think of an Anabaptist family I know, not Amish but "on the spectrum" to Menonite. They have 11 children. I'm sure that our friend would say 'oh she's being kept barefoot and pregnant" but 13 years ago when my wife and I first met them, she said "I want to a dozen children" - and they're close. They are an incredible, loving family. And I believe the decision making is pretty joint in their home. Some members of an organization I'm in are Mennonite. Hard working, pleasant, clean, wonderful people.
I've never once said you can't have a large family if you want a large family. I've never once said large, Menonite, or Amish families cannot be successful or happy. AND, I've never once said people can't be happy or live lives of value and meaning within repressive, controlling systems. I've read, for example, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. People can be resilient and finding meaning and joy and happiness even in the most difficult of situations.
What I am saying is that these communities are patriarchal, that they are controlled by men, and that, by definition, this makes it a repressive society for women and girls. "Wonderful" depends on whether you fall in line with this societal structure and expectations, or if you buck the system. If you have any inkling that it might be possible to choose a different life, that your pathway may not be the one the community has chosen for you, then suddenly it doesn't seem so wonderful any more. And if that results in shunning and excommunication, then that is a very lonely and isolating and scary experience.
Imagine a life where your kids aren't on ADHD meds from when they are six months old because mommy and daddy are on Xanax and can't deal with them
ADHD meds are not approved for infants. Yes, there are instances where we have over medicated children. There are also many reports about Amish families whose children have not received the medical care they need to be healthy. Amish communities really vary in their approach to modern medicine, but there are many reports of Amish families declining needed cancer treatment for their children.