Slashdot Log In
Bill Gates & his 12 Steps
from the Truth-&-Hype dept.
It takes a certain amount of shamelessness to be a monomaniac billionaire dwarf. But even by Bill Gates' standards, excerpts from his new book Business - The Speed of Thought, gracing this week's Time magazine, set new records for gall.
Bill Gates, you may remember, hasn't had a good year. Business Week described one competitor, open source operating system Linux, as Microsoft's "Vietnam." 3Com has snatched the bulk of the handheld computer market right out from under Microsoft's nose. Apple's new open source operating system OSX is on the way. Sony is coming after Microsoft with new operating systems that run personal computing and consumer electronics. And then there's the trial, so far at least, powerful reinforcement of the notion that just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not out to get you.
When Gates appeared as a witness in the Microsoft trial he was shockingly arrogant, and - to put it as generously as possible - forgetful. Meanwhile, complaints about MS software bugs have hit record levels on MS bug websites, and IBM's middleware software is taking off. A number of state attorneys general are licking their chops over expected settlements in the Microsoft anti-trust trial, which the company's leading execs are skewered weekly and reminded what they wrote in e-mails months and years earlier. Beyond that, Microsoft's insanely hyped new media properties - the online magazine Slate, MSN.com, and local Sidewalk entertainment and information sities - are all still struggling, all still losing vast sums of money.
Is Bill Gates chastened? Humbled? Don't be silly. He's written yet another vapid tome, the banal sequel to the much-hyped "The Road Ahead," his first best-seller, which accomplished something few authors could have achieved - making the future of the Internet so boring as to be unreadable. By and large, the press treated that book as if it were the Koran, personally delivered by the Prophet himself. Again, the mainstream media are slobbering over their favorite Millenial visionary. In this sequel, does Gates have a single word to about the many challenges facing his company, and his multiple mis-steps of l998? For that matter, does Time ask him? Don't be foolish. In his new book, gushes Time in its cover story, "Microsoft's chairman says that only managers who master the digital universe will gain competitive advantage."
Duh. This is how Gates made billions?
"To function in the digital age," writes Gates the author, "we have developed a new digital infrastructure. The successful companies of the next decade will be those that use digital tools, he continues. And to make "digital information flow an intrinsic part of your company," he offers a number of key steps.
If you're planning on reading this book and getting rich off of computers, go gamble on some e-stock instead, or play your local lottery. You'll do better. Gates' "Steps" are true yawners, either so obvious as to be useless, or full of the kind of incomprehensible cyber-jabberwocky news organizations like Time drool over. Like "Insist that communication flow through e-mail"; "Study Sales Data Online to Share Insights Easily"; and "Use Digital Communication To Redefine the Boundaries." (My personal favorite is: "Transform Every Business Process Into Just-In-Time Delivery." Everybody must realize, Gates cautions, that "if you don't meet customer demands quickly enough, without sacrificing quality, a competitor will.) Talk about vision.
And those are the best and most provocative ideas. It's hard to know which is dumber, Gates "steps" or Time's incomprehensible decision to air them on its cover.
Clearly, the Gates comeback is underway, the manipulable media ready for one more go at presenting this remarkably unremarkable man as a millenial wizard, and for the second, or is it the third, time? Modern media has no memory when it comes to fawning over the rich and powerful, and falling for hype is sure no vice in that business.
Imagine what Gates's true steps might be if we didn't live in so hype-heavy and world and if journalism told the truth. They might go something like this:
l. Destroy Competitors.
2. Discourage competition.
3. Be arrogant and evasive, even under oath and before a federal judge (this isn't really a new idea).
4. Build a digital castle for hundreds of millions of dollars and stuff it with Leonardo DaVinci's sketchpads, Napoleon's trinkets and other memorabilia. Make it so awe-inspiring that visiting journalists are dazzled and cowed forget to ask any tough questions, and continue to bally hoo even your dubious accomplishments.
5. Refuse to answer questions, anyway, except in carefully selected and protected environments - book excerpts, pre-arranged and carefully screened interviews.
6. Create unnecessary software and hype it beyond all reason, forcing hundreds of thousands of helpless and unknowing people to spend millions or even billions of dollars unnecessarily. Then charge them extra for "incident" help when they call up trying to get help they deserve for the products they bought.
7. Seek to dominate an entire culture.
8. Amass tens of billions of dollars, even though you could give ever poor kid in America his or her own computer without evening touching your capital. Give some money to charity, but require most of the recipients - libraries, for instance -- to buy more of your products to use the free stuff they get.
