Lego blocks. Putting these things in gives the builder additional options and enhances creativity rather than diminishing it. Besides, how can you have a decent Rockshi vs. Hogwarts battle without them?
The people complaining about 'diminished creativity' remind me of old farts sitting in their rockers complaining that 'things aren't the same as they used to be'. You (and they) are right - things are different. Lego has changed and that's good.
Glad they're keeping Mindstorms (Score:5, Insightful)
Don't know about the bionicals thing though, I've never really looked into it.
Slashdot is a rumor site (Score:4, Insightful)
Wait.....WHAT? (Score:2, Interesting)
Wait......they aren't going to take down Mindstorms, but then they say right there that Mindstorms is a product they want to stake on. That's the most confusing thing I've heard all day.
The day is young! (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Wait.....WHAT? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Wait.....WHAT? (Score:2)
Why is that confusing? Do you not understand what "stake on" means? Think "focus on" as an alternative.
Re:Wait.....WHAT? (Score:2)
Re:Wait.....WHAT? (Score:3, Funny)
Been marathon watching the latest Buffy DVD release too much?
Now that they're keeping Mindstorms... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Now that they're keeping Mindstorms... (Score:2)
Re:Now that they're keeping Mindstorms... (Score:5, Informative)
The problem with the Mindstorms kit is that it has always relied on a few researchers output from MIT [mit.edu]. The researchers used a (AFAICR) Microchip PIC with EEPROM to use as the CPU and an EPROM chip to store the single byte commands. There was also a smaller Mindstorms kit(can't remember the name) based on another MIT project called Crickets, which were smaller, with no LCD screen and only digital I/O. They are referenced on the linked page but the link is dead.
The PIC they used has 13 dual I/O pins and some others, even a basic Brick would take 4 pins for the lcd screen, 3 for the logic inputs. I think there are 2 A/D converters which are both used and a reset switch, oh, and the IR (it has IR, right?)
If they want the kind of things you ask, they need to upgrade the hardware, which they have never done. But with the latest chips they can easily get 4 ports (32 I/O pins) and a couple of A/D aswell. It will also have a new communication protocol allowing (essentially) less I/O lines for the memory and LCD and faster programming.
The radio communications is a bit different, WiFi is out I think, the power needed and the overspec of the transmission (a TCP/IP header would take up a lot of space on the chip).
The Bluetooth might be possible NOW, the communication is either by serial port (RCX 1.0) or USB (RCX 1.5/2.0?), all you should need to do is hack the software to use the port, its already set up to communicate in low-level code.
The language was ripped off from LOGO (perfect for a robot really) and is easy enough to upgrade..even using some of the other interpreters/languages written for the chip.
And yes, I did plan to make a clone, even down to rough schematics and language design. One problem with a clone is the accessories, the brick hardware is possible. The extra sensors are kind of tedious :( LEGO has the LEGO bricks as a common theme to make sensors easy, and they kept them simple (Was it anymore than a switch and a thermistor/resistor?)
Oh for simpler times, when real work didn't interrupt.
BB
My sentiments exactly (Score:2)
On the contrary, MINDSTORMS, CLIKITS and BIONICLE are all good examples of products the company wants to stake on.
I'd be only too happy to drive a stake throught the guy who invented Bionicles [slashdot.org]. Not Lego at all.
Glad to hear about Mindstorms, though.
Bionicle? WHY? (Score:4, Insightful)
But who came up with this stupid idea? They created some really convoluted mythology that makes absolutely no sense to sell what amounts to lego action figures with some kind of tribal futuristic snowboarding theme.
If they really want to focus on their better products, they should have KEPT the harry potter and star trek sets and gotten rid of this nonsensical CRAP.
Oh and the problem with stuff like star trek sets and harry potter sets is not that they have a theme, but that they have all these specialized parts that are completely useless for anything else. The whole point of lego is to be able to build the set and then take it apart and come up with new stuff to build. But when stuff like an imerial fighter or whatever comes with huge fixed wings as a single solid peice that will never look like anyhting but an imperial fighter wing, (or whatever those ships are called) you can't exactly use the parts to build a truck instead.
