Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: Celebrating NASA problem solving (Score 1) 60

What *other* electronic hardware and software programming system has remained operational for 50 years, and still works today?

Some of my father's designs do. He was the most brilliant engineer I ever met. For him, reliability didn't mean the thing was mostly working, it meant, never failed.

One example of his design for reliability: most microprocessors have a reset line that brings the chip to a known state, and starts execution at a particular, fixed address. Most application-specific designs use that reset upon power-up and then design around software that runs continuously. My dad? He hooked up a 100 ms pulse oscillator to the reset line of the CPU in one series of instruments that are intended for very remote deployment, and wrote the software around that periodic reset to a fixed, known vector. So, no matter what messed-up state the program found itself in, it lasted for only a brief while. I have been told by people who need to occasionally visit and validate those remote trailers that the instruments he designed *always* work. The competitors, not so much.

Comment Re:Economics of Starlink (Score 1) 103

I have to wonder - do we even have enough stuff to haul to orbit to utilize all that? ...
This completely changes what we can build in orbit.

It sounds like you have (potentially) answered your own question here. If (and I agree it's a big if) it's possible for us to have some kind of solar system scale economy, then the "thousands of launches per year" likely becomes viable, a least during the period of bootstrapping said economy.

Comment Re:Economics of Starlink (Score 1) 103

NASA has an ace up its sleeve. If Starlink wants to keep launching from the US, they can be forced to provide x amount of launches per year and cost plus some percent.

That would violate the 5th amendment to the US constitution. Eminent domain requires that a taking be compensated at fair market value.

Comment Re:sounds like a distraction (Score 1) 70

If it's a toss-up between a de-facto Chinese takeover or a de-facto Israeli takeover, then the question is not what the resignation is trying to distract from, the question is why a vital strategic manufacturer is being taken over by a foreign power at all.

(Obviously, there's good reasons for a foreign power to want to have absolute leverage over how US businesses work. Whether those foreign powers are "hostile" or "benign" is irrelevant there and so of absolutely no consequence to the discussion. What matters is that the US should not place critical industries, on which essentially all other parts of their economy have become utterly dependent, in the hands of anyone not subject to US scrutiny or US law. As it stands, I dislike how corporations work, boards have accountability to nobody outside themselves and majority shareholders - which are also usually themselves. That's not an effective system.)

Comment Well.... (Score 1) 158

I'd certainly investigate the entire corporation. If the guy is abusing his position of authority (which means that any "consent" given is a fiction) and the employees actively support this, then there's a good chance that the behaviour is rampant in the company.

There is, however, a flip-side. He's undoubtedly led the company to produce some superb products and has pushed them in a well-identified direction. Far more so than virtually any other US corporation. There's very obviously something about his personality and mindset that is actually wanted to have a successful business, and this something is lacking within much of the western business community.

Basically, much of the western world is stuck in Harvard MBA Land, and companies operating under such principles invariably collapse from complete incompetence. They're popular because those with MBAs are usually brash, arrogant, controlling, dominant, and abusive - typical sociopathic traits - and sociopaths in the boardroom tend to be very good at producing stable management structures and very high stock returns. Just not successful busineses. But who cares, if you get rich?

This does not mean we need more sex offenders or Chinese spies running US megacorps. It means we need to find out exactly what in his attitude allowed him to identify successful patterns, we have no reason to want or desire any other aspects of the guy.

Comment Re:But Elon! (Score 1) 80

Even if SpaceX's peak launch rate of 3 per day is sustainable, a single data center would still take well over two decades to build.

Don't forget to account for attrition -- satellites are known to stop working and/or decay out of orbit over time. In the worst case, SpaceX could start losing satellites faster than they can replace them. But even in the "everything went exactly as planned" case, having an orbiting array of ten-to-twenty-year-old GPUs is probably not going to be the money-making asset people imagine it to be; it would be like trying to selling CPU time on a network of Pentium 4's today.

But realistically, you're more likely to see data centers in space powered by nuclear power than solar power, assuming politics allows that to happen.

What's the benefit of launching a nuclear-powered data center into space, over just leaving it on the ground and running it there?

Slashdot Top Deals

DEC diagnostics would run on a dead whale. -- Mel Ferentz

Working...