Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:HOWTO (Score 1) 1081

.. the definition of "punishment". One central requirement is that the person punished can learn something from it.

Thanks for sharing your definition. It is not what my dictionaries say, they are about it being a penalty, not a school lesson. Try this one as it's handy. How does prison fit into your definition? From what I've heard, not much learning takes place there that is not orthogonal to the issue of ethics.

You remind me of a corny schoolboy joke :-

Judge [to condemed burglar] ; "I hope you have learned from this my man!"
Burglar : "Yes m'Lord, I've learned not to get caught next time."

Comment Re:Your justice system is flawed, too. (Score 1) 1081

Mod parent up.

In a Machiavellian sense, he (some policital criminal) could be used, for example, as a figurehead to drum up support from the people who he was able to drum up support from before, in order to follow a political agenda ....... I could think of many dozens of ways he could himself cause trouble, and I can think of many more dozens of ways he could be symbolically used by someone else to cause trouble.

We saw that with IRA prisoners in the UK. Even in prison they continued to make waves, make news (such as hunger strikes), and even continue to administrate campaigns via the communications of visitors which the civil rights people insist on being allowed. OTOH, once someone is executed, the news media (and they are what matters) soon lose interest as long as there is no mystery about it - which is why assasination keeps someone "alive" in the public mind more than execution does.

Whichever side you are on (and this applies to "both" sides") these are just facts, in a Machiavellian sense.

Comment Re:HOWTO (Score 1) 1081

I'm sorry you're too simple minded to realize ...... how many innocents had their lives taken by it.

As the alternative to execution is life (or at least long) imprisonment, the "innocent" people are still going to be unjustly punished, have their "life" stolen from them. By your argument we must never punish anyone for anything, in case the verdict is wrong.

Comment Re: HOWTO (Score 1) 1081

You do realize that it costs significantly more money to see a death-penalty case from start to finish than it does to see a case where the penalty is life without parole? ...... There are many more appeals steps that are expensive through the legal system.

Only because the USA's lunatic legal system and the fact that lawyers are allowed to make perpetual work for themselves. These endless cycles of appeal are allowed even when it is bleedin' obvious that the guy is guilty - in fact they don't even claim that in many cases, instead claiming some bullshit excuse.

Not so long ago, the condemned were take straight out and hung, and the total cost was half-a-crown to the hangman. I would not advocate a return to that, but some common sense needs injecting here.

It costs twice as much to house a death-row inmate during the appeals .... Also putting a person in jail for life, without parole, means they are never "left to their own".

Why does it cost any more to house someone on death row than "in jail for life" ? Talking about the housing here, not the appeals nonsense.

Comment Re:OK, but... (Score 1) 89

Nazi Germany serves as a well-known historical example of how certain policies can have disastrous effects, .... the onus is on those who advocate for such policies to explain clearly what immutable safeguards will be in place to prevent such a state from occurring.

History shows that nothing ever occurs the same way twice. There are just too many factors (both random and non-random) involved. I think the onus is on those who advocate ANY policy to try to show that it will not go pear shaped. Just saying it is the opposite of what Hitler would have done is not good enough.

Comment Re:OK, but... (Score 1) 89

Hitler with his silly hair cut and ridiculous mustache

May I remind you that the mustache and haircut was pretty common in that time. ...... this particular style also was used by a plenty of people who did a lot of good.

What has "people who did a lot of good" have to do with it? The fact is that the style was quite common at the time. Charlie Chaplin had one. It was Hitler who made it go out of fashion (like the name "Adolf" too). Despite that there were plenty of old farts who still wore Chaplin-Hitler type mustaches in the 1950's and 60's. One of my schoolteachers did - we called him "Hitler".

Comment Re:State-funded Businesses (Score 1) 106

The BBC, a profoundly well-known tax-funded State organization

Not tax funded. It is funded by the TV licence fee, a different thing.

then shafted every other business in that home computing field by adding their name to the product and taking a cut of the profits ... thus decimating the choice of computers available to them by reducing competition by heavily favouring one particular computer.