Lego doesn't need to get rid of their specialty sets. They need to CHANGE them so that the come with MORE parts, and LESS specialty parts. Make the kids make the big flat vertical wings out of a big octagonal peice with some smaller octagonal peices stuck on it. But leave the bumps. Don't make one solid wing.
And get rid of that stupid ass Bionicle.
Re:Bionicle? WHY? (Score:2)
Re:Bionicle? WHY? (Score:2)
Don't get Bionicle?
Don't sweat it. Just means you're old.
Re:Bionicle? WHY? (Score:3, Informative)
The BIONICLE line is built on one version of a Norwegian mythology about earth spirits (or daemons, in other versions).
Lego didn't come up with the idea, they just came up with new names they could protect in court.
AI4U Free Minds for Mindstorms (Score:4, Informative)
A free Mind [sourceforge.net] for Mindstorms and other robots is available in Forth, for when the Mindstorms robot has enough user-fillable RAM to load in the AI4U Mind.
pbForth [hempeldesigngroup.com] has long been a Forth programming language available for the "brick" of the Lego Mindstorms.
An Aibo robot fan site [aibokennelclub.org] features the JavaScript version of the free AI Mind.
AI4U: Mind-1.1 Programer's Manual [amazon.com] is an alternative AI textbook that describes the Robot AI Mind in the 34 diagrams of 34 chapters corresponding to 34 mind-modules.
Rubik's Cube (Score:2, Interesting)
legoland an email unfriendly place (Score:2, Interesting)
project idea (Score:3, Funny)
Re:project idea (Score:2)
Thanks to Slashdot (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Thanks to Slashdot (Score:2)
Re:Thanks to Slashdot (Score:2)
It's all about the clikit market (Score:3, Interesting)
While i didn't buy her any regular lego sets, she did get several sets of clikits. If they had some simple, fairly inexpensive lego kits that allowed for girls to make simple houses, malls, in all pastelly girl colors lego would take off again.
At this point, girls generally have much more imagination and ability to sit down and play and build things. The key is breaking away from the theme based movie/fantasy themes and focus on what girls like, dolls, play houses, etc.
Everyone complains but they haven't shopped lately (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Everyone complains but they haven't shopped lat (Score:3, Informative)
Star Wars status (Score:2)
Unfortunately I don't see any mention of those specifically. Can anyone clarify this for me?
Re:Star Wars status (Score:2)
2004-01-13 03:06:33 Mindstorms not going away and more LEGO news (articles,toys)
Summary:
pending (1)
for more Star Wars Lego news I recommend From Bricks to Bothans [fbtb.net]
So Studios is done then? (Score:2)
I'd been noticing a lot of the Studios set in the toy store bargain bins... Oh well, I hear there are other drivers available for the camera, and lots of movie-making software in general, no doubt. Hell, I'll accept a lot if it means Lego will
Re:So Studios is done then? (Score:2)
Yay! (Score:5, Informative)
Oh, and one last time....the pluralization is LEGO!!! The product is LEGO. You play with LEGO. The company is LEGO. Americans are the only people on the planet who call is "Legos" or "Legoes".
-psy
Re:Yay! (Score:2)
Don't make us come over there and liberate your legos.
--
In London? Need a Physics Tutor? [colingregorypalmer.net]
American Weblog in London [colingregorypalmer.net]
Obligitory Simpson's Quote (Score:2)
Vroom, vroom! [dialing phone] I'm calling Daddy!
Jim Hope: Good for you, not being bound by the recommended age.
Motor Movers (Score:2)
I wonder if this is part of their newer focused lines or if this is one of the lines that'll get the axe. I obviously haven't kept up with Legos much.
Re:Lego (Score:5, Interesting)
Back when it first came out, my Dad and I competed in a sumo cometition held at his work. It was really fun as a high scholl student to be able to play around with robotics and see how changes in code can affect the behavior of the system.
Re:Where? (Score:2, Informative)