Comment Re:Zillow is slow to aggregate Real listing data (Score 1) 36
because the interest rates have f***** everyone over
That statement lacks any kind of historical context. "Realtors in the market for over 2 to 3 decades" ought to recall that for long stretches of time, the interest rates we see today would have been seen as 1) normal, or 2) a bargain. The recency bias of seeing 3% a few years ago was a bonkers-crazy anomaly.
A 30-yr mortgage today comes in around 6.25%. As it so happens, that matches the introductory 5-yr rate on the ARM I used to buy my first house 20 years ago. My parents like to tell me that, when they purchased their home in the early 1980s, mortgage rates were around 12-15%! See here for historical data.
Higher mortgage rates do make it harder to buy a home. And for someone sitting pretty on a 3% rate from refinancing a few years ago (like myself), it makes selling not very appealing. But to say the higher rates of today "have f***** everyone over" is half wrong, and wrongly implies some grand conspiracy with malicious intent. Home ownership rates have hovered in the mid-60% range for decades, with almost no correlation to interest rates.
You need to also look to home prices for the "f***** everyone over". Those prices have increased at wild rates, doubling since the 2008 recession, and going crazy since COVID. The higher costs have various reasons, but it's mostly because of a serious supply shortage. That contributes at least as much to the "what's my monthly payment going to be?" as interest rates.
Consider $385k @ 3.7% - the average sale price at the average rate circa 4Q2019, just before COVID: monthly payment $1772.
Now consider $385k @ 6.5% - same price, but at today's rate: monthly payment $2433. Ouch.
Then, consider $515k @ 3.7% - today's average sale price at 4Q2019 rate: $2370. Also Ouch: the increase in home price is about as bad as the change in rates.
Finally: $515k @ 6.5% - today's average price at today's rate: $3255. Bloody hell!
The monthly mortgage payment has roughly doubled since COVID, but interest rates are just one part of the picture. You could whine about the Fed, but 30-year rates are more closely tied to the bond market than to the Fed rate. Those higher 30-year bond rates are driven by 1) uncertainty about the future, and 2) the US Government's wild, irresponsible deficits. You won't really be able to do much about interest rates. But you can do something about home prices by advocating for more home building and density. That's driven by state and local policy, which you do have some influence on.