Comment Re:The elephant in the room. (Score 1) 227
BLOCKQUOTE>but I think we need to argue what he said and not how he said it.
We should argue about both.
How he said it affects whether people even finish reading what he said.
I think he was trying to make complex points.
You can make complex points using paragraphs, rather than just stringing ideas together with commas till your readers can no longer follow your points.
In my case, I hit that sentence I quoted, and by the time I figured out what he was saying, I was no longer interested in continuing to read his comment.
So, even if his ideas were enough to revolutionize several sciences, they're not presented clearly enough that people will work their way through even the three paragraph summary.