Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:No.... (Score 1) 82

lol

Welcome to the 21st century, you might have to catch up on a few things. Start with Mozilla Media Engine and AVFoundation / WebKit Media Stack.

Your website sends me an H.264 stream (or whatever you decided you'll use). It doesn't need to know shit about my graphics hardware.

Comment Re:No.... (Score 1) 82

Congrats, you just broke every video player on the internet. Nothing fullscreens anymore.

Complete bullshit. Even for fullscreen video, the website doesn't need to know my screen size. It should tell the browser "here are the resolutions I can offer you" and the browser picks one of those. All the website needs to know is if I prefer 1080p or 4K. And I might pick 1080p even if my screen is 4K because, say, the hotel wifi is slow.

You just broke layout, encryption, media delivery, fonts

Complete bullshit. None of these things break if I don't tell you my OS. I've got extensions in this browser that can fake my agent string and nothing breaks. Fonts? Are you kidding me? Be more specific, what exactly do you mean by that?

Errr it's the browser rendering engine that actually tells the website the graphics capabilities.

And there's no reason it needs to. What legit use case requires a website to know whether my GPU is an NVidia, AMD, Intel or whatever chip? A shitload of the capabilities are only needed for 3D scenes (like max texture size), which is 0.1% of the websites I visit - they can ask and I can whitelist just them. Why does it need my refresh rate?

Again: All of these things have a legit use case, sure. Often exactly one. That is rarely if ever used. There's absolutely no reason that EVERY WEBSITE can query information that only one website in a thousand actually needs.

You don't tell the baker, florist and car dealer your shoe size just because the shoe shop needs it to serve you, right?

Why? You'd be such an irrelevant bit of noise in the dataset.

Because I want to be irrelevant to the fucking ad industry. I don't want them to track me, profile me and try every trick in the book to manipulate me into buying shit I don't need.

Comment Re:No.... (Score 1) 82

Your browser leaks uniqueness out of every orifice and every single one of those things has a legit use case.

Sure, the same way that putting a finger into another man's ass has a legit use case (prostate examination) - but that doesn't mean I want every man to do that to me all the time.

The point is that tech companies are exploiting the legit use cases by abusing them when you're not in that use case. Basically, they think they can finger up your ass whenever they want, because once a few years ago you consented to a doctor to give you an exam and maybe you will do that again in the future.

which is capable of

I don't mind it being capable of. I mind it doing all kinds of shit without telling me and without giving me a choice. For example, I absolutely do not want websites to access my microphone. Or even know that I have one. For the once-a-year case where I might actually use that, I can enable it.

The problem is the same problem that the cybersecurity field has been fighting for 40 years: Permit All being the default.

Comment Re:No.... (Score 1) 82

It doesn't NEED to know any of these things. My browser knows the window (not screen) size and if your CSS is well-formed, it'll manage or maybe your page looks shit if you build it shit. It needs to know my OS only if I want a download link, not on every page I ever visit. It doesn't need graphics capabilities unless it wants to bypass the browser rendering engine, in which case it should ask for permission or fuck off.

The thing is that we give up too easily and the major browser manufacturers (one of which is an ad company themselves) are complicit.

I want "fuck the ad industry" mode, where the browser generates random but plausible values for every non-essential information a website requests. Different ones every 5 minutes.

Comment Re: The climate is going extreme (Score 1) 114

Until now, the only generation who could have done anything about CO2 emissions are Boomers. The Silent Generation didn't know what the threat was and they didn't have the technology to do anything about it.

Most politicians today are extremely old and are only in those seats because equally old voters have disproportionate voting power. They are still predominantly Republican, which is a party that tries its best to deny and block any attempt at fixing or even adapting to climate change.

Time is running out for them though, so I think we will see if Gen X is any better when they're the ones in charge.

I know by the time we get to millennials (2040 onwards), there will be enough consensus to take some action. Though it might be too late by then.

Comment Re:rrriiiight... (Score 1) 78

Huh? It's an unsecure and unmaintained open-source driver that's causing the issue. The OS is running perfectly fine.

Perfect illustration of the thinking problem here. You don't even get WHAT the problem is.

Why is a driver able to fuck up a system? The OS should be the watchdog that says "WTF are you doing there?", not the obedient slave executing whatever.

A great illustration is W^X - first found not in Windows, but in OpenBSD. Because Windows happily goes "whatever you say, master", while the guys at OpenBSD said "no actual use case of non-broken, non-malicious software should ever behave like that, so we'll block it".

since a non-MS open-source driver is actually the problem here.

If you are responsible for a sensitive location, and a five-year old kid from the neighbourhood one day just wanders in and take a look around out of curiosity, pressing a few buttons to see what happens - you would definitely not keep your job by claiming that the little kid is actually the problem here.

Comment Re:anyone really want these ? (Score 1) 245

A touchscreen doesn't negate that, either. Lack of physical controls does. They are not mutually exclusive. Oh, and my new vehicle also has a real dashboard with display in front of the driver, like a vehicle should have (unlike a Tesla). AND it ALSO has an HUD display with speed, speed limit, nav info, etc, as well. AND it has voice controls. So all options are on the table.

You are right. A screen that does not replace physical controls is a nice thing.

And I agree. Any vehicle that doesn't have a proper dashboard in front of me, where I need to look to the side to see important information, is a no-buy for me.

Comment Re:anyone really want these ? (Score 1) 245

yes, it's a short list. But it's a start and a kind of "red line". I am hopeful they move that line to include other things that people use while driving all the time.

Are big screens nice? Sure, yes.

But if I have a choice between good physical controls and a big touch screen, I'll take the buttons and switches any day, thank you.

Comment Re:anyone really want these ? (Score 1) 245

My 10 year old BMW has voice commands and a map that's always been more than enough for me. Sure, it's not as large, but while driving I don't want a big map - I want an indicator that tells me "next turn left in 500m" - and I have that, not on the main display but right in front of me on the dashboard. Newer models have it on a HUD.

Nothing in what you wrote makes a LARGE screen necessary.

Comment Re:Doesn't it support it? (Score 1) 98

You're right, but how it was written never mattered in the first place. Complaining about the process of creating the article is ad hominem. If someone disagrees with the points she raised, then they need to argue directly against those points.

That said, maybe it's not surprising that people who want to remove standardized testing from the admission process would also fail basic logic themselves.

Comment Re:Nonbinding - move along (Score 1) 13

Japan has a very conformist culture. Even if it's not a law, you're still expected to follow it.

That said, foreign companies and open source projects are unlikely to comply, and Japan has nothing near the frontier to replace them. It'll only be able to push its weight around when there's a Japanese alternative they can switch to.

Slashdot Top Deals

"One Architecture, One OS" also translates as "One Egg, One Basket".

Working...