Comment Re:Another wasted research project (Score 1) 588
Any science with a 6% to 85% chance of being accurate (not a margin of error, but chance of actually existing) doesn't sound very reliable to me. Genetics will have an effect on weight but simple physics can't really be ignored here - energy in, energy out. Someone that exercises a lot, using a lot of energy, and doesn't eat much isn't going to be overweight because there isn't any spare energy to convert into fat.
Conversely, someone that takes in a lot of high energy food and doesn't exercise will in all likelihood build up fat. I know it's a more complicated picture but at the end of the day energy is going into an overweight person's body and it's not being used.