Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

News for nerds, stuff that matters

CrossOver Plugin 1.0 Demo Version

Posted by Hemos on Mon Nov 05, 2001 03:14 PM
from the look-at-the-purty-pictures dept.
jwnewman writes "CodeWeavers has released the Demo version of CrossOver plugin." I bought the regular version when it first came out, just to try it out. It's pretty impressive - I've only had some problems with it under Konqueror, but that's had more to do with my plugin setup. The demo version is a full version, but with nags in it. It's well worth checking out.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold:
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • Programs Like These (Score:5, Insightful)

    by artlu (265391) <artlu.artlu@net> on Monday November 05 2001, @03:18PM (#2524287) Homepage Journal
    Personally, i feel programs like these are great. However, having to pay for them takes the purpose out of any free operating system. I'd just assume use windows for those programs, rather then pay a company to allow me to use those programs on a different operating system. Although, i understand why these programs have to be paid for. With the current American Economy, noone will develop anything without a monetary incentive. I just hope somewhere there is someone with extra time who will design a program such as this out of the goodness of his/her heart!
    AJ
  • I dunno.... (Score:1, Insightful)

    by shanek (153868) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:22PM (#2524313) Homepage
    For some reason, it bugs me that I have to pay money to use free (beer) plugins on a free (beer&speech) OS. Nice that they have a demo, though. I'll give it a shot; maybe it is worth the price.
  • Reasonably priced.. (Score:3, Interesting)

    by A Commentor (459578) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:23PM (#2524320) Homepage
    At $19.95, it seems reasonably priced, but it adds up since I have several Linux Boxes at home...

    Maybe they should have some 'home' (non-business) site license for about $25 ;-)

  • by CptnKirk (109622) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:25PM (#2524327)
    I really like the CrossOver plugin. Specifically it give me access to Quicktime and Shockwave content not previously available to Linux users. Sure there are other reasons for this, and it would be nice to target the root of this problem, however this is left for another discussion.

    My question is whether others out there think this is a good software model? Personally I think it is. They have identified a genuine lack of service which they provide. They provide this service by building on open source technology, namely wine, and then provide a closed for profit products on top of this technology. The revenue generated by these products allow for greater development in the underlying tech (again namely wine) while still providing the desired service, the Windows plugin support.

    Aside from the "well these plugins are free on windows, we shouldn't have to pay for a product that lets us use them in Linux" comments. Do people have anything else they'd like to say about the CrossOver plugins or their business model?

  • bought it but (Score:1)

    by pyretic22 (247450) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:26PM (#2524335)
    Quicktime takes over my .png files, and netscape can handle that quite well. For quicktime movies it's quite impressive though. Just need mediaplayer support and then I'm all set :)
    • Re:bought it but (Score:4, Informative)

      by NutscrapeSucks (446616) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:00PM (#2524473)
      Open the QT control panel and go to Plug-in settings (or right-click on a movie).

      Then click MIME Settings and unselect anything you don't want QuickTime to take over. (I think more recent QuickTime versions don't intercept PNG by default.)
      [ Parent ]
    • 1 reply beneath your current threshold.
  • Winzip (Score:2, Redundant)

    by Spy Hunter (317220) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:27PM (#2524339) Journal
    This demonstration version will let you use all of the CrossOver functionality, except that from time to time, you will be given a reminder to purchase our product.

    So basically, this will be like Winzip: everyone uses it, nobody pays for it. I wonder how long until the crack comes out...

    • Re:Winzip by Some guy named Chris (Score:3) Monday November 05 2001, @03:51PM
    • Re:Winzip by oddjob (Score:1) Monday November 05 2001, @04:12PM
      • Re:Winzip by shepd (Score:1) Monday November 05 2001, @04:27PM
    • 1 reply beneath your current threshold.
  • Download FTP Link (Score:1, Informative)

    by Hexact (22921) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:30PM (#2524360)
    The links for HTTP and FTP download don't work for me but I found the directory anyway [codeweavers.com] Clem.
  • Satisfied User (Score:4, Informative)

    by ChaosDiscordSimple (41155) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:31PM (#2524368) Homepage

    I purchased Crossover [codeweavers.com] several weeks ago and have been completely satisfied. Quicktime [apple.com] works great. Being able to watch the Fellowship of the Ring [apple.com] trailer on Linux is great! Shockwave [macromedia.com] works well for many sites. (In particular, Shockwave plugins for stuff like 3D has problems.) Codeweaver's tech support mailing list is great, the developers reply quickly and are very helpful.

