Comment Wrong Diagnosis; Motivated Dishonesty. (Score 1) 58
Tivo broke Civilization.
The olds will remember.
In the early 80s, every American watched the same TV programs at the same time. LIve, broadcast TV. It was the national American culture. Everyone at work and at school the next morning talked about their shared experience and varying reactions to the BroadCast that The Party had shown them the prior night.
Cable TV - by offering a few more channels - had _some_ impact on the "breakup" of America.
But it was Tivo - mass-scale consumer time shifting. Americans no longer watched all the same propaganda at the same time.
The monoculture started to crack.
The rest of it is downstream from there. The bigs tried to retain their control of culture and opinion, but it became too fragmented and too decentralized. They couldn't.
Nobody is mad about the internet. They are mad they don't control the internet.