Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:But is high speed rail a *good* public investme (Score 1) 419

I think the main argument against HS2 is simply that saving half an hour on a trip from London to Birmingham, or an hour from London to Manchester is far too marginal a benefit to justify the huge cost.

It's not as though people are suddenly going to start commuting from Greater Manchester to Central London every day.

England is really quite a small country, you don't need particularly fast trains, you just want them to be reliable.

Comment Re:Got you, Mrs. Sampson (Score 1) 80

I think it's interesting, judging from the responses here, how many people are still carrying around deep wounds from grade school and junior high. I may be wrong, but I would interpret this as meaning that the majority of responses are from people still at grade school and junior high.

Seriously, since I left university, I've hardly ever thought about anything or anyone at school.

Comment Re:Got you, Mrs. Sampson (Score 1) 80

Science Fiction authors who are also serious writers include (off the top of my head)Iain (M) Banks, Margaret Atwood, Christopher Priest, Ursula le Guin, China Mieville and many others.

The problem with SF is that some very successful authors are actually quite bad writers in terms of style, characterisation and plotting. For example, I wouldn't want to read a "straight" novel by Philip K Dick or Robert Heinlein.

Comment Re:What could possibly (Score 1) 316

Oh I would not be too sure of that. Just wait until some bright spark thinks to start a campaign to click the button to report an MP's speech as "extremist" and "radicalising". Someone more cynical than I might even suggest that this is part of the government's plan to deal with UKIP....

However unpleasant and stupid UKIP are, they're not a terrorist organisation.

Anyway, I thought the government's plan for dealing with UKIP was to copy their Xenophobic policies as far as possible, thereby making UKIP irrelevant, when you could get the same thing just as easily by voting for the tories, i.e. with Cameron sliminess instead of Farragean twattery.

Submission + - Kremlinpedia to the rescue! (bbc.com)

An anonymous reader writes: The BBC News reports Putin's Presidental Library will develop a russophile alternative for the global Wikipedia, in order to provide objective, reliable and highly detailed information about all aspects of the world's largest country and its political system. A collection of 50.000 books and documents has already been amassed to provide citable sources for the first round of articles.

One must wonder, however, if the Kremlin's Wikimedia collection shall include photography in their retouched or retouched state? (Because there have been so many attempts to focibly modify the russian past, noone knows any more what the negatives really looked like and whom of the Old Communists actually got to pose with Stalin, just to be edited away after the purges.)

Submission + - Obamacare Heading For Supreme Court As Video Evidence Of Deception Surfaces (washingtonpost.com)

An anonymous reader writes: Two key outside contributors to writing Obamacare were Center For American Progress President Neera Tanden, and MIT Professor Jonathan Gruber. Professor Gruber has just had his profile raised significantly by videos surfacing in which he admits to a strategy of deception to pass Obamacare. Charles Krauthammer writes in the Washington Post, "This October 2013 video shows MIT Professor Jonathan Gruber ... admitting that, in order to get it passed, the law was made deliberately obscure and deceptive. ... “Lack of transparency is a huge political advantage,” said Gruber. “Basically, call it the stupidity of the American voter or whatever, but basically that was really, really critical to getting the thing to pass.” ... the bill’s authors manipulated the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office ... “This bill was written in a tortured way to make sure CBO did not score the mandate as taxes.” ... “if CBO scored the mandate as taxes, the bill dies.” ... Last week, the Supreme Court agreed to hear a case claiming that the administration is violating its own health-care law, which clearly specifies that subsidies can be given only to insurance purchased on “exchanges established by the state.” Just 13 states have set up such exchanges. Yet the administration is giving tax credits to plans bought on the federal exchange ... If the plaintiffs prevail, the subsidy system collapses and ... Obamacare itself. ... Re-enter Professor Gruber. ... in a different speech, he explains what Obamacare intended ... The legislative idea was to coerce states into setting up their own exchanges by otherwise denying their citizens subsidies."

Comment Re:For the censors (Score 2) 340

In my opinion, the most obvious and interesting theory [maxkeiser.com] is that Putin's plane was near the same air space close to the same time as MH17 ...

Your sense of what is "obvious" might be a bit off.

Web evidence points to pro-Russia rebels in downing of MH17 (+video)

Igor Girkin, a Ukrainian separatist leader also known as Strelkov, claimed responsibility on a popular Russian social-networking site for the downing of what he thought was a Ukrainian military transport plane shortly before reports that Malaysian Airlines Flight MH17 had crashed near the rebel held Ukrainian city of Donetsk.

