Skype VoIP Software Released For Linux 251
pmf writes "Skype Technologies has just released a free beta version of their software for Linux. Skype is well known P2P VoIP technology that, according to them: '...is addressing all the problems of legacy VoIP solutions: bad sound quality, difficult to set up and configure, and the need for expensive, centralized infrastructure.'"
Spyware (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Spyware (Score:5, Insightful)
Always expect spyware. The question is whether we'll be pleasantly surprised.
Re:Spyware (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Spyware (Score:5, Insightful)
Why the hell should we not be expecting spyware? Spyware is indeed extremely improbable in open source software, but here's a great example - Skype - of an application that is not open sourced. Linux does not inherently make spyware impossible - it's just that most software that is used with Linux is open-source, and therefore easily freed of spyware.
Skype could indeed contain spyware. We can and will probably use the flexibility of various firewalling and sniffing utilities to block it.
Re:Spyware (Score:3, Informative)
I can tell you that if the one for Windows sounds this good, quality wise, then the one for Linux should be better. It freakin sounds like the person you are talking to is in the same room with you. It also uses minimal bandwidth, anywhere from 4kb to 10kb for a single conversation and 10kb to 20kb for a conference call. It
Re:Spyware (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Spyware (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Spyware (Score:4, Informative)
From the FAQ:
Q: Will Skype for Linux beta be made available as open source code?
A: No.
So don't expect any potential spyware to be sitting there in the code for you to look at.
Re:Spyware (Score:4, Informative)
Then, last night, I got a third e-mail from them informing me that the linux version is available, and where I can download it from. Seeing as I e-mailed them asking, I don't consider this spam at all. I also haven't found any spywhere on my Windows box.
Re:Spyware (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Spyware (Score:5, Funny)
Nooooobody expects spyware! Our chief weapon is surprise. Surprise, and Internet Explorer exploits... Exploits and surprise. Our two weapons are surprise and Internet Explorer exploits... and uncaring users.. . Our *three* weapons are surprise, IE exploits, and uncaring users... and an almost fanatical devotion to an annoyance-marketing based business model. Our *four*... no... *Amongst* our weapons... Amongst our *weaponry*, are such elements as surprise, IE exploits... I'll come in again.
Re:Spyware (Score:4, Funny)
[JARRING CHORD]
Amongst our weaponry are such diverse elements as surprise, IE exploits, uncaring users and an almost fanatical devotion to an annoyance-marketing based business model. And nice bulk emailers, OH DAMN!
Re:Spyware (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Spyware (Score:2)
Unless they added it in the Linux version -- no.
Re:Spyware (Score:2)
The funny part is in the legal information they specifically bar you from ditributing such software via their service.
You also indeminify them against repsonsibility for any such infestation should any other user break that guideline.
And, if you really think you got a legal leg on them, think again, you'd have to pursue such a claim in the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, which, unless the legal strata has changed, means your basically trying to paddle up a river of shit with your bare ha
skype == spyware (Score:3, Interesting)
If that's true... (Score:2)
Re:skype == spyware (Score:3, Insightful)
Sounds like this product is only beer-free.
Re:skype == spyware (Score:2)
Re:skype == spyware (Score:5, Informative)
Re:skype == spyware (Score:3, Interesting)
and it's not like you can know what the program does by just looking at the filenames. if the eula gives them 'permission' to listen to your calls i'd be a bit wary...
besides. the company uses fuckin assholistic spyware, that's reason enough to not use their software that isn't really the only solution in the world.
Re:skype == spyware (Score:2, Insightful)
Thirdly, there is a problem, as i understand it, in the win32 message passing system. This design flaw allows a message to be sent to any running process without it's source being checked. This basically negates any ki
Re:skype == spyware? (Score:4, Informative)
Re:skype == spyware? (Score:2)
(c) The Skype Software and Services may be incorporated into, and may incorporate, technology, software and services owned and controlled by third parties. Skype emphasizes that it will only incorporate such third party software for the purpose of (i) adding new or additional functionality or (ii) improving the technical performance of the Skype Software and Services. Any other third part
Re:skype == spyware? (Score:2, Funny)
End User: What the fsck is this Adware doing on my computer?!
