Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:If true... (Score 1) 96

Did the comments look LLM generated to you ;)

Do you even know what peer review is? Do you think LLMs do peer review?

Also, this statement is a trap. Whichever whatever reviews I pick, for whatever AI-solved math problem, you're just going to say, "Oh, that's cherry picked, you just skipped all the garbage solutions and cherry-picked favourable results!"

But what the hell, why not bite and just pick one. Here is a review of mathematicians connected to the Erdos unit distance conjecture commenting on the ChatGPT disproof of it (sections 3-11). Let's start here.

Comment Re:If true... (Score 1) 96

You are replying to:

but advancing the diversity of mathematical approaches that can be applied to study of NS offers future potential for solving more meaningful NS problems

Nobody is saying that this specific problem is going to lead to direct applications (just like solving RH). But approaches to solving problems have the potential to build off of each other to help solve related problems, and it turns out that "related NS problems" are really important..

Comment Re:If true... (Score 5, Interesting) 96

RH is massive within mathematics, but calling NS "niche"... sorry, but in the real world, NS matters much more. Pretty much every major engineering firm on Earth has computers running NS simulations. Anything that advances NS brings us closer to (or outright directly achieves) things with direct real-world impacts (in this case, the former - proving blow-up doesn't directly have real-world impacts, but advancing the diversity of mathematical approaches that can be applied to study of NS offers future potential for solving more meaningful NS problems - turbulence closure, the vanishing-viscosity limit and boundary layer separation, mapping the edge states around the laminar/turbulent flow regime, long-duration flow regime predictability, the chaotic-adjoint problem, fluid structure interaction and multiphase flows, rigorous guarantees for hybrid AI / reduced order solvers, etc).

Comment Re:If true... (Score 5, Interesting) 96

"A brute force Lean search" - automated proof solvers have a pretty poor record. There are some proofs from that, but broadly, it hasn't yielded much fruit; the space of formal mathematical steps is astronomically large. "A brute force lean search" is usually not a very effective means to solve difficult unsolved proofs that have evaded mathematicians for much of a century. To solve these problems, you need a combination of two things: a lot of time (your "brute force" is not irrelevant), but also broad cross-domain knowledge and excellent high-level reasoning. Brute force alone isn't enough.

The proofs that AI has been creating, overwhelmingly, haven't been hideous monstrosities stitched together from preexisting work on given problems by brute-forcing the gaps in Lean; it's generally deeply novel, innovative approaches to the problems.

Comment Re:If true... (Score 4, Interesting) 96

That "same guy getting scooped by OpenAI on Navier-Stokes" thing was so much nonsense. OpenAI had no real competitors. They had already solved the forced options C & D for Navier-Stokes, and before them, the unforced Euler problem as a simpler problem before trying Navier-Stokes. Buckmaster was still trying to reach unforced Euler after the forced one. He couldn't have provided a solution because he didn't have it. Buckmaster himself claimed that he was "essentially ... a few days away from" unforced Euler (not Navier-Stokes), which is at best post-hoc rationalizing. And when he finally released, he used an entirely different, less generalizable approach. OpenAI didn't use his forced Euler method. They didn't use his coordinate system. He didn't use their deep variational tools. Buckmaster used axisymmetric flow with swirl; OpenAI’s was non-axisymmetric. And most importantly, OpenAI’s unforced Euler paper proves blowup for compactly supported smooth initial data over all of R3; Buckmaster only does so for periodic data on the 3D torus T3. And OpenAI had been beyond generous - they had offered to put Buckmaster as an author on their paper, which he was not involved in; they only balked at offering the same to Alpoge, as Alpöge worked at Anthropic (contrary to the David vs. Goliath story Buckmaster tried to spin, he was working with the latest unreleased Anthropic models for his work, via Alpöge). OpenAI was shocked to find out how little Buckmaster actually had - they had started their sprint based in rumours that someone working with Anthropic (which turned out to be Buckmaster and Alpöge) was close to solving Navier-Stokes, and they wanted to get there first.

I find it so funny that every time an AI solves a major math problem that nobody has solved for much of a century, there's always people waiting in the woodwork to go, "Oh, hey, I was JUST about to solve that long-unsolved problem!" As if the entire mathematical community had sat around twiddling its thumbs for much of a century but only a year or so ago decided to get its arse into gear.

Comment Re:Shifting expectations (Score 1) 44

The Turing Test has long been considered highly defective. It also doesn't mean "a person thinks the computer is alive". It means "the person thinks what they're talking to isn't a computer".

If you wrote a program to write out random clusters of adjacent letters, and had people try to guess whether they were talking to a computer or a cat walking on a keyboard, a lot of them would guess wrongly that they were seeing a cat walking on a keyboard. That doesn't mean that any of them think computers are cats, that there's some simulated cat brain running in software - every one of them, on being told that it was a program, will assume "the program just writes random adjacent letters".

The Turing Test and the supposed "ELIZA Effect" are not the same thing. The ELIZA effect argues that humans, encountering chatbot, assumes that the bot has intelligence or other human traits when they don't.. The reality is that humans almost always assume that chatbots are elaborate tricks - even if they enjoy playing with them. It's like attending a magic show - people enjoy engaging in the illusion of the magic, but almost nobody thinks that the magician is actually engaging in real sorcery, regardless of how real it looks. It's "Huh, I can't figure out what trick was used to create that effect, that's amazingly well done!", not "There is no logical explanation, so this person is a literal sorcerer."

If you're looking for a real psychological effect related to AI, look to the AI effect.

Comment Re:This was a hit job to kill opensource models (Score 4, Insightful) 65

Sure Alice was not a Chinese intelligence agent. But she definitely was and is a chip smuggler. Her entire business is buying up NVidia hardware, establishing data centers in third countries, and then selling access to the big Chinese AI companies. Everyone knows this. In fact Singapore (where she is based) was so concerned about this that they began to investigate her. However the Americans at the highest levels refused to have anything to do with it, even while they were publicly saying they had forbid Nvidia from selling their advanced hardware directly to Chinese companies. There's no way Alice can do her business without some connection to the CCP. So she may not be a "spy," but she certainly is a Chinese asset. There's no one in the American intelligence community that doubts that, which is why Rubio sent the memo to the Administration about that. It seems pretty clear that top Trump officials and Jensen himself actively colluded to sell to the Chinese. Probably because selling to the Chinese provides Nvidia with real money, unlike the circular financing stuff that is happening in AI companies here in the west.

Meanwhile Trump claims he knows nothing about any of this. Which could be true given his rapid decline. Either way his professed ignorance is bizarre and worrisome.

Comment Re:What? Donald Trump raised taxes to pay the rich (Score 5, Insightful) 100

Sure. 50% of Americans don't pay income taxes because their income is too low. But tariffs do place a huge burden on the poorest Americans, who do pay them, and it ends up being a far higher percentage of their income than for the upper middle class. Trump gave them a bone. That's all. Now these refunds being given to the CEOs is just a poke in the eye of people that are already struggling daily.

Slashdot Top Deals

I cannot believe that God plays dice with the cosmos. -- Albert Einstein, on the randomness of quantum mechanics

Working...