Comment Re:It just shows (Score 1) 63
I chose RC boat because some people are using this competing at "stupid human trick" as an example of intrinsic proof of LLMs being able to supersede humans.
In the scenario of an olympic swimming competition, an autonomous boat vs a manned boat would show no difference to each other, both would compete the task much better than a human. It's a useless test to measure general utility. Just like a person swimming a 1500 meter distance is not really a useful indicator on its own of how useful they are. These Math Olympiads are similar in that they are not particularly indicative of people being useful. The same ways that we would stress a human in impressive ways does not mean that a computer coming at it from a different approach should be considered to have broadly superseded the humans.
Yes, a real boat is valuable and LLM can be valuable when utilized correctly, but in the face of exaggerated hype some pessimistic reality check is called for to balance expectations.