Skype: We needed funding to add new features and/or improve the technical performance of the software. In order to get this funding, we included Adware into the software. Perfectly legit by the EULA's terms.
Re:skype == spyware? (Score:2)
Skype: We felt that the added feature of pop-up advertising would be beneficial to our users, so we included third party software which provides this feature.
EULAs are worthless in these cases. Those few times I need functionality that isn't adequately provided by open-source software, I make sure to thoroughly check the reputation of the company providing the closed-source alternative. Needless to say, after seeing the havoc wreaked by Kazaa on the computers of friends and family, I will never e
Re:skype == spyware (Score:5, Informative)
I've been using Skype on my Windows PC for aboout 3 weeks now on a pretty regular basis to talk to some friends, and so far, it's worked pretty much as advertised, no complaints here, in fact, I'm pretty pleased with it, especially compared to previous VoIP programs I've used before. In that time, before and after installation and updates, none of my spyware scanner programs have detected any spyware, at least, none that I can trace to it. So, so far at least, the 'No Spyware or Adware' button on their website seems to be legit.
Dunno about the Linux version, but I figure it's pretty much the same way. And the fact that they were willing to change their Linux EULA over spyware concerns gives me a bit of faith in them. Sure, it's from the same folk as Kazaa, but at least so far, it doesn't seem to have fallen into the same trap as the official Kazaa client.
Re:skype == spyware (Score:2)
None of the spyware finder programs i've had on my computer have ever warned me about spyware form skype.
Skype is also encrypted at each end, whcih makes me feel a bit better, even if few details are disclosed.
Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:3, Insightful)
It's perfectly fine to make money off of p2p, no one said anything to the contrary.
They have a business plan, in about 10 days they will release a new version where you can call from Skype to a regular phone at competitive prizes. You need to buy a headset from one of their partners. That's a nice service to offer, and could be implemented without breaking the spirit of free-software, but it worries me that they might push advertisement for this service so ha
Re:Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:2)
my bad...
Another Question: How secure is it? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Another Question: How secure is it? (Score:3, Informative)
Is the voice data encrypted? - err .. sort of (Score:3, Insightful)
According to their FAQ [skype.com] - yes. But since they use closed protocol, it is not worth a penny. They can be calling XOR masking an 'unrivaled privacy' for all I know.
They can't claim security unless it's verifiable, and it cannot be verifiable unless it's open. And even if it's open, the implementation can be flawed either accidently or intentionally (!).
So the best bet for an average paranoid is to consider calls going in plaintext unless proved otherwise.
Re:Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:2)
No one has detected any spyware or anything that contacts ad servers etc in the Windows version.
The business plan:
"During the beta period Skype is free and helps us to refine and improve our product. Eventually, some features and services of Skype will require a paid subscription or prepayment. Our ambition is to keep the basic functionality of Skype (PC to PC calls) free forever. More information will be provided once our beta program is
Re:Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Does anyone know if they have a business plan? (Score:3, Informative)
Test your connection first... (Score:5, Informative)
-ben
Re:Test your connection first... (Score:2, Informative)
From testyourvoip.com: Guess my connection just isn't up to par
Re:Test your connection first... (Score:3, Funny)
These Guys Are Also the Inventors of KaZaA (Score:5, Funny)
I highly doubt that the guys who made Kazaa have taken some great leap into the world of moral business. Bastards.
Re:These Guys Are Also the Inventors of KaZaA (Score:2)
Skype disadvantages (Score:5, Insightful)
* Skype is proprietary.
* Skype is using a proprietary protocol that no VoIP carriers/providers will be using.
* Skype has better sound quality? Let me laugh, it just happens that Skype is only able to do audio, so all your upload can be devoted to audio.
OK, Skype is a nice toy for Windows users. For Linux users, there is GnomeMeeting (http://www.gnomemeeting.org) and Linphone.
Re:Skype disadvantages (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Skype disadvantages (Score:2)
Re:Skype disadvantages (Score:2)
And ultimately, its objective will entail the creation of the very kind of centralized monstrosity its owners complained about.
