Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment AI advocacy (Score 1) 85

AI is integral to the world of computer science.

That's objectively bullshit. Take CS, subtract AI, and there's still about 99%+ of CS remaining. They are preaching for a change that they want, not describing something that has happened.

It makes me wonder if the members of this College Board happen to be personally invested in the proprietary AI service companies.

Comment Re:Anthropic PR (Score 1) 59

I'm not very up on this stuff, but I think(?) he's saying Hugging Face ("HF" in his comment) was considering writing a common API for various different kinds of hardware, to replace CUDA.

And that would be awesome, but also very threatening to Nvidia, which is probably part of why they bought Hugging Face: to kill such a project.

Comment Re:telemetry (Score 1) 57

You'd think that you'd make your healthcheck systems scale proportionately to the number of systems you've got last reporting active. That seems like a good thing to do.

Personally, I'm not sure this would result in the remaining systems getting healthchecked more often, though. How would that work?

Let's say: you've got 1m servers and (say) 24 healthcheck system. They each send out one service API probe every, oh, 15 seconds, for something on the severely high side of things, with a 3 second timeout. If you suddenly only have 500k servers due to a network partiation, this doesn't cause healthcheck to occur at 2x against the backend services. Infrastructure isn't built this way, because if it was, the healthcheck would be meaningless.

Very different than what the client would see on the service facing side. Even then, it's going to cause 2-3x load to all the systems due to 2x the traffic to each system (assuming it was an extremely homogenous system) and cause things to be slow, and you'd have seen a different failure mode.

Comment Re:Future tense [Re:FARA Foreign Agents Registrat. (Score 1) 76

I like to think the delay is justified by the fact that IF you think in terms of 1800s tech, America is huge and it can take a while for horses to pull a wagon from sea to shining sea.

It's November 1860 and you just won your election to be the new Senator from Oregon. You have two months to get to DC. Can you do it? (Yes, you can do it in a "mere" 3-4 weeks thanks to rail. But before rail? No way two months is enough.)

Comment Re:Things are going to get pretty messed up soon (Score 0) 44

The first thing will probably be to do something think of the children bullshit to ban local AI instances.

Are you seeing a lot of support for the "people should be forced to use a data center to run AIs, instead of being allowed to do it at home using solar power" position?

What I saw last week, is that "think of the children" means that no one should ever fucking ever let a Republican anywhere within ten feet of a child, rather than it meaning we need to give data centers a monopoly on running AI.

The RAM crisis is it. This is the high-water mark on suppressing competition. It was a clever move, but the consumer market isn't going to tolerate electronic gizmos and video games being expensive forever. As soon as someone decides they want money and opens another RAM factory, the AI companies are in trouble. They have this brief pre-Personal-Computer-Revolution situation going on like 1960s IBM, and the 1970s are coming to fuck their shit up.

Comment Re:"Physical Copy" is just a download (Score 1) 59

Sure there is: it gives you several days to download it on a shitty internet link so that on the day of release you're able to play it. Some people are stuck at 50Mbit or less internet speeds, particularly in rural or financially depressed urban areas. You're going to have people tethering their phone to download it.

Comment Re:Birds of a feather (Score 1) 98

I was expecting your linked article to talk about Huang going around hitting employees with sticks or something, given your characterization of "abusing" employees. Turns out that is not the case.

Huang now displays a "task-oriented" leadership style which places value on getting things done, setting ambitious goals, and monitoring performance, Rivkin said.

Horrendous! How can an employer just expect that employees perform?? Worse,

Workers at a high-profile company like Nvidia generally have other options but "they are choosing to remain for as long as they can," says Chaturvedi, which suggests Huang is doing something right.

All those poor abused working people must have Stockholm Syndrome to want to stay in such a terrible environment!

I don't know. Maybe it feels "abusive" to you when your boss judges your performance based on what you have accomplished, but many people actually appreciate that sort of environment and are able to work hard there to get ahead.

Now, cheating on your wife, OTOH, is definitely a very bad thing. Especially when it is with a foreign spy. Frankly, that level of poor judgement should probably cost him his job.

