I'm having a Sheldon moment; I thought you were serious. Mr. Poe is bitch-slapping me again, I guess, since there are so many here that actually believe that bullshit (or troll effectively). So I'm going to pretend you're serious even though I know you're not.
We'll be the first to tell you that "past performance is no guarantee of future success."
True, but past lack of performance is a solid indication of future failure.
The GP said "Utilities should be public, and not operated for profit." I half agree with that, based on my own experience of living in Springfield (yes, we have an Alderman named Gail Simpson). CWLP is owned and operated by the city. We have the lowest rates, the best uptime, and the best customer service in the state. And yes, CWLP turns a profit which helps keep taxes down (they sell power to other power companies as well as residents and businesses).
In 2006 two almost EF3 tornadoes tore through springfield, completely destroying much of the south end and east side's infrastructure. There wasn't a single utility pole left standing in my neighborhood. You could still see the scars the tornado left years later. A couple of months after our tornadoes, one hit the St Louis area. I visited my friend who lived on the east side of the river, who had been without power for a month. His lack of electricity was the only indication that there had ever been a tornado.
If you're on Amerin or other private company and your rates are high and customer service sucks and the power goes out every time it rains, tough shit, buddy. It's not like you can go down the street to the competitor. You have no power over its CEO whatever; he's beholden to the stockholders, not you. OTOH if my service degrades or my prices go up, the Mayor will lose the next election -- it's happened several times before.