Web Sites Shut Down 211
Over 600 readers submitted that the popular comic strip
User Friendly has
been shut down indefinitely following the injunction against
the site from an, as yet not publicly named person. This
adds Illiad's site to Segfault
and Bedope, each of
which also has gone down following complaints regarding
content.
What Rights Do You Want to Give Up Today? (Score:1)
The real question seems to be who is the anonymous threat? As we all saw from the theos.com debacle, lawyers aren't happy when you post there names, letters, etc. without there permission. Therefore it doesn't seem so unlikely that UserFriendly and Segfault have not posted a name.
Of course, from just the material posted on those sites, one can come to a few conclusions as to who would be peeved.
The weird thing is, the courts have ruled that use of trademarks and copyrights for parody is legal. This is part of that whole pain-in-the-MSFT-gluteus-maximus constitutional right to free speech.
"What about free speech?"
"Well that's not the point, your giving this place a bad name"
-- Chumbawumba
MEEPT!! (Score:1)
Definately an april fools joke. (Score:1)
Loks like a joke (Score:1)
I must say, it was the most elaborate one I've seen in a while.
Re: Moderation fails us! (Score:1)
www.hackernews.com cracked (Score:1)
do the obvious if you want to email me
Nightmares of Bloom County and Donald Trump (Score:1)
...phil
No april fools joke (Score:1)
And your evidence for this is...? As far as I know, the unnamed entity is remained unnamed all along.
...phil
If this *isn't* a joke.... (Score:1)
...phil
Support UserFriendly Website - I AM NOT IN ON IT (Score:1)
I started the Support page a week ago, opened it 4 days ago. IF this is a joke as people are hoping, I promise I will personally kick Illiad's rear.
As it is, there are too many problems to be able to get a picture of what is going on. I am trying to get more information so I can let people know what is going on. A press release is being prepared for release, we are going on the presumption that this IS REAL. This is not a laughing matter in anyway. I prank like this would kill these sites, not help them.
I have had 20 emails already asking about the archive. Yes, I have 99% of the comics from start to 3/31/99. If the site is still down after midnight PST I will set them up online for people. I'll post it here.
Let us not be hypocrites! (Score:1)
How many among us cheered when the Nuremberg Files website was shut down? If we will stand by when they shut down sites that are on the "fringe" that advocate an "extremist agenda" we open the door for the rich, powerful and influential to paint us as "kooks", and "extremists" in order to shut us down.
We must remember that the right to freedom of expression is absolute. Let them take it from one of us, and they'll take it from all of us.
LK
One April is also the start of a month. (Score:1)
I could easily see that the injuction would start at the beginning of the month.. Insurance usually doesn't just start on Mar 23 and neither do things like this.
We will see in 72 hours however.
Slashdot next?? (Score:1)
Well, yes M$ has the money, but the US has this provision for a fair an speedy trial. If UF talks to the judge they can force the trial to comence within a few weeks. Given the his buisness is shut down (UF does have ads, don't know if it makes money) ANy lengthy delay in the trial would have to be approved by both parties.
Don't overlook UF's ability to counter sue. UF has basicly no money, so they have nothing major to lose. Since this trial is not cut and dried for anyone against them (satire is generally considered protected), UF can sue for disruption of buisness, with a greater chance to win.
I wonder if I can sue. After all I've lose a part of my day, and that is causing pain and suffering.
April Fools? (Score:1)
metalabs mirroring download.com is an obvious farce, (that is just offensive) and since they make reference to Linus moving as a reason, and link back to slashdot, that looks like a friendly conspiracy.
This one, however, was definitely prepared in advance, if it indeed is a joke. If it was, then I admit, you really got me. But otherwise, I'm going to be without my Userfriendly.
April Fools? (Score:1)
YOU GUYS SUCK!
Last April Fools Day was obvious, but this one was just... mean, man.
People, check the date (Score:1)
As a joke it is ill considered. The last thing people want in a website is for it to be down.
then all four lawyers and the judge failed the bar (Score:1)
First hint: the demand for portrayal in "a more positive light." Large corporations hire expensive law firms that can afford lawyers that wouldn't toss something this silly in with a defamation claim.
