Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: Bygone days. (Score 1) 57

Republicans lost two presidential elections, 2008 & 2012, due to running conservative candidates. So they gave up and became a further-left party. Now Obama looks like a relative conservative .. but Clinton & Harris look conservative _too_.

Voters are insisting on left-wing presidents, with the exception of Biden because the initial leftist shock of Trump pt1 was too much to absorb.

I use left as change things quickly, break things, tear down Chesterton 's Fence, taking big chances, and right as gradually careful change, thinking about why things exist before destroying them, and be averse to risk. Trump is left of FDR in that view.

When discussing political ideologies, it helps to use a common reference frame, just like in relativity. Adjusting meanings of commonly used terms to suit a particular argument is... Fraught. And confusing.

For clarity, try this model:

"Left" and "right" started as literal seating in the French revolutionary assemblies: deputies who wanted faster, deeper change (anti-monarchy privileges, more egalitarian reforms, later republicanism/secularism) sat on the President’s left; defenders of the King, Church, and traditional hierarchy sat on the right. That historical baggage still colors French usage more than the US bumper-sticker version.

Modern American "left/right" is usually a grab-bag of two different questions that often (but not always) correlate:

- Economic axis: how much the state should steer the economy, redistribute, regulate, provide services (more "left") vs. emphasize private property/markets, lower taxes, less regulation (more "right").

- Social/cultural axis: appetite for change and pluralism vs. preference for tradition, order, and continuity.

That’s why "liberal vs. conservative" is often clearer as a separate axis: "liberal/progressive" meaning more open to social change/civil liberties; "conservative" meaning more skeptical of rapid change and more focused on stability/tradition. Also, "liberal" is country-dependent: U.S. "liberal" often means center-left; "classical liberal" is closer to pro-market/limited-government.

Using those common frames of reference will help make your views more clear to both yourself and others.

Regardless, you'll note that neither the original nor the modern meanings of "left" and "right" align well with what you've described in these two comments. And in particular, FDR was very much a "move-fast-and-break things" President, eventually having to threaten to pack the Supreme Court with supporters when they continued to strike down laws that he had proposed, Congress passed, and he had signed before they stopped blocking his radical changes at every turn. Trump, by contrast, is "Reactionary" rather than "Liberal" (when he's consistent at all). That is, he wants not slow change, but a return to a previous era's values and norms. Possibly in his case, a feudalistic era's values and norms.

Imagine, then, one axis like this:

<---- Progressive ---- Liberal ---- Centrist ---- Conservative ---- Reactionary --- >

Where Bernie Sanders is on the left, and Donald Trump is on the right.

Or if you prefer overtly political labeling:

<---- Communist ---- Socialist ---- Democrat ---- Republican ---- MAGA --- >

There are, as previously mentioned, multiple axes. This is an oversimplification to get the point across.

Comment Re:Shows you what they were thinking (Score 1) 89

There is always some personal upside for some people when technology becomes "obsolete" but remains critical. No argument about that and I am likely one of those. For example, I already have a request whether I would be interested in maintaining some FORTRAN code when I retire. (Not sure I want to, but FORTRAN is a very reasonable classical language. And I can do C or even assembler embedding if needed.)

Some expertise is both critical and rare. That said, this LLM hype is pretty bad for most people and it must eventually crash back to reality. Anybody dependent on LLMs will be in really deep trouble at that time.

Slashdot Top Deals

"Plan to throw one away. You will anyway." - Fred Brooks, "The Mythical Man Month"

Working...