Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Quick question (Score 1) 56

Radiation hardened hardware has shielding and larger components.

That depends on the degree of hardening. It is not black and white. You are never going to make it 100% impervious.

You simply can't harden chips like the RPi uses

You most certainly can. There are some simple fixes that can make a big difference.

Checksumming doesn't fix errors, it detects them.

Once you detect an error, you can often fix it. You can re-run a calculation, or reload a program from flash, or whatever.

Comment Re:Quick question (Score 2) 56

but these "AstroPI" are just using stock chips.

With current technology, it is common for even stock chips to have some rad-hard features. For instance, many ICs are manufactured with depleted boron as a semiconductor dopant and in the borophosphosilicate glass insulating layer. This can dramatically reduce the number of soft errors, and adds little to the cost, since depleted boron is not particularly expensive, and only small quantities are needed. It is also possible to fix some problems in software, by running periodic checksums on blocks of memory.

Comment Re:In other words, ... (Score 1) 307

... the way to address the diversity issue is to dumb everybody down?

I don't think that is what they are saying. I have kids in elementary school, and I volunteer to help out in class and in an after-school programming and robotics program. There are HUGE differences in ability between kids, and dumping them all into one class doesn't make much sense. A typical Chinese-American boy is going to be lightyears ahead of a typical Latino girl. If you direct instruction toward the smart kids, the dumb kids will be lost. If you focus on the dumb kids, the smart kids will be bored, and will ridicule the dumb kids. We ended up doing what Google suggests: We moved the smart kids to a separate classroom where they work on self-directed projects with adult intervention only when they get stuck, while the dumb kids work in a more traditional lecture style class. Nobody is excluded, and kids are segregated by ability, not ethnicity or gender.

Unfortunately, I have found that the dumb kids tend to stay dumb, while the smart kids leap even further ahead .... I don't have a solution for that.

Comment Re:Why do I care what Harrison Ford thinks? (Score 4, Funny) 299

I am capable of judging the finished product without having to take the word of someone who has achieved fame by some method other than judging movie scripts?

But why would Harrison Ford exaggerate the quality of the script? Sure, he has a stake in the financial success of the film, but nobody in Hollywood is going to prostitute their integrity just for the sake of money, and an occasional Oscar. I think you can just take his word for it.

Comment Re:Just in time. (Score 1, Informative) 219

Consumer disk drives cannot be substituted in while retaining the same level of reliability.

Thanks for your unsupported and unsubstantiated opinion. All the actual data says otherwise. If "enterprise" drives were actually more reliable, you would see them used in datacenters by companies like Google, Facebook, Yahoo, etc. But all of these companies use "consumer" drives in their datacenters. So does everyone else that believes data over marketing.

Comment Re:Just in time. (Score 1) 219

This probably has more to do with TLER than anything because consumer drives are designed with the expectation they'll be run as a single isolated disk whereas enterprise disks are typically expected to be part of some RAID array

Except that the referenced study shows that consumer drives are just as reliable as "enterprise" drives WHEN USED IN A DATACENTER. Nothing that you mention explains that.

Comment Re:Just in time. (Score 1) 219

but to segment the market HDD mfgrs put better electronics in SAS drives. better firmware too-.

I think this is BS. The marginal cost of "better electronics" is pennies. The marginal cost of "better firmware" is zero. So you are basically saying that manufacturers intentionally create defective products. In a competitive market (and the HDD market is very competitive) there is no reason they would do that.

If they actually did that, it would show up in reliability tests, rather than just in the totally made up MTBF figures printed on the box.

Also, they don't need to. They can just tell people that the enterprise drives are better, and plenty of idiots will believe them, in the face of contrary evidence, and even come up with conspiracy theories to justify their irrational choices. There is a sucker born every minute.

Comment Re:Just in time. (Score 5, Informative) 219

their enterprise drives are ok but I wouldn't touch them, these days, for consumer drives. no way!

There is no difference in reliability between "enterprise" and "consumer" drives. Those are purely marketing terms. The sole advantage of enterprise drives is a longer warranty. If you are bad at math, you might think that is a good deal.

Slashdot Top Deals

I cannot conceive that anybody will require multiplications at the rate of 40,000 or even 4,000 per hour ... -- F. H. Wales (1936)

Working...