    While I would prefer that Crossover be free software [fsf.org], at least Codeweavers [codeweavers.com] is contributing most of their improvements back to the main Wine [winehq.com] project. Pretty much only the Crossover plugin itself is proprietary software. Buying Crossover is a great way to support the development of Wine and get Quicktime support on Linux right now.

    • Re:Satisfied User by kindbud (Score:1) Monday November 05 2001, @03:40PM
      • Re:Satisfied User (Score:4, Insightful)

        by ChaosDiscordSimple (41155) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:55PM (#2524445) Homepage

        Why? Does it look any better than watching it on Windows? Was it easier?

        It looks the same. Compared to rebooting into Windows, it's significantly easier.

        I spend most of my time under Linux. I used only reboot into Windows for games and Quicktime. Now I only reboot into Windows for games. (And thanks to my Playstation 2, I don't boot into Windows for games very often any more.)

        Why not just get Windows?

        I have Windows, but I don't like it. I'm perfectly happy working under Linux. Crossover allows me to satisify my desire to watch Quicktime videos under Linux. Seems like a good match to me.

        Why support a software vendor that refuses to support your favorite platform?

        Because I'm a realist. Maybe as Linux's share grows we'll see Quicktime for Linux, but that's not going to happen in the near future. Refusing to use non-native software does nothing to improve the situation.

        Or do you consider "it doesn't break under Wine" to be good enough?

        I use Linux. I want to watch Quicktime videos. Apple is not going to port Quicktime Player to Linux in the forseeable future. Crossover solves my problem. So yes, it's good enough for now. One step at a time...

        [ Parent ]
      • Re:Satisfied User by djoham (Score:2) Monday November 05 2001, @03:55PM
      • Re:Satisfied User by Myddrin (Score:2) Monday November 05 2001, @03:59PM
      • Re:Satisfied User by dinivin (Score:1) Monday November 05 2001, @04:07PM
      • Re:Satisfied User by Bradee-oh! (Score:1) Monday November 05 2001, @04:19PM
      • Re:Satisfied User by Sloppy (Score:1) Monday November 05 2001, @10:35PM
  • this seems kind of iffy... (Score:2, Insightful)

    by liquidsin (398151) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:33PM (#2524377) Homepage
    I think the crossover plugin is a great idea, but I'm not sure how many people will go for the idea of paying to use plugins on linux that would be free to use under windows (AFAIK, those plugins are all free downloads for win). Kind of an odd turn, using the free Win version instead of paying for the Linux version...
  • Hamster Havoc! (Score:1)

    by dunham (35989) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:41PM (#2524418) Homepage
    Note that the movie from the quicktime standalone screenshot [codeweavers.com] on their site is CmdrTaco's "Hamster Havoc".
    • 1 reply beneath your current threshold.
  • Exceptional timing, folks (Score:3, Informative)

    by fobbman (131816) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:43PM (#2524424) Homepage
    I cannot imagine a better day to release this than today [slashdot.org].

    Capitalize on all the frustrated geeks and their inability to find a non-Linux box to view the teaser.

    Lemonade always sells better when it's hot outside.

  • Experiences with Crossover (Score:5, Informative)

    by digitalhermit (113459) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:51PM (#2524431) Homepage
    I purchased Crossover when it was released. There were a few initial setup problems but their support is very good. I checked their archives and found an answer to my problem (pugger.so was conflicting with the QuickTime plugin in Netscape). Though I didn't report any problems I received emails from their support staff just to make sure everything was fine.