9. Be obnoxious, surly and arrogant.
10. Be sure to make friends with important people in media and have them over to your house. jonkatz@slashdot.org
- Stating FACTS by Anonymous Coward (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:40PM
- Don't respond to this either by Gleef (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:19AM
- Re: word was bought and so is powerpoint by Gleef (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:25AM
- Re: What has BGates done? by Gleef (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:51AM
- Hey! by Gleef (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:54AM
- This by Gleef (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @05:47AM
- Published by Warner Books by Aaron M. Renn (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:56AM
- Did any of you actually READ this? by Chris Johnson (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @01:41AM
- Stating FACTS by Trepidity (Score:1) Friday March 19 1999, @03:46PM
- Bravo -- Vitriol is becoming more impt than truth by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:00PM
- The Road Ahead? by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:04PM
- "Insist that communication flow through e-mail" by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:06PM
- Read Mr. Kaczynski's New book instead and learn... by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @03:05PM
- cynics win by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:57PM
- Haha, sweet! Nice work by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @06:18PM
- Hitler...created volkwagon! by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:07PM
- Not really by gavinhall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:08PM
- The road ahead ... by gavinhall (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @02:21AM
- Do you have any idea of what a cretin you are? by gavinhall (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @05:44AM
- Who is Bob? by jacrawf (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:45AM
- Very Deceptive, Shane by DunbarTheInept (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @05:41PM
- The Edsel. by Eccles (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:17AM
- No Subject Given by Eccles (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:41AM
- Yadda Yadda by Da Unicorn (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:07AM
- It's not really propoganda if it's true... by Danse (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:11AM
- You misinterpret what I said... by Danse (Score:1) Friday March 19 1999, @08:08AM
- Re: What has BGates done? - not much by demon (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @07:04AM
- Bad day ... by Aubrey (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:01AM
- Here is a link to the OTHER article .. by Aubrey (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:24AM
- Did any of you actually READ this? by soren.harward (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @09:26AM
- Did any of you actually READ this? by soren.harward (Score:2) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:41PM
- 11 & 12. by ninjaz (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:51AM
- Media? What about industry? by heroine (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @02:11PM
- Retraction... by robin (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:30PM
- Hitler...created volkwagon! by Scott Wood (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @05:01AM
- Hmmmm.... by Derek (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:03AM
- Try selling the Edsel in the 90's... by Dirac (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @05:35PM
- Stock price =/= reality by dilger (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:29AM
- Bad year by jd (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:55AM
- He was right, I'm afraid by stephend (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @02:37AM
- Did any of you actually READ this? by Foaf (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @06:48PM
- How Intellectual Revolutions are Lost by Blakes 7 (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:05AM
- You're eating right out of his hand by Brian Kendig (Score:2) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:53AM
- Come on... by Millennium (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:56PM
- slashdot to come by HBK-4G (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @05:58PM
- come on, people by hazard (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:09AM
- I like having Microsoft around by ciurana (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:15PM
- Wrong by ciurana (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @08:43PM
- Jon Katz AND Microsoft bashing?!?!?!?! by Old Fart! (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:16PM
- Bad year by Shimmer (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:49AM
- Even better... by ploeg (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:26PM
- Who is Bob? by Black Art (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:56AM
- Re: heaven forbid... by Sinner (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:08AM
- stunning by hany (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:43PM
- killer bill strikes again by Lurking Grue (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:36AM
- GODWIN'S LAW!! GODWIN'S LAW!!! by HipPriest (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:02PM
- Wrong there, slick... by HipPriest (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:15PM
- Bravo -- Vitriol is becoming more impt than truth by hawkeye (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @09:11PM
- Oh well. by Dastardly (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:49PM
- Business idea to annoy Microsoft by Dastardly (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:08PM
- Sidewalk by fugue (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:57AM
- Waldenbooks is going to love this one! by Eric Wayte (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:09AM
- SHUT UP, JON KATZ HATERS! by Anarchofascist (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:30PM
- And guess who bit? by David Gould (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:16PM
- no! its AOLS! by datazone (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @06:05PM
- Who is Bob? by drig (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:33AM
- Name one thing by Darchmare (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @11:35PM
- He is, I swear! by Darchmare (Score:1) Friday March 19 1999, @12:12AM
- Preaching to the choir, but good! by edgy (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:58PM
- Hitler...created volkwagon! by kachina (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @07:13AM
- I think your comments say more about your own... by shanelenagh (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:59AM
- Cool! I started a flamewar! by shanelenagh (Score:1) Monday March 22 1999, @07:05AM
- Who shout's loudest is correct !!!!!!!! by siva06 (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:44AM
- 12 Steps... by Mr Z (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:50AM
- Agreed (Katz flames Gates for being a poor writer) by L. Ron McKenzie (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:03PM
- Katz's article was a flame. by L. Ron McKenzie (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:07PM
- Microsoft's 12 Steps by Mike Cornall (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:50PM
- How Intellectual Revolutions are Lost by mcelrath (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:49AM
- I think YOU double clicked on the submit button... by Chase (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:10PM
- Business@ the Speed of Drool- 3/15/99 by Pasty Drone (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:50AM
