Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:lock out, tag out (Score 1) 56

This is the whole point of Lock Out, Tag Out safety procedures. You lock it out and put an out of service sign on it. Pretty straight forward.

It seems like you didn't understand what happened here remotely. The system failed in operation not during maintenance. The analyser system sent an alert email (stupid design) which didn't get through. At no point was a person involved, and at no point was there maintenance or equipment out of service.

Comment Re:The buck stops there (Score 1) 56

Who would set up an automation where the failure mode leads to uncontrolled addition of a toxic material?

My friend you have a lot to learn about industry. The world is full of such systems and there is no recourse for it. There are just reductions in probability of a failure mode occurring. For fun look to international standards for safety instrumented systems such as IEC61508 or IEC61511, and note that in application of these standards you almost universally assume that automation systems would be an initiating cause for a potential event 1 in 10 years and you use that as a basis for determining your risk profile.

But the first part of your statement is very much true. The issue here though isn't the failure itself, that is a given and was correctly identified as a possibility. The problem is whoever decided the mitigation was to send an email needs to be smacked in the head with a chair. One of the golden rules of mitigations for potential toxic threats is to inform potential victims *LOCALLY*. Same reason a fire alarm goes off in your building rather than simply sending an email down to reception.

Anyway bed time. Tomorrow I'm spending the rest of the week at a chemical plant where we get to review precisely these scenarios: automation system failure leading to hazardous events. Even small projects will identify hundreds of cases where automation failure would lead to toxic release, explosions, implosions, fires, etc.

Comment Re:reminds me of a power grid "black start" (Score 1) 35

Isolation isn't the problem. The grid can be isolated automatically and remotely down to very fine individual components. The problem is the co-ordination. It's not one company starting up or shutting down their equipment. It's an effort involving detailed planning and steps involving many companies both on the supply and the demand side of the equation, each of which can have their own localised issues to deal with (e.g. generator not synchronising properly).

You did touch on the biggest problem though bringing it back up slowly. Bringing the grid up is actually quite easy. There's simple steps to follow. The problem is each step takes a long time and needs to be carefully communicated and most steps have critical hold points that have to be met before the process can continue.

Comment Re:Bad design (Score 1) 56

If the system knows there is an issue, especially with a toxic chemical, why in Thor's name was it not set up to enable an automatic shutdown? Bad design ... very bad design.

You're confusing control and safety. It was almost certain there were different systems responsible for dosing and determining if something is safe, and in this case *both* failed. One overdosed, the other (was really shitty designed) failed to send an email.

The system that dosed didn't know there was an issue. The system that detected an overdose knew there was an issue but like every *mitigation* measure it can't unfuck that which has been fucked up.

That's the fundamental problem with mitigation systems. They don't prevent an incident, they mitigate the negative effects of it. Smoke detectors can't prevent a fire from starting. Gas detectors can't prevent a leak from occurring. An active shooter siren doesn't prevent a person holding a gun. These systems come in after the fact. By the time an email gets sent you will almost certainly be looking at a chlorine analyser with many minutes of deadtime detecting a spike in chlorine levels from something that occurred many minutes earlier. Shutdown doesn't make it safe.

That said it still very much is bad design that it relied on email instead of say a siren.

Comment Re:Attention seeking (Score 1) 71

Christ, I don't know what's the worst part of this response.

Dropping a snarky sci-fi reference, once a slashdot staple, somehow is "confusing fact and fiction"; the Reddit-tier levels of "confidently wrong" (others already pointed out that it got a whole trilogy); or the smug didacticism?

Looking at our User Ids, we've both been on this site long enough that we'll both be worm food long before The Singularity/The Rise of the Machines anyway. Relax.

Comment Re:I've been warning about this for years (Score 1) 25

And you haven't stated the problem with long links.

I literally did and you didn't re...

Sure, you might want a short link if you are displaying it in a medium where someone will have to be forced to type it in

Wait you did read it, so WTF are you talking about.

Though, you can also offer it as a QR code

URL shorteners predate wide spread QR code use by a decade.

Other times you may encounter a long link, but that's being sent through some electronic or digital medium so it doesn't really matter in the end since the user will just be able to click on it.