    Performance is, for the most part, indistinguishable from a native Windows version on my 900MhZ Athlon. I understand that there is some initial delay the first time the plugin is started on slower machines. It's been fine for me though.

    Netscape *seems* to be a touch more unstable with the plugin installed. There are occasional long delays but I have not confirmed that this is not just some DNS timeout or other Netscape instability (I'm running 4.78... I have not tried installing on 6.1).
  • Spread of Mal-formed code (Score:3, Funny)

    by Motheius (449386) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:54PM (#2524442)
    "But even better, you can open this type of attachements directly from any mail client."

    I am guessing it is only a matter of time before someone writes code that will wreak havoc on the linux community.
  • damn nice stuff. (Score:3, Informative)

    by Xzzy (111297) <sether@@@tru7h...org> on Monday November 05 2001, @03:58PM (#2524462) Homepage
    I generally don't buy software without having tested it out yet, and just playing with this software for ten minutes is more than enough time to justify the twenty bucks for the thing.

    First time I've been truly impressed with some piece of software for Linux in the past nine months or so, and this is to the point where twenty bucks for the full version seems like it's UNDER priced.

    Download the installer, run it, press a few buttons inside the config gui, and suddenly you can watch all the movies on quicktime.com.. with no stuttering or slowness.

    Damn fine piece of work guys.
  • CrossingOver Plugin (Score:5, Funny)

    by Anonymous Coward on Monday November 05 2001, @04:00PM (#2524469)
    Unfortunately, I accidentally downloaded the CrossingOver plugin by mistake, and now all the Web pages I view ask me a lot of vague questions about dead relatives.
  • missing something (Score:1)

    by SupahVee (146778) <superv AT mischievousgeeks DOT net> on Monday November 05 2001, @04:05PM (#2524495) Journal
    I must be missing something, so flame away, thou trolling moderators, but where the hell is the full download at? Codeweavers seems to have a nice product if it works, but every download page links right back on top of itself, which is just about as annoying as trying to untangle scotch tape.
  • OK, OK (Score:1, Funny)

    by Anonymous Coward on Monday November 05 2001, @04:05PM (#2524496)
    You win, I'm turning communist. I guess I really had no choice. :(
  • It works (Score:1)

    by Turmio (29215) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:06PM (#2524501) Homepage
    Wow, I'm impressed, it actually works quite well. They got my $19.95.
  • by 7-Vodka (195504) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:08PM (#2524512)
    Those nag boxes are really annoying, they pop up every few seconds and completely obscure what you're seeing for ages.

    One for every window you have open too.

    Friendly reminder screens as they are called couldn't be further from the truth.

    The quicktime pluggin seems to be working fairly well.

    It's not really usable unless u buy it i guess.

    Not too bad if you're using the player and not the plugin, since you can move the screen away from the nagboxes and still view it.

  • Another happy user... (Score:5, Informative)

    by Anonymous Coward on Monday November 05 2001, @04:12PM (#2524540)
    If it counts, i'm another happy user of the CrossOver Plugin. What got me to jump on board and fork over cash for the 1.0 release? Easy. truth in advertising. [codeweavers.com]

    They made a point of telling the truth about their product and are making all due effort to support and enhance it. Great company who are doing a needed service for the Community. Not only that, they are a major supporter of the wine project. Got a few bucks? They deserve our support.
    As for me, the software has been absolutely flawless. I did have some issues on a Mandrake box but it ended up being Crossover was fighing a battle with Plugger. One minor plugin deletion / restart later it installed like a dream.
    Support the community! They deserve it!
    • Tricked me by RedWizzard (Score:2) Monday November 05 2001, @06:50PM
  • Is this legal? (Score:1)

    by cbwsdot (212913) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:19PM (#2524574) Homepage
    Quicktime in Linux?! Is this legal? Has Apple sanctioned this? What about the people who own the rights to codecs, such as the Sorenson codec. It seems like something would have to be reverse engineered...
  • by Mustang Matt (133426) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:19PM (#2524577)
    If only these would have been released under some opensource license. These plugins could have been implemented in the next version of SuSE/Redhat/Debian/name your dist. and would have really bridged a gap for getting windows users comfortable with using linux on the desktop.

