I understand the *theory*, in the same way I understand the *theory* of the second amendment. But just like I cannot look on with anything other than horror and bafflement at the *actual consequences* of the theory being implemented for 2A, so I cannot look on with anything other than dismay and bafflement at the *actual consequences* of having small settlements run their own police departments.
And obviously, while the citizenry of a place can, in general and in principle, vote the bastards out, or up sticks and leave themselves, many types of consequence of the (ab)use of coercive state power are permanent and terrible. From disfigurements to deaths to many other sorts. So when a town kicks out its councillors or fires its police chief, it may simply be too late for an individual innocent citizen lying dead in the gutter thanks to an aggressive and badly trained cop who took against them.