>"The majority of the people you show it you will download it and do a full nuke-and-pave"
Doubtful. Although it might be a significant minority.
>"then wonder why this new 'Windows' can't run their favorite programs".
Like a browser? Because for a huge chunk of home users, that is all they really use now.
>"Even if all 1 million downloads turn into real OS installs, it's a drop in the bucket compared to Windows installs."
True. But if even if a small number of those people then show someone else and that other person switches, and on, and on, awareness keeps spreading. That is a great thing.
Generally, I don't care what OS people use (as long as I don't have to support it), but I do care if they are unhappy. Having Linux as an option is really great and works fantastically for a large number of people willing to really try it. The fact that it is free, fast/efficient, has no licensing mess, is more secure, more privacy-oriented, more controllable, more customizable, more open, easier and faster to update, and without forced cloud crud, no AI creep, no ads or nagware, and very little fake/forced hardware "obsolescence" all make it a very compelling option for lots of use cases. Not all use cases, but a surprisingly large number.
>"However, after Microsoft's recent announcement their own updates have broken their own system [slashdot.org] combined with no longer supporting W10, this can only lead to good things."
Microsoft obviously has its own agenda that doesn't mesh at all with what many (perhaps even most) users want now. And it shows. As MS-Windows has gotten significantly worse and more hostile over the decades, Linux/distros have gotten significantly better. Even people who haven't tried it in 5 years are often pleasantly surprised.
I tend to point people to Mint, but Zorin might be just fine, as well (I just have no experience with it).
Releasing immature tech to the general public is a strange strategy, especially when hypemongers exaggerate its capabilities.
The general public has a reputation for misusing tech and doing really stupid stuff with it.
The proper use of AI is for helping us solve previously intractable problems in science, engineering, medicine, etc. Using AI to create slop, scams and fake "friends" is a misuse of the tech.
>"I need an OS that I can plug a sound card into, start up my machine and it installs the driver and starts working"
Generally, that is Linux. I have installed various Linuxes over decades on hundreds of various machines. For the most part, modern Linux detects all the typical hardware and just configures and uses it. There is no need to "install drivers".
>"I want GUIs for all common tasks and I want it intuitive enough the I'm not spending hours looking up"
Again, that is generally the case with modern Linux. All the good distros can be completely managed through a GUI.
Could you end up with trying to install a not-so-great distro on a machine that has some unusual hardware? And have to take a dive into stuff? Sure. But that is the exception, not the rule, at least not in 2025.
As I already said in the previous post:
"MacOS mostly doesn't really even use ~/.config, because, well, "Apple".
We don't know if Mozilla will do that on MacOS, which does not follow all Unix conventions. Especially desktop ones, of which this is.
>"Linux" appears ZERO times in the specification."
And yet, 99% of who this change will affect will likely be Linux users. MacOS mostly doesn't really even use ~/.config, because, well, "Apple".
>"This is a specification for UNIX. Linux copied from UNIX but is not UNIX."
If it quacks like a duck and looks like a duck, it is probably a duck. Linux is Unix, in all ways that matter to anyone now (and for a long time before now). Worrying about exact Linux vs Unix vs UNIX vs Unix-like vs BSD vs POSIX is kinda no longer relevant.
>"Apps should keep their files in their own directories. Spreading them across a 1000 different directories makes no sense and just make uninstall a hassle"
It will still be in its own directory. Just in ~/.config/mozilla instead of ~/.mozilla
For example, LibreOffice stores its settings in ~/.config/libreoffice, GIMP is in ~/.config/GIMP, Thunar is in ~/.config/Thunar, VLC is in ~/.config/vlc, etc...
"Ada is PL/I trying to be Smalltalk. -- Codoso diBlini