None of these concerns is valid. (Score:3, Insightful)
So? So were most cablemodems until recently. VoIP is a new technology to the consumer market, it will take a while for one or two standards to settle, and when they do, just like most things like DVD formats and Cable modem protocols and such, firmware gets upgraded and no one cares. Besides, so their proprietary, what di you want to do, take your hardware and move to some other linux-native VoIP provider? Wait...there aren't any.
Re:None of these concerns is valid. (Score:3, Interesting)
No excuse, sorry. There exist OPEN standards, PUBLISHED standards out there
Hype about Skype... (Score:3, Informative)
Those are the real advantages. Get behind a proxy server and then try any other VOIP 'solution'. Of course, they're going to have to pay for all this somehow eventually...
Uhhh.... (Score:4, Interesting)
Sez on the linked page this is from the same folks that brought you KaZaa!
Great. The folks that introduced spyware EULAs to file sharing now want to handle your phone service. OSS or not, can they be trusted to provide any more free downloads?
Re:Uhhh.... (Score:4, Informative)
You're confusing these developers with Sharman Networks. The Kazaa developer team has absolutely nothing to do with spyware, and is only responsible of creating innovative software.
Memory Refresher:
KaZaA sold to Sharman Networks [arstechnica.com]
They have versions for ... (Score:4, Interesting)
I guess Amiga is next in line.
According to their Public Minds site, ... (Score:5, Informative)
How about the FWD? (Score:5, Informative)
One-up on Skype (Score:5, Informative)
Re:One-up on Skype (Score:3, Informative)
Appendix A. Final VoIP Software
Please see CD-ROM for the complete software application.
Huh? Got a download link? BTW, Skype only sometimes requires your call to go through another node such as due to firewall issues. Most of the time, after negotiating the connection, it's a direct connection.
Re:One-up on Skype (Score:2)
Re:One-up on Skype (Score:2)
It slaughters anything i've heard for latency. Teamspeak cant even come CLOSE.
I was on the phone with a friend halfway across the country, and also on skype..the latency was -maybe- 1/4 of a second.
Try stuff before you start knocking it.
Re:One-up on Skype (Score:5, Informative)
Related News (Score:4, Funny)
this is fantastic news (Score:5, Informative)
Overseas, I've had less luck. From my place in Central NY, my Skype calls to a friend in Amsterdam are generally intolerable, although he reports that it works fine when he talks to his brother in Philly. I've had poor but acceptable connections using Skype to talk to a friend in Madrid.
Voice quality has continued to improve slightly with each new release of Skype. But for me, the verdict is Skype is sensational within North America, and barely tolerable or outright unusable for calling overseas.
Still, I wish everyone had broadband and Skype. Even without taking the fact that it's free, it just sounds measurably better than standard long distance calls within the US.
Re:this is fantastic news (Score:2)
NO SPYWARE OR ADWARE!
Course it could be untrue, but i doubt it.
Its also encrypted. Good stuff.
Talk to your geek friends only (Score:4, Informative)
Re:Talk to your geek friends only (Score:4, Informative)
Come July 1st, they'll open their comp to phone service. Wether or not that'll be in the Linux version then, is anybody's guess though.
They lost my interest at the faq (Score:2, Interesting)
>
>Will Skype for Linux beta be made available as open >source code?
> No.
TY, HAND
Re:They lost my interest at the faq (Score:2, Troll)
Re:They lost my interest at the faq (Score:2)
Last I checked, neither ATI nor NVidia is handing out source for their Linux drivers. I really doubt most Linux users shun those and stick with a generic VGA driver instead.
Does this mean it works on OS X to? (Score:3, Interesting)
Or will skype release the final version on both OS X and linux? How hard is this cross-os coding?
Re:Does this mean it works on OS X to? (Score:2)
-Erwos
Calling out (Score:5, Informative)
Vonage? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Vonage? (Score:2)
No (Score:3, Insightful)
What about for handhelds? (Score:3, Interesting)
Ciryon
Re:What about for handhelds? (Score:2)
Re:What about for handhelds? (Score:2)
Ciryon
Re:What about for handhelds? (Score:2)
linux86 ? (Score:3, Interesting)
Linux is more than just x86...
I like Skype, But... (Score:4, Funny)
Easy fix (Score:2)
Let me know if that helps!
