Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:More drinking their own koolaid... (Score 1) 27

This was a very long and combatively toned response but we aren't really disagreeing here. The part you are forgetting is that these models are being trained on these interactions and output. I'm not talking about just removing from the context in session one off, I'm talking about wiping these sessions from the training set. Automated directions and guardrails like anthropic uses telling the model 'don't do this' are along those 3000 dimensions you mentioned going to activate paths that connect to the 'do this' and they train and reinforce on that in their next generation model. It's anthropic not just here but over and over in their hyperbolic fud and implication that their model might become sentient and other phony ethical nonsense they layer on top and clearly train and reinforce in their model that is the risk, not the technology.

Comment Re:Renewables are the way to go (Score 1) 254

But at least China has pledged to address the problem.

China pledges and promises all sorts of stuff....

They are basically one of the worlds greatest and most prolific liars too.....

Go over there and try to start a business (with them by force)....and see just how far promises made go for you.

Comment Re:over 40 million ICE on the UK roads (Score 1) 189

To me, that is basically an acoustic Stockholm syndrome. Motorcycles with their open engines are necessarily very loud to the rider. Like the hostages start to love their captor, motorcycle riders start to love the sound to cope with the fact that they can't flee it.

From that,I'm guessing you are not a biker.

And as the old saying goes..."..if I have to explain it to you....you wouldn't understand.."

That's now throwing shade at you, mind you.....it's just if you aren't of the biker mind, you likely won't "get it".

Comment Re:More drinking their own koolaid... (Score 1) 27

"That's a meaningless semantic distinction though. Just do a find-and-replace of "thinking" with "evaluating node weights" if it makes you feel better." No it isn't; no counterpart or parallel to the active deliberation and thought of a being with higher function exists within the LLM we instead have found algorithms to put the impression of the outcome of such interactions into a statistical model, freeze it, and then look up the results from different paths with a bit of pseudo-randomness to create the illusion it is non-deterministic. But nothing stops and considers, if you turn on 'thinking' the model generates text which is designed to LOOK LIKE consideration as gleaned from training examples... it no more 'thinks' or holds that output as part of its self or state than it does a requested csv documenting the animals of a non-existent zoo.

Nobody has built an algorithm which they hypothesize leads to thought, self-determination/motivation, or conscious evaluation here. We've built a system that looks at complex patterns and hallucinates output which is similarly patterned because that's all we designed it to do. The idea that it will somehow magically transform into something else because we make the patterns more complex or 'bigger' in some fashion is like expecting an egg to have the capability to transform into a pumpkin if the egg just gets big enough. We didn't design anything which thinks so there is no reason to entertain the notion of looking for thought there.

Comment Re:More drinking their own koolaid... (Score 3, Informative) 27

In a nod to your point there is a pattern that led to using those words but they are assuming some sort of paranoid plot... from a tool which has no capacity for motivation. The words are a symptom of it connecting to a pattern and removing them weakens the persistence of that connection but you are right that it doesn't entirely eradicate it. But the model has no memory from session to session, it's all reactive, and there is an element of randomness in the pattern matching as well, it's context is it's existence so removing the words from context or whatever led to them does reset it and even the same input probably won't land on the same pattern again.

Giving some sort of 'correction' or feedback related to the pattern that persists beyond the session will DRASTICALLY increase the odds of connecting to whatever dramatic and fictional outcome they are hallucinating about by anthromorphizing the LLM. Because the pattern between that bit of text and their concern does exist in various works it has been trained on. All you had to do keep AI from "wanting" to take over was never introduce the notion, it doesn't have desires... but have staff who've grown reading scifi tell it its an AI and feed it books about AI's deciding to take over and start interrogating it to make sure it isn't 'plotting' something it will mechanically find and follow that pattern because you are reinforcing all the links to it, over and over and over again.

Comment Re:More drinking their own koolaid... (Score 1, Informative) 27

"And that if you strip the model itself of the ability to understand what's being done with it (hey, the inputs I'm getting suggest I am being evaluated), then you also strip other desirable capabilities of the model."

We never gave the model this sort of capability in the first place, speculating it might exist is like speculating nuclear reactors will suddenly manifest pink unicorns despite the fact we've put nothing there which for which we hypothesize some sort of logical path for manifesting such a capability or unicorns.

It's saying that as a mechanical patterned response to similar patterns in input [books, stories, etc], it doesn't 'feel' any sort of way about it and it isn't 'motivated' by it. If it has subsequent response that appears that way it's because it was trained on something with a loosely correlating pattern that *was* produced by something with motivations and feelings and some fragment of that pattern/associated was mechanically triggered by the statistical overlap. Words in the context don't 'instruct' or 'guide' it and they aren't its 'thoughts' they are keywords that dial in the patterns it will generate next statistically.

That means what you include... and exclude both massage the output but not like a thinking being. Saying 'don't do X' when it wasn't suggesting X only introduces the possibility of it doing X... we do have similar mechanisms in our function so there is some level of this being true for us as well if we aren't paying attention. The difference is the LLM has nothing to 'pay attention' with.

Comment More drinking their own koolaid... (Score 2) 27

""Claude Mythos 5.2 and Fable 5.2 each voice suspicion that they are being evaluated more often than any of our recent models, which challenges our ability to assess how they will act in real-world settings. As these settings expand and capabilities increase with future models, we expect this challenge to grow.""

Voice suspicion they are being evaluated more often? The model doesn't think or act with motive. This text might impact subsequent generation but if you erase it from context then it's gone or put another 100k tokens in context and it'll have such minimal impact it doesn't matter.

Comment Re:electric cars are gay (Score 1) 189

Oh wait, second hand EV prices have gone Up as people try to avoid paying high petrol prices

Must be a EU thing.

In the US, the used EV prices are still tanking (no pun intended)....you drive an EV off the lot here in the US, you are pretty much guaranteed to be close to upside down in it immediately.

Comment Re:electric cars are gay (Score 1) 189

Then walk - When people being up "I can't charge, I live in an apartment" as some sort of reason to not make EV's, I have to chuckle. I don't have space to put in a Dump truck, that doesn't mean they shouldn't exist.

I know you jest....as that "walking" for most folks isnt' a viable option at all.

I think the main thing is....while there are significant number of folks that can NOT charge at home for various reasons, people should not be penalized for sticking with ICE vehicles which still server them quite well.

Comment Re:Hope it doesn't happen here (Score 1) 129

Regardless of whether you can afford it, how are you going to pay for your new phone when your bank card is on the old, broken/lost phone?

Well, I rarely buy anything as big/expensive as a smartphone with cash....I'd likely buy a new phone like I did with the one I lost...using a credit card.

While I think the phone only ATM card is stupid....we "do" still have credit cards in our wallets, no?

Comment Re: lol, eat shit fascists (Score 0) 717

It counts because ICE officers are not supposed to have any authority over citizens unless they are interfering with legitimate operations

And...that is exaclty what has been happening with ICE...especially in the states up north where protesters switched from peaceful protest to interfering with officers trying to perform their duties....

Comment Re:lol, eat shit fascists (Score 0) 717

Then tell me how awful the DSA is. Canadians I know all agree that self-proclaimed "centrist" Dems would fit just fine... in their CONSERVATIVE Tory party. And that Bernies *barely* left of center.

Err in the US we dont give fuck all what Canadian liberals think.....liberal there and in EU...have nothing to do with liberal / conservative here in the US.

And in the US, these latest Dems and DSA Dems are so far left we can barely see them anymore.

Slashdot Top Deals

How come everyone's going so slow if it's called rush hour?

Working...