Comment Re:Why? Please, why? There are so many excellent . (Score 1) 93
What "excellent film adaptation" are you talking about? There's one old animated adaptation, and that's is. There's also a movie that bears the same title, but it's apparently a coincidence: nothing except the title and names of some of main characters matches, thus I don't see how it could be relevant to Tolkien's books.
The first thing about adapting a book is reading it at least once, and Peter Jackson skipped that step.