Comment Re:Disingenuous (Score 1) 51
If AI is truly eliminating jobs, and keeping them eliminated, there is only one possible reason why: AI is delivering value.
If this is not true, nobody has anything to worry about: everyone who invests in it will go broke and things will get back to normal. This does not seem likely at this point, however.
Technology that delivers value is a good thing. It has always been resisted (sometimes violently) by the displaced workers. But this isn't because the technology was bad, its because those workers were staring down hard times. Striking out against the tech was something they could easily do (whereas, actually reskilling and finding other jobs may not have been viable, and may have involved taking a step down into a lower social class, or starving to death on the street, depending on the details). But, striking against the tech didn't work. And will never work. If the tech delivers real value, too many powerful people will embrace it for any public protesting to stop it.
I am not saying it is ok to just throw people out into the cold, en masse. I am not saying that there won't be repercussions. I am saying that the rise of technology is inevitable, and the protests are futile.
Everyone who hates capitalism (of which there are many who post on this site) should rejoice at this. The one and only way humanity will ever achieve communism is by having an automated labor force that does all the dirty work. Until we have that, every attempt will go the exact same way every other historical attempt has ever gone. We simply cannot, and will never, "escape" capitalism until we have true labor automation. Every step on that road will be painful. That doesn't make the tech evil.
Everyone who loves capitalism (of which there are many who post on this set) should rejoice too. Capitalism is good because competition is the great optimizer, right? Not because it guarantees jobs for people who have outdated skillsets. This is just another link in the chain of progress that capitalism has brought us. All we need to do is find the right way to adapt to the new tech (which may include shuffling around a few laws if necessary). Once we are well positioned to really capitalize on AI, there will be a lot of wealth created and the wheels of industry will continue to turn.
If we want to protest, let's protest the local harmful impacts of those data centers and push the surprising costs right back on the companies that own them. And for sure lets protest against use of AI in decision making that could unfairly harm people impacted by those decisions. This sort of thing is already happening, and should continue. Protesting "AI" and spinning wild narratives about how it will doom the world is just silly.
Whatever surprises AI brings, we will adapt to them.