>"Anyway pretty much all the cable is Hybrid Fiber Coax (HFC) now. They run fiber to the head end and then run coax from there."
Yep, that is very true. And Cox has ads all over also saying "fiber powered" for years. All AT&T and others have to keep advertising is "fiber to your home" and the others, like Cox/Spectrum/Comcast/etc can't make that claim.
>"You get all the benefits of fiber to the neighborhood without the high cost of fiber to the premises. Most people will never notice the slightest difference because they won't buy the most expensive fiber plan anyway."
The problem is not about bandwidth. On that, it is true that almost nobody cares. 200Mbs 300Mbs 500Mbs 1000Mbs, for the vast majority of homes (mine included) it just doesn't really matter.
But what DOES matter is that coax is very unreliable. Especially the old crap that has been out there for decades. It is very prone to failure, backfeeding, poor connections, interference, balancing issues, etc. Over and over I have had to get Cox out here to fix their crap on the pole, or the drop to my house, or in SOMEONE ELSE'S HOUSE that is screwing up my feed. That kind of problem pretty much disappears with fiber to the home. And that is worth something. How much is it worth? I guess the market will decide, if/when consumers even have that choice/option. I haven't until recently. And it should have total cost of ownership worth to the ISP as well- all those service calls to trace and fix coax problems can't be cheap.