    Oh well, it's still cool news.
  • by Cirrocco (466158) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:21PM (#2524584) Homepage
    ...it works really well considering the layers it has to pass through.
    Yeah, it's a little slow but it's worth it to be able to watch Quicktime movies on my Linux Box. My friend and I both bought a copy because it isn't re-distributable but he sees potential for using it for other plug-in installations so it may be more useful than first thought.
    If you've got the $20 to spare then grab it. It probably won't be the worst $20 spent in your life even if you don't use it much.
  • by BoarderPhreak (234086) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:31PM (#2524640)
    If money is a limiting factor and you can only have one system, or OS - than this is a good solution. Or if you absolutely have to have side-by-side operability.

    Otherwise, I'd say until Linux is there (and I hate to say it, but it's not, yet) than either dual boot, or think about another machine for your "day to day" stuff, and other for whatever reason...

    I've always said, use the best tool to get the job done. If you're compromising here or there, than you're not really doing that.

  • For those that need it... (Score:3, Insightful)

    by cr0sh (43134) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:33PM (#2524651) Homepage
    This sounds like a great product. I don't understand the people here who disparage it because you have to pay for it - there is nothing that says you can't run payware alongside (or on top of, as the case may be) open source and *gasp* GPL'd software. Don't come down on it because it isn't "free" or Free.

    Personally, I don't have a real need for this product, so I won't be buying it - I really don't ever see many QT trailers or whatnot to justify it, and all the Shockwave stuff can go out the window as well - give me quality content and information, I say.

    I would much rather see the development of an open source video codec on par with Sorensen, and have it become well developed and widely used, but I tend to doubt such will happen, as so much of the tech involved in such an endevor is locked up in patents.

    My main concern about such software (like this plugin) is that related to security - whether any exploits could be run against it to gain root access, or something. I tend to doubt this, and if you are running as a user, and you have a good firewall you should be mostly protected - but it is something I always have in the back of my mind...
  • Oh great! (Score:1)

    by dickDragon (227357) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:33PM (#2524653)
    Now even the slashgeeks will be moving from
    universally readable web pages to proprietary formats.
  • Finnaly a company that gets it! (Score:4, Insightful)

    by smammon (88123) on Monday November 05 2001, @04:52PM (#2524756)
    An actual installer! It understands the differences in Distros and even puts links/launchers/icons into the menu systems of BOTH KDE and Gnome! Wholy cow!

    This is something that developers have needed to do forever. Forget the RPM vs DEB vs Tarball wars and make it easy for the user dammit!

    We all gripe about Micro$oft developing software that is just bloated eye candy with crappy (or no) guts. IMHO Linux developers have been too busy neating up the guts to notice that no one uses their program beacuse it takes two friggin days to satisfy all of the needed dependancies just to compile and then annother two to figure out where the damn thing's files should reside.

    Oh ya, after the install the product actually works as advertised too.

    These guys get my $20!!! Kudos Codeweavers!
  • how a REAL UNIX user would do it (Score:3, Insightful)

    by rasactive (528598) <onewland@gmaiSLACKWAREl.com minus distro> on Monday November 05 2001, @04:53PM (#2524762)
    wget http://movie.url/movie.mov -O movie.mov && wine C:\whatever\quicktime.exe

    Of course I'm sure some Dennis Ritchie wannabe is gonna reply to this and tell me how to do it with piping (you know you want to).
  • I tried it, its well worth it (Score:3, Interesting)

    by Christianfreak (100697) on Monday November 05 2001, @05:02PM (#2524822) Homepage Journal
    Installed flawlessly, nice configurator, it looks nice and best of all IT WORKS. I was skeptical at first but then I got to see the Star Wars trailer. I'm going to shell out the $20 for it. Try it out you might be as surprised as I was.

    On a side note they don't disable the demo after 30 days. It looks like its more of an on your honor system. But it does put little messages to buy the software at the beginning of the movies. (At least in quicktime).