Re:I like Skype, But... (Score:2)
Re:I like Skype, But... (Score:2)
The problem is real, depending on the phase of the moon she comes through in a jagged-stuttery-roboty voice, ocasionally with some lag. I don't know if it's a bandwidth issue or what. She has resigned herself to re-installing the software daily to keep in touch, which seems to help somewhat.
It's good to know that I will be able to keep in touch with her once my new linux machine arrives.
Re:I like Skype, But... (Score:2)
Oh, so they do have an Amiga version out!
Thanks, I'll be here all week..
Subliminal voice messages. (Score:3, Funny)
Just below the level of audibility, you get a breathy feminine voice telling you she "digs geeks who buy
Media-shifted Spam. My bleeding ears.
incompatibility (Score:2, Insightful)
skype is a cpu hog (Score:5, Informative)
Just mentioning that skype is a cpu hog. This matters because it means it's not great for playing recent video games.
A great alternative is teamspeak [google.com] which lets groups of players talk. Another alternative (I haven't tried this one) is Ventrillo [ventrilo.com].
Skype is great if you just want to use your computer for wireless chit chat.
I might as well plug the Jabra BT250 [jabra.com] bluetooth headset while I'm at it. Wireless headset with up to 8 hours of talk time. I use this plus teamspeak to give me the freedom to wander my house and not loose contact with my gaming buddies. It also works nicely with my powerbook and my cell phone.
Re:skype is a cpu hog (Score:2)
When you get back, you need to find out what you've missed. In multiplayer games, the state is always changing.
A huge deal? No, but it is limiting. It's nice to be able to just get up go do whatever, then come back and continue. It makes things m
Nice Work (Score:2)
KaZaa works pretty darn nice for what it is.
KaZaa originally didn't ship with spyware, its just the current owners who do that.
Connection hijacking (Score:4, Interesting)
Linux Compatible Headsets? (Score:2)
1. I've never tried to use the microphone port on any of my soundcards under Linux, or when I have it hasn't worked.
2. I don't own a headset for my computers. (obviously related to #1).
I would guess that most headsets that plug into soundcards are going to work regardless of O/S, but I see that there are USB-based headsets as well. So
Cheap Bastards (Score:5, Informative)
Plug DTE into power, hub and my cordless phone base station and I had dial tone.
They assigned me a local number, so it is a local call from my office.
Free calls worldwide to other Packet8 scuscribers. Unlimited calls in US/Canada for people with regular phones. $20.59/month and that INCLUDES all taxes.
I get to use my cordless phone and speaker phones. I can take the DTE with me and my phone number follows me.
Oh, and Packet8 just introduced *real* E911, for the paranoid among you. (Note: If you take the DTE travelling with you and then call 911, it'll claim you're at your address on file -- back home.)
Father's Day alone saved me the $20 in what would have been LD charges.
For those that love the software phones, Vonage supports one that has a Linux client as well.
And VoicePulse will allow you to set up your own Asterisk server, hook in and use them as a PSTN gateway.
FreeWorld Dialup (Score:5, Informative)
- standards based
- Free
- Windows [xten.com], Linux [sourceforge.net] and pocketpc [sjlabs.com] clients available
- Call 800 numbers and more [freeworlddialup.com]
- Call to/from vonage customers [192.246.69.231]
- get free phone number and have people call you [ipkall.com]
- Get a wisip phone [pulverinnovations.com] (WiFi SIP) and you have the closest thing to a IP mobile phone you can get.
FreeWorld Dialup [freeworlddialup.com]
I'm currently running windows and ipaq (pocketpc 2002) clients fine. And calling my home vonage service - no problem!
Quick question (Score:2)
Re:Thanks Hemos (Score:2)
Re:Thanks Hemos (Score:2)
Re:If it's not Ogg.... (Score:5, Informative)
"Speex is an Open Source/Free Software patent-free audio compression format designed for speech" and speex is part of the xiph foundation
Re:If it's not Ogg.... (Score:2, Interesting)
Not only is that an unimportant question, it's also a stupid one. If they *had* to go the free software way, Speex would be the codec to use for VoIP.
Re:Directly from the license... (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Spyware - Another freek (Score:3, Informative)
smash.