Comment Re:Just stick to the mantra (Score 1) 106
No, that's what you get for anyone on your network running windows.
Not a problem on my home network. Besides, that's only if you actually set your system up so that Windows has access to the NAS box.
My friend lived in a low budget rental with 4 random roommates (former roommate was the thief,
That sounds like a good lesson in choosing your roommates more carefully, or better yet not having any (and certainly not 4).
For $100 + a few minutes every weekend doing incremental backups, I'll go the external harddisk over a NAS anyday. Though realistically I went for both a NAS and an external offsite backup.
Personally I prefer the external HD and incremental backups strategy too, but the downside with this compared to the NAS strategy is that you don't get automatic, regular backups: you have to be diligent in actually doing the backups, and you're only going to do them so often (once per week in your case), whereas with a NAS you can schedule them to be far more frequent, daily or even hourly.
I believe the other poster even suggested having two NAS boxes: one in active use doing hourly backups, and the other in off-site storage. Swap them out every month or week so your off-site is never that far behind, and then if something happens to your on-site systems you still have a fairly recent backup set. This is somewhat pricey, but seems like a robust strategy to me.