Sure it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things. But it still is a usability nightmare to read text only to be greeted with literally hundreds of characters of gibberish. The obvious answer to that is to truncate the link visually like Slashdot does. But that is endpoint dependent.

I mean, I give a Google Maps link to a friend.

I give Google Maps links to my enemies. To my friends I hit the "share" button which generates a... URL shortened link so their phone message history doesn't fill up with a page of gibberish.

Comment Re:Not a network security guy but... (Score 1) 98

ATC used to hand off aircraft without being on the Internet just a generation ago, and it worked.

Firstly, none of this is "the internet". Not every network outside your home magically is "the internet". The FTI is effectively a private telecoms network.

Secondly, this upgrade is about obsolete infrastructure, not about a change in process, change in handoffs or change in flight movements (which are actually down since 2000).

Comment Re:Actual cause: PRD maintenance during the day (Score 2) 98

That's just not true. Air traffic differs wildly day and night. Just because there's still planes in the air doesn't mean it's not quiet and that the impact is significant reduced if something goes wrong.

Here's a video timelapse globally, watch how flights vary day vs night: https://www.youtube.com/watch?...

Also the Friday part is significant not because of traffic, but because of support. You want people focused on work, not on what they are going to do on the weekend.

Comment Re:"Middle-of-nowhere Arkansas" (Score 1) 98

Jesus, first people complain about Akansas being a flyover state that never gets any attention compared to the big cities, and now when they finally get the limelight you call people bigots. Pick a lane.

Jokes aside, on what basis do you suggest it would have been excusable in NYC? No where in the test of the summary is such a thing suggested. As for why it is interesting that this was caused by something in the middle of nowhere, it's fascinating from a technical level to hear from a far flung piece of gear in the backwards of the country to be able to cause such an impact. On the other hand with the concentration of critical infrastructure in major cities, you sort of expect it NYC.

Now, calm down, no one here is a bigot, but someone here does seem to be a triggered snowflake.

Comment Re:The router wasn't the problem, project 2025 was (Score 2) 98

Did they not budget for a test network in a lab for the ATC system?

No. Seriously we're talking about comparatively ancient systems spanning the nation. Test networks are borderline infeasible when you consider the network design and more importantly, ... the age of the equipment you need to consider in the test.

Comment Re:No. (Score 1) 88

Stop letting wealthy aholes get away with stuff that would send them to jail for treason because it was just a mistake.

Huang isn't in trouble for anything that would put anyone in jail. Breaching internal policy and not disclosing relationships is not a criminal issue, it's a company policy issue. And that's what he's been fired over.

If Jensen's assistant did the same thing the assistant would be fired, arrested, and charged with espionage.

No. You don't get charged with espionage because you dated a spy. You get charged with espionage for handing the spy critical information. At this point time will tell if this actually happened, but so far there's no reason to think if the assistant bonked Huang-2 that they'd be in jail.

Comment Re:Scum. (Score 3, Insightful) 88

1) It ceases to be private life when it exposes the work liability concerns which is why every major corporation has disclosure rules. The fact you think so strongly about this to put your words in all caps makes me wonder if you should be contacting the legal department of your own employer...

2) Yes people mess around at work. The lower down you go the less significant it is. Virtually all workplace flings aren't an issue so they are disclosed on a register and done. The higher up the chain you go the more the register is scrutinised. You getting your dick wet with the receptionist is no the same thing as a CEO bonking a VP.

But what you can really do is THINK:

Huang isn't in trouble because he slept around. He's in trouble because he didn't disclose it as corporate policy requires. Breach of policy is a death sentence to a CEO / senior manager as I displays a complete breakdown of corporate governance. THAT IS THE ISSUE.

Comment Re:Suggestion (Score 1) 83

It's expensive.

It's not. Throwing something into a ditch is orders of magnitude cheaper than recycling it. That is one of the problems we have with recycling and why it's so hard to scale it up.

Diverting something away from landfill makes environmental sense, but short of subsidies or other government regulation it absolutely does not make economic sense.

Slashdot Top Deals

Computers are not intelligent. They only think they are.

Working...