Few things in life are clear when you get into the weeds of a subject. This is why real experts and professors are so hesitant and undecided while blowhards are so confident... sadly the majority of people in the USA judge leadership and competence by how confidently a person presents... maybe chatbots will change this perception if they keep up their overconfidence?
My experience is that productivity gains overall are more harmful that people realize because it's long term, usually more in-depth or complex to spot, and unpleasant which is demotivating or optimism bias blocks out the effort/consideration. It's also easy to cherry pick outside things such as going outside of the job losses into other jobs created; such as, creation of IT dept. and staff going up while other jobs disappear or change/stop growing. Sure, you can do more because it is now viable - should you choose to do so and generally that produces more gains than reducing staff. It doesn't always result in productive gains-- eventually, years later when that extra labor is ruled out as non-productive the connection is not made as staffing goes down; especially, when staffing stays the same but does not grow proportionally because it's a soft staff reduction by limiting staffing growth.
The whole mentality of today's business is to reduce jobs; capitalists never are job creators, they begrudgingly are forced to create jobs by necessity only and their goal is to eliminate top overhead costs to compete. The larger role in society of providing gainful employment is hardly even contemplated from the look of it. This is where regulations are necessary to set the rules of the game to constrain the fire that drives the engine. It'll burn everything it can and is very useful, if not necessary and will find every way to keep burning - we fear too much about burning out and not getting started again. To be safe, it has to be strongly contained and respected for it's danger not worshiped like a pagan god (which it is in the USA, for generations now as the #1 true religion -- Trump reflects the deeper "soul" of the nation, the world is seeing this.)