- Bill's Luck - Wrong QDos by Donat (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @07:53PM
- Bill's Luck - Wrong QDos by Donat (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @08:00PM
- Name one thing - the movie by ch-chuck (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @07:40AM
- flames galore.. why? Becayse... by Pudding Yeti (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:39PM
- Sidewalk by banky (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:19AM
- Jon, good essay, enjoyed it by blocked (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:45PM
- Vitriol? Hmmm. by blocked (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:54PM
- But the next article tears Gates to shreds :) by makohund (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:57AM
- Retraction... by makohund (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:08AM
- I agree. by Dast (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:21AM
- Gates' shortcomings by Chris Lindsay (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @11:49AM
- IntelliActiveDirectBookX? by Dr.Dubious DDQ (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:22PM
- Bill Gates - b*o*r*i*n*g by Ymerej (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @05:11PM
- Hitler...created volkwagon! by moorewr (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:03PM
- What has BGates done (Software purchase history)? by vovin (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:12AM
- Bill G's 12 Step Program by RichN (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:25AM
- Drudge Report talks about this by Zonker Harris (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:13PM
- He is, I swear! by Mr.P (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:08PM
- Name one thing by meme (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @10:51AM
- How BG made his billions by Hos (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:52AM
- Oh well. by jerodd (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:03AM
- Postus scriptum. by jerodd (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:08AM
- Need a web hosting service by jerodd (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:10AM
- Katz is getting smart! by OldBen (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @06:45AM
- Microsoft's 12 Steps by SalsaDoom (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @09:20PM
- Yikes, Bill Gates the marketroid by phred (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:15PM
- Sidewalk by kaisyain (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:06AM
- NOBODY excpects the Spanish EXTRADITION (Pinochet) by grittkmg (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @01:32AM
- Bad year by Eivind (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @12:20AM
- Seems to make sense by Visoblast (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:48AM
- The Road Ahead? by SoftwareJanitor (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:17AM
- He is, I swear! by SoftwareJanitor (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:45AM
- Stating FACTS by starman (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:13PM
- Yes really by Jeld (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @04:59AM
- Name one thing by Jeld (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @05:07AM
- What has BGates done? by Anonymous Shepherd (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @02:45PM
- Bugs by Winkey (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:42PM
- How Intellectual Revolutions are Lost by Tardigrade (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:48AM
- You forgot the URL to the article. by Mike McCune (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @03:56PM
- Go on, Have a go... by Courval (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:38PM
- It's Volkswagen (with E) you illiterate by MS (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @12:51AM
- Now I see why people want to customize Slashdot... by Corndog (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:23PM
- Don't respond to this either by Praxxus (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:52AM
- Stating FACTS. Where are YOURS? by nyet (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:21PM
- How Intellectual Revolutions are Lost by Saint Stephen (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:38AM
- Billy does have a point by Black Parrot (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:30PM
- Actually, Jon, Gates has a damn good idea here by Black Parrot (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:39PM
- It's Microsoft's Internet! We just live in it... by Mike A. (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @01:49PM
- He is, I swear! by Z (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:14PM
- Does that make Windows. . . . . by Salgak1 (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @02:46AM
- Gates on book: not again by A.S.M. (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:16AM
- Who is Bob? by Vulpine (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @04:36PM
- realkiwi's rules by realkiwi (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @09:52PM
- Way to go Jon, good job! by dieMSdie (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:54AM
- M$ employee alert! by DannyB (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:50AM
- Paper vs. Electronic Accounting by ChrisGoodwin (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:00AM
- Stating FACTS by hs2534 (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @03:05AM
- Hitler...created volkwagon! by mwood (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @02:40AM
- ignoring by sklib (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:42AM
- Bill G's 12 Step Program by meersan (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:01AM
- Re: "The word is math" by tragedy (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:47AM
- Luck? by tragedy (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @02:04PM
- Actually, I think it was his mother. by tragedy (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @02:06PM
- Not really fair. by tragedy (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @02:10PM
- The Edsel. by tragedy (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @02:24PM
- Drivel about drivel about drivel by jet_silver (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:54AM
- Who is Bob? by coaxial (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @12:55PM
- Hitler...created volkwagon! by AlefNull (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @06:21AM
- Microsoft Visual C++ by BeanThere (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @12:32PM
- Me too by BeanThere (Score:1) Friday March 19 1999, @11:43AM
- So how is this different from Katz' past articles? by BeanThere (Score:1) Friday March 19 1999, @11:53AM
- Troll-o-meter: 7 by BeanThere (Score:1) Friday March 19 1999, @12:36PM
- The road ahead, or the road behind? by GoodDood (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @05:17AM
- The Road Ahead? by Spatch (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @07:11AM
- The Book wasn't aimed at you, John by MrNixon (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @02:35PM
- Gates on book: not again by Roadmaster (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @10:58AM
- I think time would be interested to know... by mikol (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @12:40AM
- Some people just do what they know best... by RCwyvern (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:37AM
- It isn't so bad by tubs (Score:1) Wednesday March 17 1999, @11:04AM
- I think your comments say more about your own... by An Observer (Score:1) Thursday March 18 1999, @01:55PM
- 131 replies beneath your current threshold.