Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:No real need. (Score 1) 382

Since people use a handle on Slashdot how would a an HR search find you?
Plus if you read my suggestion you could still post as an AC if you wanted. You just might take a Karam hit for being a jerk if you acted like a jerk.
There is a checkbox right now on this post that allows me to post as an AC.

I use the same Handle most places because I want to stand by what I post.

Comment Re:No real need. (Score 1) 382

I agree that Slashdot's moderation system works better than most places.
I do not see how you could work out the id.

If I was to post as an AC and post a a troll and you block me it would only block me when I was posting as an AC.
It would not block me when posting as myself.
As to stopping ACs without a log in. Yes it would I do not see the issue with that. If you are posting something so sensitive that you do not want it tracked by a government level threat you should have be using a VPN/Tor/ so having a fake login on Slashdot that you only use for those posts seems like a no brainer.
After all you do not have to give any id info to get a slashdot ID.

Comment No real need. (Score 5, Insightful) 382

Slashdot could significantly reduce trolls by just making everyone login to comment.
Keep the ability to post as an AC but make these changes.
1. You still take the karma hit to your real name when you post a troll and get the good karma for good posts.
2. The ability to block the person when they are posting as an AC. The person blocking would still not know who they are blocking as it would just say AC on the blocked list.
It would not stop all the trolls but it seems like a good compromise solution for Slashdot.
BTW I do not block Slashdot ads since I want them to get paid and they have not put up any annoying video ads lately.

Comment Re:Some people... (Score 1) 457

I do not agree. What happens is you stop working for solutions and just become a tool. Time and time again people forget that the ends do not justify the means it does is give power to those that make power and wealth to those that are talking heads and professional activists who have no incentive to solve anything. That groups egos are stroked and pockets lined by conflict not solutions.

Comment Re:Implausible. (Score 1) 393

It is the free market. It is a variation of buying local.
Frankly a completely free market is a terrible idea anyway as it will almost always lead to monopoly that is bad for the consumer.

The way that the system needs to work is for the market to be free enough to allow competition while being regulated enough to prevent abuses. In this case the regulations look to be slanted to give an unfair advantage. The problem is ULA also has plants in the same states as SpaceX so they seem to be staying out of it. So now the correct tactic is publicity to bring this to light and for people to write their congress people to not let it happen. There is just no need to get too worked up about it or shocked. It is the way the system works and if you want it to work properly people need to give it some guidance.

Comment Re:Some people... (Score 1) 457

Actually I did make an error and left out pro nuclear in the list.
I am actually very fond of Open Source, Solar, and Wind as well as Nuclear.
And yes I find the right wing nuts just as annoying as the left wing nuts. If you want me to fill out the list there was the guy that when I tried to explain the benefits of bringing the US missionaries with Ebola to the US for treatment some one replied that they hoped the plane carrying them would crash on take off and kill them.

You can be pro many things but when you take to fanatic things go bad. A little bit of cost for being a nut job might just make online a better place.

Comment Re:Some people... (Score 1) 457

Actually I am pro both. Solar makes a good source of opportunistic power. It is terrible as baseload. WInd is much better as a baseload replacement but it still needs backing plants using natural gas.
I support reducing carbon output by replacing coal baseload plants with nuclear and wind with natural gas backing plants, and using solar to help reducing peaking loads during daylight hours.

But what does the opinion matter? Is one side or the other of the discussion worthy of threats of physical harm?

Comment Re:Some people... (Score 2) 457

"I would normally agree that people get offended too easily, but that's only when people express their honest opinion. "
It isn't just disagreeing. You may disagree with me all you want. The problem is that for a lot of people things like solar power, antinuclear, open source, and many other subjects seem to have taken the place of a religion for people.

I once had a commenter on slashdot say that they wanted to lock me in their basement and rape me. "I did reply that I was happily married and that was really not my thing".
The subject of the discussion was Solar vs Nuclear as a baseload solution!
Being a 49 year old male programer that threat was easy for me to dismiss. Had I been a 17 year old girl or boy that had been a victim of sexual assault in the past it would have been terrifying.

Comment Re:Jezebel? (Score 1) 299

You may disagree all you want.
The difference is when you get into threats of physical violence which has happened on slashdot to me. Throw in all sorts of pro Nazi and Klan comments and you can have a pretty hostile environment.

It is a tradeoff. I feel the good that ACs bring is far outweighed by the garbage they bring.
As too needing to grow a thicker skin, take a look at my id number. I have been on Slashdot for a very long time so my skin is pretty thick.

Comment Re:Jezebel? (Score 2) 299

Doesn't really matter. Frankly CNN's comment section makes me want to throw up.
The solution is simple. Make people have an ID that is sticky. I would like to see Slashdot not allow real ACs but instead allow people that want to post as ACs hide their ID but still take the Karma hit.

For most forums I really do not want to read what people will not stand by.
Of course not every forum needs to follow this rule. It would be up to the owners. Is the value of ACs worth the cost of ACs.

Slashdot Top Deals

"The fundamental principle of science, the definition almost, is this: the sole test of the validity of any idea is experiment." -- Richard P. Feynman

Working...