MH17 disaster: Social media posts, phone recording used to blame Russian separatists

Social media posts by pro-Russian insurgents - most of them hastily removed - suggest the rebels thought they had shot down a Ukrainian army plane before realising in horror that it was in fact a packed Malaysian airliner.

Ukraine and MH17: Who are the separatists?

On Thursday evening a Russian social media page linked to the rebels announced they had knocked down a Ukrainian An-26, adding, “We warned them – don’t fly ‘in our sky’”. The post – which was accompanied by distant video-shots of smoke rising after an apparent crash – was later removed, but it has stoked suspicions that pro-Russian militiamen shot the Malaysian Airlines jet by mistake.

The evidence that may prove pro-Russian separatists shot down MH17

Deadly Ukraine Crash: German Intelligence Claims Pro-Russian Separatists Downed MH17

Putin's plane was an hour away.

This could have been a simple, yet tragic, case of mistaken identity.

It was, but not as you apparently intend. It wasn't the Ukrainians trying to shoot down Putin and being mistaken but rather the "separatists" shooting at what they mistakenly assumed was a Ukrainian aircraft.

Comment Re:uh, no? (Score 1) 340

Because this is not a black and white issue?

The issue of which side of an international border the combat units of a nation's army are located is pretty black and white.

5 Billion dollars was dumped into the Euromaiden coffers prior to the "revolt" (Search "Soros spending on Euromaidan" and you can read reports).

Even if that ... "news" .... were available from a reputable source, George Soros isn't an arm of the US government.

Personally I dislike the West's method of imperialism. It's a round about method of invade and conquer without spending troops and bypasses the Constitution.

What do you think the Constitution has to say about any of that? You dislike assisting other countries in building democratic institutions?

What we have today is more reminiscent of the East India company. Executive orders for "war" and private funding has given mercenary powers to big business bypassing Constitutional requirements for declaration of war by Congress and the People.

Nonsense. What country has IBM or General Motors conquered and ruled? None.

Comment Re:uh, no? (Score 1) 340

Much of Europe gets energy supplies from Russia. Russia has threatened European energy supplies. Most of Europe is a member of NATO. Russia has been aggressively probing NATO airspace recently. Russian military aircraft have recently caused a number of near mid-air collisions in Europe due to ignoring civil aviation rules. Russia has threatened various NATO states with nuclear weapons.

It looks like pretty much all of Europe has a stake involving Russia in some way. Does that mean that the views of all Europeans are not worth listening to regarding Russia? Does that mean there can be no objective analysis of Russian conduct from other Europeans? Hardly.

I think your management school may have skipped some material.

Comment Re:uh, no? (Score 1) 340

I suppose it is too much for you to look at shades of meaning, especially in light of his previous stands in favor of Russia's invasion and annexation of Crimea. But both sides are "dishonest"? Who has troops in the other's country engaging in combat? It seems to me this muddying of the waters speaks to bias as well, his and yours.

Putin has troops in Ukraine trying to take territory from Ukraine, NATO doesn't. But if you think that "cablegate" is the equivalent, please do point out how? It seems to me that your "abhorrence" of Putin doesn't seem to go so far as to opposition to open aggression.

Crimea and Ukraine, where Russia has been sending troops, are not Russian soil whereas Texas is American soil for a very long time.

Comment Re:uh, no? (Score 0) 340

What you have frequently done over the last few years is attack me, engaging in name calling (shill, troll, as above) while making specious claims about logical fallacies in my arguments and simultaneously ignoring inconvenient facts. (example - read up the thread) I suppose that should be expected given that you lean towards "Truther"ism, 9/11 and otherwise.

If you simply follow the facts they may take you either away from or towards the position of "the establishment." You often seem to prefer anti-American establishment assertions rather than the actual facts. Strangely that doesn't carry over to the Russian government. Perhaps that is why you favor them so, they are antagonistic to the American government.

I can say with certainty that I have seen at least a dozen formulate the same opinion as myself.

His UID is 3,886,123. I guess that means if we take out you and your 11 like minded "peers" there are potentially 3,886,111 people potentially open to reason. I'm dubious that the number is actually that high, but there is always hope.

Slashdot Top Deals

"The one charm of marriage is that it makes a life of deception a neccessity." - Oscar Wilde

Working...