My original statement, just a statement without anything incendiary in it, has ignited a firestorm of profanity, personal insults and general anger. Because people disagree with me, their rage is somehow appropriate.
I have encountered much the same. I think on a previous thread I stated that I tried WFH, hated it and even though I was a solo contractor, paid for a desk in a co-working office so I could be out of the house and have other people to talk to, and that actually proved incredibly and let to me doing a startup
Exactly - And there is the interesting part. The typical angry response does not allow for any deviation from the idea that people who work from home are the most competent, most productive employees who will have the world beating a path to their door. And seem to believe this is universally true.
Certainly some people do work better alone. I've met a number of people who flounder if not supervised. I had a very talented employee once, who if you gave him a task, would say he was going to get a soda before starting, then spend a few hours flirting with some of the staff assistants, he fancied himself a modern Casanova, then come back hours later. He never met a deadline. I finished most of his work. Boss ended up calling me in to issue an order to me "do not finish his work", as they wanted him gone. Probably the supervisors of the staff assistants he was annoying. Irony of all that is I became the Prick in all this, the bastard that had some personality conflict with a top notch employee. Another employee had a side business, took him on as a full partner (the idiot) and this very talented but rudderless guy drove him out of business.
That's an extreme example of a person failing, but there are many lesser degrees of people needing supervision to function.
Another thing is despite what appears to be the norm on Slashdot, most people need a bit of actual humanity around them. Or perhaps most people are cowed into silence by their histrionics if some dares to disagree. But humans are by and large social creatures. Introversion is not the norm. Nothing wrong with introversion, but there seems to be a conscious effort to force on others these days.
Finally, a person who wants to slack off ie, a lazy person - will have a marked tendency to love WFH. Just sayin'!
Yo wouldn't believe (well hyperbole, obviously you would) the batshit insane things people here were saying to me, such as I'm a shit manager and a worthless employee who leans on other people's work and steals credit because what other possible reason could there be to be in work?
Yes, some people have the need to make shit up. One of the biggest things I see is the claimed incredible productivity gains that happen only in WFH. At work, if I need something, I go to the person, tell them what I need, in person, and they do it, hand it to me and it's all good. Then some want to only communicate via slack or text. Will they be there to answer? Will I be able to concisely communicate my need and get everything back in a much shorter time? That hasn't been my experience.
My "favorite example of this effect is a guy who claimed he only communicated via text, no phone calls after I offended him with voicemail. So I took a walk to his office, and noted he was standing outside, chatting with someone. I asked for a moment. I simply said "If I call via phone you will answer - if that is too much trouble for you I will pay you a personal visit, I will not be happy, and I will bring the director with me because that's who I am working with. And complex communications via text is a non-starter."
All for the crime of being a human with only very mild introversion (I like and need socialising, but too much is draining and I need quiet focus time too).
Might be something else going on. In my case, I once thought I was an introvert, but the wife called BS on it. She said "You are obviously in your element, networking, enjoying it, and people want to talk with you even if you are a little terse at times - I think they like that, and you definitely listen." What I thought was my weekly day off where I'd hop in the car to "recharge" was actually processing, which is similar, but marks more in-depth thinking than just avoiding people.
What you describe sounds a little like that.
But maybe it's this too:
Maybe it makes them feel better living in a world where competence is inversely proportional to ones place on the food chain.
And that outlook is holding them back.