Comment Couldn’t buy Arm, so hire its brain? (Score 2) 27
Quick history refresher: Nvidia tried to buy Arm for ~$40B back in 2020. The FTC sued 4-0 to stop it in Dec 2021, the UK and EU had their own investigations going, and Nvidia gave up in Feb 2022. SoftBank even got to keep the $1.25B Nvidia had already paid. So not technically "denied", but it sure wasn't going to happen.
The FTC's big complaint wasn't Nvidia owning the IP. It was Nvidia getting a look at all the confidential roadmap stuff that Qualcomm, Apple, Samsung, etc. hand over to Arm because Arm is supposed to be a figurative Switzerland. Guess who knows all of that? Sure, Haas has an NDA and a non-compete, but you can't NDA what's in a guy's head. Can't buy the company, so hire its brain? Same trick as the $20B Groq "license and hire" acqui-hire deal the DOJ is already poking at.
This is why I care about open ISAs. I like the Arm ISA, really I do, but it's a product one company rents out. Arm tried to make Qualcomm destroy the Nuvia core designs (and lost). And look at Apple: the userspace is plain AArch64, but everything around it is undocumented Apple-only weirdness. Custom interrupt controller, custom boot chain, secret GPU. Asahi has to reverse-engineer every new chip, and M3 support only just landed this month, still with no GPU acceleration. That's the kind of lock-in an architecture license lets you build.
RISC-V and Power are royalty-free, and there's no single company to buy, sue or headhunt. Until Arm is in that category, I'm backing RISC-V or Power ISAs and I'm staying on x86-64 ISA until one of those two open ISAs takes off. x86-64 isn't an open standard on paper, but the baseline (x86-64-v1) AMD Athlon 64 patents have expired, and x86 has 40+ years of inertia and a long line of non-Intel implementations behind it: Cyrix, Transmeta, VIA, Zhaoxin. Compaq clean-rooming the IBM BIOS is why the PC platform is open in the first place. Used x86-64 servers are a dime a dozen on eBay, and I can scrounge a working CPU pretty much anywhere on the planet, even on an island like Hawaii, without anybody's permission or a working supply chain.