Second hint: shutting down under advise of councel. The alleged claim is silly; the chances of advice this bad coming from all three lawyers is slim.
Third Hint: the injunction itself. In the U.S., there is no prior restraint, saving only dire security issues, such as shipping schedules during a declared war. Lesser security matters and defamation are left to the courts after the fact. While there was a rogue court order a year or two ago blocking a publication, it was overturned immediately.
Fourth hint: the secret plaintiff. You're not going to get an ex parte temporary restraining order in a sealed case. Won't happen.
OTOH, when I think of some of the lawyers nand a few of the judges from my practice . . .
More fuel for the fire... (Score:1)
However, here's another bit of evidence that
it might be the case:
Last year, several major comic strip artists
got together and did a switcheroo of their strip,
with the classic example of Scott Adams drawing
Family Circus, and Bill Keane drawing Dilbert.
This year, several on-line strips are repeating
the same thing (The main page for this can
be found here: http://grove.ufl.edu/~normal/switch.html
If you look at the bottom of the page, apparently
Illad and UF was supposed to participate (swapping
with 'The Deep End', which incidently is still
up with no noted problems). Did this 'gag' by
UF, segfault and bedope have more priority for
Illad than this comic switch, or did UF really
get C&D'ed?
(Also, I do find it ironic that all 3 sites have
completely shut down, instead of just removing
the offending material, which is generally what
is done in the C&D type cases...)
Funny... (Score:1)
What surprises me the most is how they got my high school GPA, since there is no translation from Danish to US grading systems.
I'd better stop before I make a fool of myself. After all, we wouldn't want to start a new month that way, would we?
-Lars thinks it's overdone
What about Dilbert? (Score:1)
I want details, but until they are available, it seems only safe to assume that this is another example of "We can afford expensive lawyers. You can't, so the legality of your actions are irrelevant as we will prevail in any legal action".
I'm no lawyer, but I was led to believe that US law had been shown to protect satirists.
I can easily find bandwidth in the UK for any of those sites taken down if necessary.
Matthew.
The company and the email address (Score:1)
I thought the 1st amendment covered satirical works like those on User Friendly and Segfault. I'm losing more and more faith in the US than ever...
US? (Score:1)
Maybe it was the Canadain Goverment halting him because he didn't mirror his page French.
Of course it's formulaic... (Score:1)
But for now, everything is running according to "the way it's done."
Legal Counsel... (Score:1)
There has to be a way to see if the name Michael Scott DeWitt is registered as a lawyer somewhere. Where is Userfriendly located, it might be likely if this were real that he would hire a lawyer in his area, and a quick search of a local phone book might back up his story. If this isn't a joke (which I believe it is, as are most things that will be on /. today), then I would say that verifying the existance of Michael Scott DeWitt may be the key to uncovering the legitmacy of this shutdown.
That's not always the way it works. (Score:1)
the bastards (Score:1)
NOOOOOOOO! (Score:1)
That, and how come slashdot knows the last time I brushed my teeth, and my social security number?
If this is a joke... (Score:1)
Noooooo!! (Score:1)
What about Dilbert? (Score:1)
Since Illiad isn't a deep-pockets corporation, he's much more vulnerable to legal action.
What are the legal distinctions between US law and Canadian law regarding libel, parody, and freedom of speech? The US is pretty liberal about these issues, what about Canada?
US? (Score:1)
JOKING, people (it IS April Fools day, after all), but I do remember a John Candy movie where Dan Aykroyd (playing some sort of police officer) pulled Candy's truck over, commented on the anti-Canadian graffiti scrawled all over it, and wouldn't let him proceed until he sprayed on French versions of all the slogans. (Which, of course, was a ripoff of the graffiti scene from Life of Brian -- but still funny.)
Hit the sites... (Score:1)
If it isn't an April fools day joke (Score:1)
Once we get this far then publicity is the answer.Small, humorous sites being suppressed by a large company is a story too good for the press to miss.
We must fight this, if we don't then we can expect all of our favourite sites, including Slashdot to disappear.
No april fools joke (Score:1)
Slashdot doesn't slander Microsoft. Slashdot is a news service. Very rarely Slashdot has its own pieces, and usually they don't even come close to mentioning Microsoft. And all the posts are (in case you've missed the small type): "Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest © 1997-99 Rob Malda." So Rob doesn't have any worries.
