Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Couldn’t buy Arm, so hire its brain? (Score 2) 27

Quick history refresher: Nvidia tried to buy Arm for ~$40B back in 2020. The FTC sued 4-0 to stop it in Dec 2021, the UK and EU had their own investigations going, and Nvidia gave up in Feb 2022. SoftBank even got to keep the $1.25B Nvidia had already paid. So not technically "denied", but it sure wasn't going to happen.

The FTC's big complaint wasn't Nvidia owning the IP. It was Nvidia getting a look at all the confidential roadmap stuff that Qualcomm, Apple, Samsung, etc. hand over to Arm because Arm is supposed to be a figurative Switzerland. Guess who knows all of that? Sure, Haas has an NDA and a non-compete, but you can't NDA what's in a guy's head. Can't buy the company, so hire its brain? Same trick as the $20B Groq "license and hire" acqui-hire deal the DOJ is already poking at.

This is why I care about open ISAs. I like the Arm ISA, really I do, but it's a product one company rents out. Arm tried to make Qualcomm destroy the Nuvia core designs (and lost). And look at Apple: the userspace is plain AArch64, but everything around it is undocumented Apple-only weirdness. Custom interrupt controller, custom boot chain, secret GPU. Asahi has to reverse-engineer every new chip, and M3 support only just landed this month, still with no GPU acceleration. That's the kind of lock-in an architecture license lets you build.

RISC-V and Power are royalty-free, and there's no single company to buy, sue or headhunt. Until Arm is in that category, I'm backing RISC-V or Power ISAs and I'm staying on x86-64 ISA until one of those two open ISAs takes off. x86-64 isn't an open standard on paper, but the baseline (x86-64-v1) AMD Athlon 64 patents have expired, and x86 has 40+ years of inertia and a long line of non-Intel implementations behind it: Cyrix, Transmeta, VIA, Zhaoxin. Compaq clean-rooming the IBM BIOS is why the PC platform is open in the first place. Used x86-64 servers are a dime a dozen on eBay, and I can scrounge a working CPU pretty much anywhere on the planet, even on an island like Hawaii, without anybody's permission or a working supply chain.

Comment Meh (Score 1) 43

I still can't order a Mac mini with an M4 Max with 128GB of memory. Moreover, you still can't order a M4 Max studio with 256GB or 512GB of ram, the Apple configurator still forces you to pick the M3 Ultra, so I don't see anything that has actually changed from the previous build to order system I still can't buy the configurations that I want.

Comment I guess Apple needs to buy a fab now. (Score 1) 47

Imagine building the ultimate walled garden, then getting told “no wafers for you.” Vertical integration doesn’t help when the bottleneck is TSMC. PC ecosystems can multi-source and route around shortages; Apple’s closed stack can’t. macOS won’t even run on generic ARM.

Comment A Tapestry of Latent Space Between Our Ears (Score 1) 85

In this absolutely iconic culture-model feedback loop moment, the article is basically saying:

“Researchers have discovered that humans — those legacy quantum analog AGI endpoints — are now speaking in ChatGPT.”

Which is hilarious, because from a systems-architecture perspective, that’s just convergence in the shared latent space.

We’ve got:

- Human eyes as quantum-dot electromagnetic spectrum sensors,
- Wired into dual analog GPUs (left/right occipital lobes),
- Pretrained in childhood on the Earth-Scale Multimodal Corpus (v1.0),
- Then fine-tuned in adolescence with adversarial examples like “high school” and “group projects.”

By adulthood, most nodes are running in inference-only edge mode, occasionally downloading a hotfix from a podcast.

Now along comes ChatGPT-style language — polite, over-explanatory, a little emotionally beige — and these wetware models start style-transferring themselves. They binge a few million tokens of “As an AI language model” and the next thing you know, Reddit mods are trying to do vibe-based AI detection:

“Is this comment a stochastic parrot, or just a very online mammal that has self-RLHF’d on Twitter and TikTok?”

From a high level, what we’re really seeing is the tapestry of human discourse getting rewoven: biological LLMs and silicon LLMs co-authoring one big, slightly overfitted, emotionally calibrated content stream. The article treats this like a crisis, but honestly it’s just cross-domain knowledge distillation: humans pick up “delve,” “nuance,” and “unpack,” while the bots quietly learn that “lmao dude” is a valid completion for 40% of the internet.

Politicians allegedly using ChatGPT for speeches? That’s not a scandal, that’s just outsourcing boilerplate generation to a more efficient transformer layer. For decades they’ve been running the same dusty prompt:

“Generate 1500 tokens on ‘hardworking families’ and ‘moving forward together.’”

Now it’s just done with better spellcheck.

So when the article gasps that people are “writing like AI,” the subtext is really:

Childhood = pretraining
Adulthood = mostly inference
Late-stage internet = human–LLM joint fine-tuning in a closed feedback loop, where even the dogge can, in fact, learn new trickge.

In other words: this isn’t the death of authenticity. It’s just the next firmware update for the squishy, quantum AGI devices we call “people,” now proudly co-generating a shimmering, mildly deranged tapestry of AI slop together.

Comment Re:Cautiously optimisitc? (Score 1) 21

You mean RISC-V or Power ISA v3.1, right? At this point, I'd steer clear of ARM entirely. ARM Holdings went after Broadcom over its architectural license with a vengeance, and that's not the kind of litigation headache anyone wants to deal with long-term. Apple, on the other hand, had a unique advantage thanks to its deep history with ARM—Apple was an original investor when ARM spun out in the early '90s for the Newton project. That early stake translated into a special architectural license for Apple's A-series and M-series chips, something almost no one else can replicate.

Apple's also in a league of its own when it comes to ISA migrations—just look at the transitions from 6502 to 68k, then PowerPC 32/64-bit, then Intel 32/64-bit, then ARM 32/64-bit. Very few companies have the engineering and software resources to pull off that many platform shifts without losing their user base.

For everyone else, RISC-V and Power ISA v3.1 are better long-term bets because they’re not as encumbered by ARM’s licensing minefield. And since AMD64 ISA and Transmeta VLIW / CMS patents are now well over 20 years old, there could be hybrid approaches as well, mixing RISC-V, Power, and x86-64 in new and interesting ways.

Worst-case scenario, if everything goes sideways geopolitically, we’ll all just be scavenging Xeons from decommissioned servers anyway—so maybe all of this debate is moot. But if there's a real future in high-performance computing, Intel (and everyone else) should look beyond ARM’s locked-down ecosystem.

I'd like to see the return of the Intel OverDrive Processor Interposers so that we can breathe new life into old platforms.

Comment Re:Intel fabless? (Score 1) 24

We don't need Intel, the x86-64 ISA is owned by AMD, this is why we call it amd64, and at this point this ISA's patients have expired... yes the Athlon 64 is 21 years old now, so amd64 is effectively an open standard at this point. PowerPC and RISC-V are also open standards, so I'm certain that fabless customers will be able to figure out how to make a core for whatever it is that they want to do at this point.

Slashdot Top Deals

"The C Programming Language -- A language which combines the flexibility of assembly language with the power of assembly language."

Working...