    Again though, this looks like it was well worth it and the $20 goes to Wine.
  • by mj6798 (514047) on Monday November 05 2001, @05:03PM (#2524823)
    On the one hand, this allows people to lessen their dependence on proprietary operating systems. On the other hand, it means that some already proprietary formats become even more deeply entrenched as there is less incentive for anyone to create and use alternatives.

    On balance, I'd say: don't use it unless you really have a very compelling need. View MS Office documents in StarOffice or AbiWord and submit bug reports for any problems you find; that's how those programs get better. As for Quicktime, complain to the web site using it and ask them to use an open format instead (in fact, do that whether or not you actually have a Quicktime viewer).

  • CrossOver Plugin 1.0.1 released (NEW) (Score:2, Informative)

    by CptnKirk (109622) on Monday November 05 2001, @05:09PM (#2524854)
    Released 11/05/01, this update [codeweavers.com] fixes many bugs in the 1.0 release. Install was painless, and it seems to work great.

    List of Fixes in 1.0.1

    • Support for Powerpoint Viewer 97/2000.
    • Support for ModPlug.
    • Now available as a demo version.
    • Better handling of xalf via a new LDPreload option.
    • Fixed the 'XtDisplayToApplicationContext undefined symbol' that appeared with Mozilla 0.9.4 and later releases.
    • Fixed an incompatibility with the SVGA driver of the XFree 86 servers.
    • Fixed the title corruption that was occuring in QuickTimePlayer in 24bpp.
    • Fixed the QuickTime plugin progress bar behavior in 24bpp.
    • Fixed a clipboard related lockup that could happen during QuickTime installation.
    • Fixed the handling of file names containing spaces. Especially useful with the Microsoft viewers.
    • Updated to the new QuickTime installer and fixed the installer update issues.
    • Fixed the TechTV channel QuickTimePlayer freeze. All channels should work now.
    • Added 'out-of-the-box' printing support.
    • Added a quicktimeplayer.sh script to let you start the
    • QuickTimePlayer from the command line.
    • Added traces to make it easier to diagnose font problems.
    • Added the regapi Wine tool and a script, regapi.sh to launch it more easily.
    • Improved cleanup_crossover.sh to really kill all Wine processes.
    • Improved winedbg support to help us better diagnose problems.
    • Many other improvements in the pluginsetup interface, the documentation and various other bug fixes.
  • by Chris Colohan (29716) on Monday November 05 2001, @05:18PM (#2524897) Homepage
    I just tried it out under RedHat 7.2. When I tried Quicktime it had no problem playing movies, but there is no sound. I tried using the powerpoint viewer on a presentation of mine, and all the fonts were messed up.

    So it still has a few rough edges. If it worked flawlessly, they would get my money right away...
    • 1 reply beneath your current threshold.
  • by Junta (36770) on Monday November 05 2001, @05:21PM (#2524902)
    Cool, now I have something to play movs :) So now I can play mpg/avi/asf/wmv with PyhtonTheater, DVD with Ogle (more likely my PS2), realmedia with the realone preview release (XVideo support :). What this plugin lacks that all my other players has is XVideo support... Of course it is undertsandable, but I won't be kicking my movs into fullscreen any time soon..
  • by Dirtside (91468) on Monday November 05 2001, @05:25PM (#2524926) Homepage Journal
    I installed the demo on my Linux box (Mandrake 7.2 using IceWM as my window manager). Crossover added itself to my IceWM menu file, except instead of simply *adding* itself to my menu file, it copied the default menu file *over* my menu file and then added itself to *that*. Basically, all of my custom changes to the default menu file were lost when I installed Crossover.