Log
What have you done with the REAL MEEPT!!? (Score:1)
Nightmares of Bloom County and Donald Trump (Score:1)
For those who need a little catching up here, back in the 80's there was a comic strip by Berke Breathed called Bloom County. You know, Bill the Cat, Opus the Penguin, Milo, Oliver, Steve Dallas, etc. One of the funniest comic strips I ever enjoyed. The strip was obviously the model for User Friendly as the characters and drawing style of Iliad is all too similar; the style of drawing humans and the "newspaper clipping" pictures hanging on the wall are most of it. Not that I'm throwing any stones at Iliad for this, I actually quite enjoy that style and I'm glad that it is being used for a strip that I like.
Around 1989 or 1990, Donald Trump was in the peak of his popularity. On the cover of every magazine and newspaper out there as one of the richest men in America, he was quite a target, much like Bill Gates and Microsoft is today. Mr. Breathed, like any good satirist, took this opportunity to make a lot of people laugh at (of course) Mr. Trump's expense. Many public figures in the past have been subject to such ridicule, but Donald Trump aparently didn't have much of a sense of security or humor. Mr. Trump, in an effort to end this "public humiliation" (like it really was hurting his business) decided to buy out the syndicate which controlled Bloom County (United Feature Syndicate? can't quite remember) and told Mr. Breathed that he had two weeks to shut down the strip.
I say that there is quite a similarity here in situations.
Bloom County was a hard hitting humorous comic strip that poked fun at the richest man in America. Donald Trump was an extremely wealthy and powerful businessman in America that had the ability to push (or buy) people out of business.
User Friendly is a hard hitting humorous comic strip (and strikingly similar resemblence to Bloom County, not that there's anything wrong with that from my perspective) that is poking fun at the richest man in America. Bill Gates (and thus Microsoft) are one of the most powerful entities in the corporate world that has the ability to push (or buy) people out of the business.
Are we seeing something now?
<RANTNRAVE>
My feeling is that this disgusts me. Freedom of speech is one of the things that makes this country great. Capitalism is also another great thing, and I have to give some respect to Microsoft in that light (all personal feelings aside- please, I'm a Linux user myself, and I am not instigating ANYTHING towards pro or con Microsoft here). Other people and companies get similar treatment every day and most people can take a joke. Yes, what is said in the comic strip may be on a different plane than a typical personal attack (since it deals with a corporation), but isn't it the same? A corporation and a person are treated somewhat as similar entities in business law, so how can a corporation get away with this obvious bending of the first amendment?
I guess the answer would be lawyers; they can tie someone up in legal proceedings that, regardless of fault, can cause the victim to lose valuable time and/or money trying to claim their innocence. (see: McDonalds case from London about 3 years ago; innocent protestors in front of a store ended up in a long and way overblown legal battle for something which they were completely in their rights to do, but the lawyers of a huge corporation were able to make it hurt).
</RANTNRAVE>
Well, I guess I'm getting a little more emotional here that necessary, but I think I said what I intended to say. Flame away...
This had better be a joke! (Score:1)
If this is a joke I hope they don't get into trouble with MicroSquish because many people are blaming them even though they may not have done anything.
US? (Score:1)
Nahhh... if he were in Quebec, it would be believable for the Office de la Langue Francaise to pull that seeing as they do all the time. But the Canadian government on a federal basis doesn't require mirroring except of its own sites.
Nightmares of Bloom County and Donald Trump (Score:1)
UF is *NOT* only on the web anymore. As any UF fanatic knows, it has been being printed in the National Post for around a month now. Granted, the NP doesn't exactly have a wide coverage...
For all you non-Canadians, the National Post is the paper started by good ole' Conrad Black aimed to be a national paper for all of Canada. It has articl... ahem, submissions from writers for all the major newspapers in the country. Plus, they're handing it out for free in the metro in Montreal, so I've finally read some of it. Hey, any Montrealers out there wanna speculate on whether they'll end up using the Gazette's schoolboy labourers to get subscriptions?
About the lawyer's name... (Score:1)
Hmmm... the evidence mounts.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
Nightmares of Bloom County and Donald Trump (Score:1)
The wheel is turning but the hamster is dead.
