Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:To what degree is the statement wrong? (Score 1) 290

That statement is fine

That statement is not "fine". That statement follows a logical structure that may be correct, but there's nothing "fine" about a department responsible for preventing the spread of disease promotes an ideology by explicitly making a change that fuels vaccine hesitancy among the public.

There's a lot more to statements, such as human interpretation than simply logic would ... wait ... have you been screened for autism?

Comment Re:In my experience (Score 1) 56

Allowing them to be "agents" and do things on your behalf is problematic because they can get things wrong and then make things worse when they try to fix it.

This shows you have no idea what agents are. Agents act on your behalf *under you instruction*. No they aren't self-managing or judgement making. They are task completing. Ultimately an AI agent is akin to AI how a Macro is akin to an Excel formula. You create agents to do specific things with specific criteria. And they many orders of magnitude more useful than generic LLMs.

Comment Re:This seems evil - accepting tuition from them (Score 1) 237

You are accepting students and taking their money even though they won't pass.

Except that seems to be the opposite of what is being said in TFA which is that colleges are putting effort into bringing students up to spec so they *can* pass. Have you considered enrolling in a college? Maybe they'll make you take a basic English comprehension class to help you along.

Comment Re:College is not middle school (Score 1) 237

It isn't the college's job to teach anything other than college level courses.

This is so incredibly elitist and dumb it's amazing. No a college's job is to tech the subject. Whether they aid that by giving people the opportunity to have a head start is irrelevant. Simply blocking people out of an education because they came from a system that put them on the back foot leaves you with yet another elitist tiered system that promotes inequality.

Heck if colleges didn't provide non-college sources I would never have turned into an engineer. I didn't select the necessary pre-requisites in high-school. Having the ability to do highschool bridging courses in math, chemistry and physics allowed me to ultimately enrol in engineering, something your idea would have blocked me from despite the fact that I graduated top of my school for the subjects I did do.

But I guess fuck me because I wanted a career change.

Comment Re:Not only in the USA. (Score 1) 237

Every moron and his dog had to decide how math is taught except actual mathematicians.

While your post is generally on point, field experts are rarely the best placed to decide on how to actually teach their own subject. There's a follow on to the adage of "Those who can't do, teach", and that's that "Those who can do, typically make really horrible teachers."

Comment Re:Current LLM's (Score 1) 204

Current LLM's are like chatting with a chronic liar.

Cool story but that has nothing to do with TFA or TFS which is talking about Agentic AI.

That is AI in it's current form.

No, that's your mass media spoonfed knowledge of AI in its current form. Actual AI in its current form is fucking amazing for special purpose applications. Noise reduction, image processing, image generation, agents for comparing or mass execution of specific tasks, feeding historical operating data into neural nets to predict future outcomes, IT FUCKING DRIVES CARS, it's mind-blowingly amazing. You did such a great job starting by calling out LLMs specifically (even if that's not what this article is about), and then you threw it all away by generalising and calling it "AI in its current form.

Also LLMs are too amazing when you use them for something other than a random bullshit generator. They translate text in context better than any other tool every created, they underpin comparisons of documents, and because they are effectively a language processor they have the power to provide you, an end user, the ability to create a context based search for virtually anything.

Comment Re:Obvious answer (Score 1) 204

Exactly, and they expect you to hand over control of your life and everything wholesale.

Except that's a strange fantasy some people live in. Who said anything about control over your life, or wholesale? 99.9% of AI products out there are merely "assistants" and don't fundamentally control anything. More over precisely no one has created a product that does this wholesale.

I find it hilarious reading the comments here on this article in particular as agentic AI is actually *useful* among a cesspool of shit that is generic LLM bullshit. It's little more than the concept of Macros which can actually save a heap of work.

I'm a globally AI naysayer. Its' good only for generating stupid pictures. ... except for the few AI agents I've set up for my work. Despite the initial CoPilot agent training being a disaster.

Slashdot Top Deals

"And do you think (fop that I am) that I could be the Scarlet Pumpernickel?" -- Looney Tunes, The Scarlet Pumpernickel (1950, Chuck Jones)

Working...