Comcast has always done it that way. because it was cheaper then running fiber to everyone homes where they aruldy had the cable. the backend fiber the line to the home there old cable line. sense the runs are short they still can get fiber speed.
It's a bit more complicated than that. Sure, with cable and a well-maintained and designed distribution network, you can get pretty high speeds in the forward direction. But the higher bandwidth of fibre will still provide higher speeds to more customers. And the more subscribers on a trunk, the more obvious the difference becomes.
As for the backhaul, noise accumulation is a bitch even on a well-maintained plant. It gets worse when you consider leaky lines and unterminated ports on taps and splitters. Plus, if you're using old amps and filters where the diplex split between outbound and inbound is below 54MHz, then you have VERY limited bandwidth for return data. And correct me if I'm wrong: if any kind of handshaking needs to occur before the next incoming packet arrives intact, then the outbound speed limitations can lower the inbound data rate.
Also, fibre is petty much immune to signal ingress, whereas cable is very much NOT immune to it. Back in the day, bi-directional cable plants in even small-town hospitals were a pain to manage sometimes because of unterminated ports and lines. When you extend that to the neighbourhood level, and then go regional, things can get ugly really fast. Throw in water leakage and physical damage that can lower speed drastically without actually killing the connection, and you can have performance that varies radically over time and with weather conditions. And even the best-maintained, fattest coax can't support the data speeds that fibre can.
It would be great if someone could weigh in on the challenges of maintaining a fibre-based comms network, as I have no experience with it.