About the lawyer's name... (Score:1)
Here's another theory:
Guy who runs BeDope: Mike (Michael)
Guy who runs Segfault: Scott
hrmm, suddenly we realized where the name came from...
and no one really knows Illiad's real name, do they?
Damn, I can't believe I'd been taken.
What about Dilbert? (Score:1)
somewhere other than in the US. To the extent that Illiad remains the author and remains in the
States, this may not help but if he's game, I know we are.
People, check the date (Score:1)
if it turns out that this is s'posed to be a joke
I shan't be laughing.
Sure.. (Score:1)
It's gonna be like this all day.. be prepared. =)
People, check the date (Score:1)
People, check the date (Score:1)
Yeah, I guess it's too much to assume that Illiad could coordinate with the guy who runs Segfault and whatever other sites are down.. we've given them too much credit for being clever.
[/sarcasm]
If it were 100 sites, yeah, I could see your point, but 3? Hell, that's two emails and 2 response emails minimum to set this up. No sweat. And as for the set-up time.. go check out any of the AFD archive sites, you'll find -very- elaborate and well-planned stunts there..
LucasArts?? (Score:1)
Bedope, Segfault, and UFie is all April 1st Jokes (Score:1)
Very suspect... (Score:1)
C'mon it's april fools day (Score:1)
- Darchmare
- Axis Mutatis, http://www.axismutatis.net
Now let's think about it...Apple (Score:1)
To be honest, I think it is all an April Fool's joke and am a bit embarassed that I was one of the "600" that submitted the story of UF being down. This is after I laughed at the concerned callers of a local radio station after they ran a story about the "Internet Clean Up day" today in order to clean up the mess of the Melissa Virus and to test Y2K issues.
Still, if it is true, I don't think it is Microsoft(they don't need too much more bad publicity and besides...Dilbert is still around) or LucasArts. Anyone else think it could be Apple?
Userfriendly often makes fun of the iMac(iWhack) which is Apple's cashcow and baby right now. I think we all know how they try to protect their copyrights. This also ties in BeDope (in a fashion). Not sure where Segfault fits in as I only learned of them yesterday...after they were turned off.
Happy April Fools' Day and let's all hope it is just a joke on us.
How about a poll?
1) It's all a hoax
2) It's Microsoft's fault
3) It's LucasArts's fault
4) It's Apple's fault
5) sunspots, dude
6) This poll sucks/Rob sucks/Slashdot sucks
If this is a joke... (Score:1)
--
I also sent in the sad news (Score:1)
Now excuse me please while I go wipe the egg off my face.
Profoundly Clever Joke get ACLU in on the act (Score:1)
No april fools joke (Score:1)
The 'as-yet-unnamed' complainant is Microsoft's legal department. Illiad has been hassled by them for the past week.
If Illiad is hassled by MS, how long until
Sites taken down (Score:1)
Hmmm (Score:1)
What can we do to Help? (Score:1)
People, check the SCORE (Score:1)
Gotta be a joke. (Score:1)
Second, isn't it just a little suspicious how similar the explanations looked at each site? Formulaic, almost.
Headlines: Productivity increases. (Score:1)
film at 11
Who? (Score:1)
I know M$ is the usual target of UserFriendly gags, but you'd think they'd have had enough bad press lately, and have no need to pull stunts like these to get some more...
Wouter
Vacation? (Score:1)
Tom
Very suspect... (Score:1)
Michael Scott DeWitt = MicroSoft Do It.
Oh well. Slow morning.
Lawyer a Minnesota porn star? (Score:1)
NOOOOOOOOOoooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Score:1)
*oops* well, even if it is a joke... (Score:1)
ah well, even if it is a joke, Its a little to close to home.
the bastards (Score:1)
This is *humor*
funny.... you know, ha-ha?
like my wife said, eveyrone is free to make fun of the president, politicians, etc, but God forbid they poke fun at MicroSloth (or other corp with expensive lawyers.)
bastards
funny.... (Score:1)
Now let's think about it...Apple (Score:1)
remind me not to check any web pages early in the morning, my brain just doesn't work right, damn holidays sneaking up on me like that.
