I haven't abandoned Slashdot for Multiply. There's still too many things I prefer about Slashdot over Multiply. I've just been way too busy at home and at work to post much of anything. The latest is that my MIDI keyboard of 21 years finally died. So I had to get a new one, which wound up being the Yamaha MM6 over the weekend. It's pretty decent. Not a total replacement for the Ensoniq Mirage, but it will hold me over until I can afford something better. Since I was keyboardless for a week and a half I turned my eyes to (repost from Multiply follows): ..polishing up my Photoshop skills. In GIMP, of course. ;P
So I've gone back to learning more about layer masks and channels. I found a few Photoshop tutorials and it's apparent to me now that if you really know the underlying concepts, it's not hard at all to duplicate the same kind of work in GIMP for most of the basic stuff. Photoshop has changed a lot, so I know there are some things beyond the well known professional print support that it can do that GIMP can't do in quite the same way. But this isn't meant to be a GIMP vs. Photoshop post so enough with that.
What I'm asking any of you Photoshop users out there:
Q. How do you edit a photo to remove stray hairs without making the subject's head look weird?
I'm hoping you can fill in the A. part of this. After some experimentation last night and little perusing of Photoshop tutorials on-line, Here's what I did:
I followed one tutorial's suggestion to go to the channels and look at each one individually for the channel that has the most contrast between the fly away hairs and the background. Once you find it, you duplicate it. You use the levels and other color correction tools to adjust the contrast to get the edges as well defined as you want them Then the painstaking part is where you use a mix of the lasso, fill, paint and erase tools to basically create a "mask". Hard black for the subject and white for the areas you want to cut out. You might need to re-adjust levels several times after you paint in/out the areas you do or don't want. Once your have just the silhouette of your subject, you can set the channel copy to a selection, then use that selection to delete (or fill depending on your goal) a layer mask in the layers pallet. I'd recommend using the feather command to soften your selection otherwise you end up with nasty jaggies that make the cut out object look very amateurish. It "sorta worked" for me. But it's still not quite right. So I'm wondering if any of your Photoshop pros out there have any suggestions as to what you do. (I'm specifically avoiding any mask plug-ins since I'm in GIMP and there is no such animal! :)
Anyone else doing this kind of thing in GIMP? If not, WHY (outside of professional print needs)? It's completely possible.