Comment Re:And nothing of value was lost... (Score 1) 74
You just can't let go of your encryption hobby horse,
BAAHHAHAAHHAAHAAAAAA
*gasp*
BAAHHAHAAHHAAHAAAAAA
BAAHHAHAAHHAAHAAAAAA
BAAHHAHAAHHAAHAAAAAA
BAAHHAHAAHHAAHAAAAAA
BAAHHAHAAHHAAHAAAAAA
1) Either really will stoop to that level of dishonesty or you have no idea what Google RCS was all about. E2EE was a defining feature of Google RCS that distinguished it from Universal profile. To call it a "hobby horse" says you either know nothing about this topic or you are willing to lie about the importance of it.
2) Do you understand what OTHER FEATURES means? E2EE was one of many features in Google RCS that is not defined in Universal Profile nor did the specification spell many ways to handle any of the extensions Google added. Except the one method used by device that used incompatible RCS versions: Fallback to MMS.
3) You still haven't addressed the basic question of Apple was supposed to decrypt Google's implementation of the Signal protocol that no one else used.
Sure, Apple can have that their way, if they don't support Google's extensions, I'm fine with that, and I don't criticize Apple for that.
Even today, not all Android phones use Google RCS especially those that use GrapheneOS or LineageOS. Did you know that?
No, Apple did *not* have to support a myriad versions of RCS to get photos and videos to properly sync. Just one.
And what would that accomplish again? When all these Android devices had incompatible versions of RCS, did they default to Universal Profile 1.0 when messaging each other? No. They all defaulted to MMS. So Apple would implement another incompatible version that no one used that did not have many features . . . Or Apple could default to MMS like everyone else.
Nobody cares about phones that have a 2% market share. Android has 40% or so market share in the US, and more outside the US. It's not too much to ask Apple to support the other half of the market that uses a single Messages app
You are asking Apple to support people who are not their customers. Why again? Do you ask Toyota why they don't use the same tires on the Camry that Honda uses for the Accord? That's how stupid your request is. I do not know how to say in any other way so you can understand: THE FALLBACK FOR MESSAGING IS MMS. For decades.
Clearly, Apple eventually capitulated and made it happen.
Apple has made Universal Profile 2.4 happen. Full Google RCS compatibility has not happened yet. The GSMA announced in March 2026 the release of RCS 4.0 specification which addresses rich text and videos enhancements. They have not solve the problem of E2EE compatibility. Did you know that either?