April 1... otherwise know as April Fool's... (Score:1)
Now, who'll join me in supporting Linus to buy a Compaq Dynamouse for his laptop to be recharged? The power in Russia is said to be flakey at best...
This portraying has a reasoning (Score:1)
So actually, LA is obliged to sue these sites under this agreement even if they do not want to...
Misplaced Humor (Score:1)
Implying than any company is doing this even without making direct reference to a specific company can have major backlash and I don't think that's the sort of publicity any of them want. True, the timing implies that it was a huge setup for an even larger April Fools joke, but then again, it could just be bad timing of the courts.
We won't know til at least tommorow... Til then try not to get too hot under the collar, and for crist sake, stop the script kiddies from doin anything stupid if you can...
Zanthor
Moderation fails us! (Score:1)
Since this is one of the stronger pieces of evidence on this topic, I wish it were at least moderated at 2. Now I can't even find his article even though I have my threshhold at -1. *sigh*
In other news... (Score:1)
C'mon it's april fools day (Score:1)
There's a new one today - "IP Over Avian Carriers With Quality Of Service", RFC 2549.
Also RFC 2550, which addresses the Y10K problem.
A well planned April Fool's Day Joke. (Score:1)
Still kudos to UF and SegFault for banding together on April Fool's Day and providing entertainment.
Those three sites aren't alone (Score:1)
Cheap Trick! (Score:1)
As an aside, I'd like to get this code that detects my sexual orientation, because I don't know what it is. Also, exactly what encoding is that? Base65536? IEEE floating-point?
BTW, we released XFree86 4.0 today. It's got antialiasing, ability to switch client windows between displays, and true 3-D support with both OpenGL and Pex for over a dozen 3-D accelerator cards. Go to the XFree86 project webserver [xfree86.org] and check it out.
Cheers,
Joshua.
I've been had! (Score:1)
Well, at least not until tommorrow when I can start feeding my DustPuppy and Iambe addiction again. ;->
RIOT!!!!!!! (Score:1)
viva la revolucion!!!!!!!!!
C'mon it's april fools day (Score:1)
Silly American.
UF is actually in Vancouver, which is in the Pacific Time Zone.
In other news... (Score:1)
If they're not in trouble now... (Score:1)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
It's a CONSPIRACY!
Top ten reasons why it's not real (Score:1)
April Fool's (Score:1)
re:Lets start up a posse (Score:1)
What do you guys think a legal team to defend the GNU community? Do you think its feasible?
negahban@home.com
Re: What can we do to Help? (Score:1)
cnn. redherring. nytimes.
the more we can publicise this,
the more the public will be outraged,
get involved. at least it will show
support.
the bastards (Score:1)
What can we do? Is it that current times will
force linux users and consumers to take
it up the ass if a corperation [microsoft.com] is big enough?
Does it mean that small free web sites that deliever orignal content [userfriendly.com]
with large followings will be forced to just quit and give up domains
if any sizeable company with money wants the domain?
In recent times we've seen stories on here of
companies demanding web sites because the domain
was a trademark violation even though the site
had existed well before the creation of the
demanding business.
We've also seen the trademarking of just plain old
stupid shit. I'm waiting for a patent on eating
and a trademark on words like cheeseburger (so
you can no longer use the word eating and will be
liable for a lawsuit if you put cheeseburger on a menu).
So. What Am I Rambling About? This wonderful
captilist economy we (US citizens) live in is
great for the goings-on of real life, but is not
ready to handle a free self ruled internet and
will, as long as it runs unchecked, try to apply
US rules of business to a medium never meant for business.
-Z
suggestion: move UF and SegFault to a server in the netherlands or other country not subject to US laws.
Noooooo!! (Score:1)
Ahhh no reason to live (Score:1)
Who? (Score:1)
Was one responsible for all three?
If there weren't another joke on /. already... (Score:1)
(Let's hope I'm the fool =)
--> Erik
People, check the date (Score:1)
"Crying Wolf" would be an appropriate term for it.
If it's "for real," then I hope that all of the sites involved file countersuits.
People, check the date (Score:2)
People, check the date (Score:3)
MEEPT!! (Score:3)
Uh, Uh, Uh.... ohhhh [theregister.co.uk]
This proves that the new test'ment bible was written before Jesus was born.
MEEPT!!