Ahhh right there's so many hotels with the same name and it really helps when you spell it correctly, I was looking at something different. And yet what you've linked to shows the same. You compared the Ritz in Chicago to the Como Shambahala. Even if you were right you were still not comparing apples to apples, regardless of how you try and walk back now.
Considering now you've linked a hotel it has come back at over double the price of the Ritz in Chicago. Yet unfortunately there's still no comparison, even above you've linked two different countries with two very different price points.
The closest you can get is the Ritz in Mandapa which actually is the same price, but the Ritz is far better connected, and given how fittings vary very wildly between locations, unless you've been to literally both these locations on the same island in the same price point I can only say your confidence in yourself is completely misplaced.
Again focus on places you've been, in comparable price points, in comparable cities with the same offering (e.g. central location, remote location, whatever you want, just comparable). And *then* you can judge whether one deserves a fake luxury moniker.