Comment Re: lol, eat shit fascists (Score 1) 717
I feel like there's a lot worth debating here so I'mma tackle it point by point. It gets longer towards the end, but I appreciate everyone bearing with me. Some of the later points deserve the most nuance. Either that or they are simply just the least abstract and most concrete concerns for me and the people around me, leading me to care about them the most, ha.
> Defunding the police
The slogans "defund the police" and "abolish the police" are both shorthand for completely changing how the police work so that rights are respected without zealous violence and qualified immunity. That'd be a good thing IMHO.
> but not the pronoun police and associated cultural weirdness
Golden Rule, IMO. Everything by default is straight, white, male etc. Being otherwise is not a something that is infectious. So "let them be" is what I think, and I honestly don't get why not.
> backed by the force of the state
Humans seem to be bad at risk assessment. I don't think that being told to occasionally "STFU", to quit with with -isms, and consequences such as workplace discipline are objectively the "forces" that people should be worried about. I think it's the type of force and violence that we've seen specifically under the Trump administration (and Nixon for that matter) that is much more of a risk, is antithetical to liberty, and harmful. Less so the forces and consequences associated with basically codifying the golden rule.
> to include mandatory anti-white, anti-male, and anti-straight preferences in contracting and hiring practices.
Consider looking at it this way: it's not anti- any of that because we (straight, white cis men) are incredibly disproportionately "on top" and have had all the opportunities and advantages handed to us and the practices being maligned are just meant to give the rest of folks the same/similar/equal opportunities. I'd hate to earn less, be treated less well, etc just because I was born into a certain religion, skin, color or gender. Frankly speaking, it seems to me that it's just fucking luck what everyone is born into (race, religion, gender) and not something that can be controlled. On the other head, working on (inadvertently) putting certain groups of people on pedestals and putting others down is something that something that we can shape. Why not do it?
> Mandatory electric cars.
For consideration: carrot and stick (incentives and disincentives) != forced/mandated adoption. In addition, consider that that less pollution is a net benefit for all. Furthermore, it seems obvious to me that when facing off against other car companies and other nations worldwide, going in the direction of electric cars is a competitive, positive economic and societally beneficial strategy when compared to pushing an outdated technology that has more negative side effects, is declining in popularity, and is less and less what people want.
Who would want to be the company--or the country with all the companies--making horse and buggy carriages while all the others have moved on to making automobiles. Bag-holding, anyone?
Not to mention, shooting ourselves in the foot. Just look at all the sales that countries and companies missed out on compared to the Chinese company BYD selling more electric cars in a month than the US/US car companies in an entire quarter. Yes, they have the advantages of more government subsidies and cheap labor, but ultimately, 'twas the short-sighted strategy of America--and the rest of the world--of offshoring everything to China that predictably lead to the Chinese companies being be able to make things themselves and (for the moment) blowing past the rest of the world. That was totally shooting ourselves in the foot. Granted, it was slow--over several decades since the early 70s--but it was still self-sabotage for corporations and countrymen alike.
> manndatory apartment blocks on previously single-family lots.
This, I actually agree with! My local area is pushing this and I don't like it. It bothers me on several levels. I think that perhaps, my number one concern is ownership. People should be able to own their own homes. The less rent taking, the better.
At the same time, single-family homes on large parcels of land are inefficient. So, perhaps how about condos instead of apartments? But even then, I think high density multifamily dwellings are frankly kind of--I don't know--sucky. But we don't have to go with high-rise apartments or high-rise condos, right? There's got to be a middle ground... For example, how about side-by-side units instead?
How about building units (single-family or side-by-side) in the size/shape/general style of the ones that I see all the time in my area that were built in the 50s, or like the others that I see all the time that were built in the late 60s/early 70s (or 80s even). A friend of mine bought a 2026 new construction home like that in a second or third ring suburb in Wisconsin for about 300 grand. That's possibly still a bit too much for a starter home, but that's a start...
> And all the other Biden day 1 EOs.
> There's not enough information for me to understand what is meant by that.