Comment Re:Video (Score 1) 1671
You do not win a war by giving in to demands of the enemy and you do not win a war by making it an even score.
Perhaps not in a full-on all-out metal storm. But police action and counterinsurgency isn't at all the same kind of beast, it's a kind of diplomacy, and that's where the USA has been getting their international butts kicked all through the GW Bush presidency. Heck, they got the same thing handed to them in Vietnam and didn't even realise that 'overcoming the Vietnam syndrome' just meant 'forgetting - or not even attempting to learn - some very important lessons'.
It is perfectly possible to 'win a war' by killing lots of civilians and yet lose the hearts and minds of the populace. When those hearts and minds determine how many suicide bombers are coming at you, yeah, you're not gonna win by just killing more people.
Basic maths: If every monster you kill creates two more, perhaps there comes a point when it's counterproductive to keep firing? And that's the kind of situation the USA is in. Sometimes you have to get out of the hole by stopping digging.