What BS - sounds like you are airing a pet issue . Were you in the UK at that time? I was, and the BBC micro cetainly did not "shaft" every or any other business. Amstrad and Sinclair computers were much more popular. I only knew one person who bought a BBC micro, he was middle-aged and bought it second-hand. The BBC micros had the image of being geared to education and wee thus rather boring.

A quick visit to Wikipedia confirms that only 1.5 million BBCs were sold. Amstrad sold 3 million CPCs around that time and 8 million PCWs. Meanwhile Sinclair sold 5 million Spectrums.

These days, so many "respected" organisations sell their name to be attached to commercial products (my Alma Mater even rents its name to be put on credit cards) that surely people realise it means nothing anymore.

Comment What are the Specs? (Score 2) 106

FTFA :-

"The BBC does not see Micro Bit as a rival to ... Raspberry Pi, Arduino, Galileo and Kano, but rather hopes it will act as a "springboard" to these more complex machines ....it will be compatible with three coding languages - Touch Develop, Python and C++.

It has a C++ compiler but is not complex? Seriously, intoducing kids to coding using C++? Things like the RPi don't need a springboard to reach them anyway. All these things can be used as simple as you like or as complex as you like. What OS is this thing using anyway?

the BBC is being careful not to repeat the mistakes of the BBC Microcomputer launch, which angered rivals such as Sinclair

Why was "angering" Sinclair a "mistake"? He was just another micro manufacturer so was hardly to be expected to welcome a new rival. Couldn't they have told him to f#@k off?

the BBC is working with several partners, including chip-designer Arm, Microsoft and Samsung, to get the end product right.

Microsoft? Now they are angering me.

Comment Re:Well... are we surprised? (Score 1) 156

I don't think Apple is too worried about this, except if consumers are fooled into buying one. No one wants to show off a knock-off status symbol. It defeats the entire purpose.

But someone who buys a knock-off is not generally going to announce to people that it is a knock-off. So, if it looks the part, the knock-off is going to be just as effective as a staus symbol as the real thing.

Or just as ineffective. The very existence of the knock-offs defeats the status symbol, because even if you buy that $10,000 one, people are just going to assume that it is a knock-off.

I knew a woman who owned a really large diamond, worn in a necklace. When people saw it they would ask if it was real, and she would say "Of course not!". But it was real. Either she did not want to look super-vain, or did not want to risk it being stolen. I suppose she had it for self-gratification or as an investement, but as a status symbol it was pointless.

Comment Re:This is good (Score 1) 44

Microsoft are losing ground to Google, Amazon Web Services etc ... so they've decided a free course is the best way to get people using their product

Ah, the old .. market share = competence argument. I guess Linux is the single most worst desktop operating system ever built.

What did the GP statement have to do with competence? As for market share, then Rolls Royces and top-end BMWs must be the worse cars you can buy.

A teacher cannot be a billboard.

By that logic, nobody should be teaching mechanics how to repair a Subaru, cuz.. y know all mechanics should know how every single car works.

Yes, in principle they should. Car mechanics should be able, and do, move between different dealerships. They soon pick up the differences. (I have been a manager at one and have seen it.)

I know that universities and their courses have been debased in recent years, but it should not be a universitiy's place to be vendor specific. I did an engineering degree course without any vendor specific-ness whatsoever, including eg how gas turbines worked. We learned to do the fluid flow and thermodynamic calculations. Subsequently, in my job as a marine engineer, I was sent by my employer to a course at Rolls-Royce specifically on running and repairing Olympus gas tubines. It was meant mainly for skilled mechanics and was not what I would describe as university level stuff.

Comment Re:Laws of thermodynamics don't apply at GoodYear (Score 1) 221

many posts here assume that it's the heat of the tire that is being converted to electricity. In fact, it's the flexing of the tires that is being converted

That is not what TFA said :- The concept “BHO3” tire “offers the possibility” of helping recharge the batteries of electric cars by transforming heat from a rolling tire into electrical energy, Goodyear officials said

I'm not sure whether it will work effectively, but let's wait and see.

Save the wait; it won't.

Slashdot Top Deals

Living on Earth may be expensive, but it includes an annual free trip around the Sun.

Working...