Comment Re:Bygone days. (Score 1) 59
I think your points on Obama are good. I'd like a more clear explanation of what the senate would be without the 17th.
(I didn't like Obama, because I'm a screaming liberal and he was pretty darn conservative, turned wars into something run by lawyers and did a lot of killing of people with neither a real declaration of war nor due process which included them -- you can make all the practical arguments you like, but the evolution of that is Trump murdering people in the Gulf of Mexico with impunity. Biden was much better. I suspect Michelle Obama would have been a much better president than her husband. It's fantastic that we had someone brown as president, and embarrassing that we haven't had a woman.)
If the idea is that the party in power in the state should pick via a smoke-filled room the two senators... that doesn't seem to represent the interest of the state, either. The senate has two roles. It's the house of lords for the US -- intended to advise. The do NOT run as "I'm a smart guy and an elder statesman" which is clearly part of your point.
But the other role is just to get votes for the constitution 200 years ago. We wanted Rhode Island's vote, for example. The were worried about being dominated by Massachusetts, for example, because of the population size. The senate no longer is needed in that capacity, because small states are in enough numbers to work together, and that was not really fair in the first place.
It would be better to give all states 10 reps in the house plus more based on population than to make a whole house where every state gets the same weight.
The idea that states as governments need representation at all exists because before the civil war we were not a country -- we were a collection of tiny countries "The United States in America" -- after the war we became "The United States of America" (not official phrases, but look in document searches before and after the war). We don't have to protect fiefdoms. I am worried that repealing the 17th is aimed at strengthening fiefdoms.