    Aside from that, it works great (although Apple seems to have found a way to make the Quicktime 5 plugin never cache a downloaded movie on your local machine, which is annoying as fuck -- I want to view it whenever I want, without having to re-download it every time. Can you say "waste of bandwidth"?). I don't know if I'd use the Crossover plugin enough to justify paying for it, but we'll see.
  • Codeweavers Wine (Score:1)

    by npietraniec (519210) <npietran@nosPam.resistive.net> on Monday November 05 2001, @06:02PM (#2525097) Homepage
    Maybe a little off-topic, but when is Codeweavers [codeweavers.com] going to release another preview version on Wine 1.0? Their "preview versions" work better than the snapshots at the Wine page. [winehq.org]

    inquiring minds want to know.
    • 1 reply beneath your current threshold.
  • My 2 cents (Score:2)

    by matty (3385) on Monday November 05 2001, @06:31PM (#2525208) Homepage
    Install was mostly painless, but I did have to poke around a bit and 'activate' a couple of the plugins. Joe Average User might have some problems, but we're definitely getting closer.

    Those "friendly reminders" are anything but. Damned annoying, IMO. Also, my fonts in Flash animations looked suspiciously like the default font in Netscape (I use Moz0.9.5) after I installed it. I uninstalled it after a few short minutes, mostly because of the annoying reminders, and the Flash fonts reverted back to their previous appearance.

    While I do appreciate the usefulness of this product, Flash and Real already work for me, and that added to the annoying font issue make it not worth my $19.95 yet.

    YMMV...........
  • unfortunately, skipstone breaks with quicktime installed...
    even though mozilla works fine.
  • it's great, but... (Score:1)

    by Quickening (15069) on Tuesday November 06 2001, @12:31AM (#2526347) Homepage
    I bought it the day it came out, and don't have any problem with the idea. I do notice a certain sluggish instability using it which...reminds me of windows! I got 2 more windows plugins working with it, however, DANGER!, twice now the shockwave plugin has locked up the kernel process table! Hard to believe but quite obvious when it happened. The kernel crashed soon after. I wrote support but go no help. Guess I'll try the update.
  • distros (Score:1)

    by dmwilcox (534497) <dmwilcox@[ ].net ['gmx' in gap]> on Tuesday November 06 2001, @01:02AM (#2526404) Homepage
    this is the only time anyone will ever hear me say this, but this is a good thing for distros to take care of for their users. i mean this is actually something to advertise, i mean really how can you really listen to a linux distro advertising about software you can download for free? anyway if distrobutions bought licenses in bulk and put a license in with a box distro, then you have the licensed software, and the linux company is supported by charging some overhead, because through buying in bulk, the price should drop. daniel all unix baby! but sadly not an advocate of linux for the common man. =-(
  • by antdude (79039) on Tuesday November 06 2001, @01:29AM (#2526455) Homepage Journal
    Is anyone able to stream videos in Netscape Communicator v4.78? about:plugins show MOV and QT is off. I checked my settings and they are checked. How about you guys?

    Thank you in advance.
  • by h4b1t (527236) on Tuesday November 06 2001, @09:06AM (#2527138) Homepage
    sooner or later someone on the konqueror team (or some random someone somewhere, probably coding it right now) will release a free equivalent of this program, i really think...
  • Re:Sweet! (Score:2, Insightful)

    by Torawk (321146) on Monday November 05 2001, @03:30PM (#2524357)
    I don't know exactly what you mean by "all popular quicktime plugins" but I just installed it (before the story was posted) and it works great for the trailers at apple.com/trailers. [apple.com]

    The demo just has the annoying msgs that appear over the movie, they do go away so you can see the full thing but atleast the msgs are semi-entertaining.... :)

    -Torawk
    [ Parent ]
  • I'll bet a lot of Sun employees will be surreptiously buying it so they can effectively communicate with the outside (MSFT) world...

    You won't see it on Solaris. Ever (unless maybe while on a LSD type trip Codeweavers ports Wine to Solaras x86.)

    Wine is tighed as tightly to x86 as Windows is. But Wine does have features for setting up a wine server type thing for other platforms. I don't know the full details though.

    But anything you run under wine is just an X11 client, so export DISPLAY=etc:0 and you're off and running...
    [ Parent ]
  • by Junta (36770) on Monday November 05 2001, @09:10PM (#2525803)
    PythonTheater plays wmv, http://xtheater.sourceforge.net/, as well as mpg, asf, and avi.
    [ Parent ]
  • 21 replies beneath your current threshold.