Comment Private companies should not circumvent 4th (Score 4, Insightful) 64
It's really as simple as this: a private company should not be able to circumvent our 4th amendment rights.
Even if their collection of the data is legal on the face of it, their use and sale of that data to law enforcement should explicitly not be. LE using a private company to end-run the 4th amendment needs to be struct down by SCOTUS in no uncertain terms. Every single search done by LE should have a signed warrant - no exceptions.
Looking more broadly, congress needs to get it's shit together and pass laws restricting this kind of mass surveillance in general.
The 'problem' is there's plenty of uses to justify this "we caught the car thief" but the potential for abuse is FAR too great. The utter invasion of privacy is beyond reason. Better a criminal go free than an innocent man be jailed.