Comment Re:Yes (Score 1) 264
This exactly. I still hate The Old Man and The Sea because of this obsession with over-analysis. Nobody wanted to hear my theory about Hemmingway being an alcoholic who wrote boring books with extremely thin plots because his brain was soaked in the previously-mentioned alcohol(and key lime pie). I was 17 so of course I wasn't into subtext but the teach could have at least *tried* to convince me it existed instead of just presupposing it was there and acting like all of the other silent students in the class agreed with him...(No, I'm fine, things from nearly thirty years ago don't bother me.. at all. Why do you ask?)
As far as the article is concerned, 20 pages was a short except in many of my college classes and that much reading was assigned for essentially every class on a weekly basis. (And it was *super* obvious that I was the only student even attempting to do the reading in most of my classes[2010 timeframe]).