Human life is, for matters of public policy, frequently assigned a value based on a number of factors.
I propose that when a person is made ill, permanently debilitated, or dies of a disease for which there is a vaccine available, we use that value to calculate a fine to issue to all unvaccinated people without a valid medical exemption.
It'll get expensive quickly, and the fewer anti-vaxxers, the more expensive it will get until they give in or end broke and dependent on government assistance - which will come with a vaccination requirement. The fine should be adjusted for income and wealth, to ensure rich anti-vaxxers suffer just as much as the poor ones.
Fuck 'em. I don't need my community at risk because of ignorant death fetishists.
And while we're at it, an unvaccinated child being affected should result in the full fine being specifically applied to the parents. When they run out of money, the state can take and raise their child. Which sucks for the kid, because the system sucks, but it's still better than polio.