But it doesn't sound like he was abusing his employees.

Comment Re:Uhh (Score 1) 191

It was licensed MIT. They didn't make specific claims about mislicensing.

Other people were "stealing" their private (public) PRs before they went upstream, was the complaint I understood, and not contributing their work back - which was all perfectly acceptable with the MIT license. So they're trying to prevent that (perfectly acceptable under MIT) behavior.

They don't like it, so they're cutting off access to people using AI. Simple as.

Comment Uhh (Score 2) 191

"free real estate to pilfer and exploit"

Um... that is literally the purpose of Open Source. Every license allows this to one degree or another.

"exploit our permissive licensing"

Well, you picked the license.

"hijack our work"

Zir, that is what you said they could do. (The license.)

"In some extreme cases, in-development feature code was being lifted straight out of our personal forks"

So they did exactly what the license allowed, and you allowed, by making the repositories public?

"In case you did not know, Asahi Linux forbids AI generated code contribution"

Ah, so there we go, we found the reason, you're opposed to your work being "hijacked" by AI people who aren't actually writing the code, and profiting from doing so.

Let's just be honest what this is: you're making defensive efforts to avoid AI contributions. That's fine, but I have one question: when will you be changing out the Linux kernel for something else? Huge swaths of it have had AI contributions at this point.

The more I read this, the more I realize: are they really talking about Caldera Linux (fraudulent Linux copyright/ownership claims), which was entirely unrelated to the gripe he's got? I'm not sure what other events , unless they're talking about the license issues with ATT/BSD in the very early 90s? This is not alike any of that at all.

If they're misattributing or not giving license for code they've written, that's one thing - and that's a problem. It's not a problem that's going to go away by changing the license: clean room implementations are both fast, and easy. (IME, I can often produce better code overall with AI than the original).

The fact is, copyright protection has gotten very complicated with AI, and it's not going to get any easier. It's not going to go away, and to no small degree, it's made a lot of nuanced software licensing for open source irrelevant: the cost to re-implement is negligible, it's the ideas which are going to hold financial value.

If you're contributing hand-written code to an open source project, I appreciate that you'd want to do that as a hobby you enjoy. Go for it. But also don't be upset when people continue to do the same thing with newer tools.

Sadly, this largely sounds like farriers complaining about automobiles. Yes, shoeing horses is a real, valuable skill (one still needed). So is writing code. But it is no longer prestigious in and of itself, and is debatably as professionally useful as being able to solve sudoku.

Comment Re: Ooops (Score 0) 105

Other notable people who've done the exact same thing:

- Steve Jobs
- Barack Obama
- Zuckerberg
- Albert Einstein
- Tom Wolfe

There's a reason why it was common for men to spend a lot of money on 1-2 garments that would last them a year and were the same, every year, but women had a tendency to have more variety: changing your clothes is a vain distraction.

You probably do this to some degree, too. I personally only buy plain color undershirts and wear them with black dress shirts, the same jeans are on auto-order (it only took me a decade to find a brand/model that I like consistently), and sock preferences. Black tees for when it's just whatever, and black golf shirts for slightly nicer scenarios. I've been buying the same shoes and boots for 10+ years. (Do I wear other things on occasion? Yes. I'm not a billionaire who gets to run the room, I have to conform somewhat. I've got band shirts, etc. but I don't like having to decide every day.)

These are things you do as you find something you like that works for you, so you don't have to think about it again. Who wants to spend all that time shopping for clothes?

(On that note, there's a surprisingly large amount that you can get away with socially if you're well dressed.)

Comment Re:"possibly" - WTAF? (Score -1, Flamebait) 123

It means they are postulating something that's extremely biased in its findings and they've got no way to substantiate it, and it's likely easily refuted, but they're doing it anyway because they have an agenda.

Better look at the coal-powered Chinese monies that were used to fund the article.

Slashdot Top Deals

Competence, like truth, beauty, and contact lenses, is in the eye of the beholder. -- Dr. Laurence J. Peter

Working...