Comment Re:Who thought this was a good idea? (Score 2, Funny) 47
Who thought this was a good idea?
Well, pretty sure the cops thought it was a great idea.
Who thought this was a good idea?
Well, pretty sure the cops thought it was a great idea.
WTH are you trying to say? OP said, "They will likely still listen to and record everything." That doesn't state anything about ex-filtrating that data. So if the processing now has an option to be done locally, that means it's doing it one way or the other, does it not?
No, it doesn't mean they are going it "one way or another". This is an feature you can turn on or off in powertoys. And since it's open source, you can audit it yourself if you have doubts.
We're already aware of troves of data that does get sent to them, and I suspect you've heard of MS Recall?
You mean the MS Recall that processes data 100% on device and doesn't send any of it to Microsoft? Now I have to ask WTF are you trying to say?
If they can justify regularly saving full screenshots, then could easily justify saving a transcript of all the audio they record.
You just making shit up to strawman now?
Going back to this
That doesn't state anything about ex-filtrating that data.
The last line of OP's post is to a article titled "New Research: AI Is Already the #1 Data Exfiltration Channel in the Enterprise". So yea, I think they were implying data exfil even with local AI processing in the powertoy application (you know the thing we are actually talking about here).
They will likely still listen to and record everything. The main difference is that you pay the power used. But now you have the illusion of the data staying on your device. Nice!
Powertoys, Microsoft Foundry Local, and Ollama are all open source, so show us the code where they are 'still listening to and record [sic] everything':
https://github.com/microsoft/P...
https://github.com/ollama/olla...
https://github.com/microsoft/F...
See also: https://thehackernews.com/2025...
That is exactly the issue this is solving for.
This.
My take on vibe coding is simple: Don't.
At least not the way most people understand it. I'm totally ok with having an AI do the tedious work. But only do it on stuff you could do yourself (i.e. you're just saving time). Because otherwise, you'll never be able to maintain it.
This, in general, is the whole problem: The entire "vibe coding" movement only worries about CREATING code. But in the real world, maintaining, updating, refactoring, reviewing, testing, bugfixing, etc. etc. are typically more effort than writing it in the first place.
So you disable all the tracking and that's cool and all but a lot of businesses use that tracking to decide whether or not you're committing fraud or not. So you use Firefox and they can't track you but then they won't let you make purchases on their website...
I use Firefox daily and have for several years now and I have never, once, run into this issue.
Been a while since I've flown a budget airline. On the normal flights I've taken, there's always a few people (usually older people) with paper boarding passes.
The closest to perfection a person ever comes is when he fills out a job application form. -- Stanley J. Randall