Comment Ok sure (Score 1) 23
Certainly appreciate the history of these two in the industry but Romero was canned, what, like 30 years ago because of ego issues? He obviously didn't care about the places legacy that much. Both of them are ego monsters tbh so they really must be soaking in folks asking them for their opinions here.
Carmack also didn't have to sell to Zenimax in the first place and if they were in need of an acquisition to survive then it would have been him making those layoffs instead. He also apparently made the call that Bethesda couldn't use id's engines for Elder Scrolls or Fallout, probably a mistake in the long term i think driven by ego as id had just as much if not more success as a tool develop than a game developer. And then he goes to work for Facebook of all places and threw his lot 100% with Zuck and Palmer Luckey. A talented programmer but obviously suspect judgement. He got his money.
There's a Ship Of Theseus question with game studios, once you've replaced all the key members is it still the same besides the name?